Will you really burn/cancel membership if MM comes?

maverick · Post: # 1144695Post **maverick** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:37pm

dragit wrote:I will burn down our new 12mil$ training facilitiesâ€¦

b.t.w. I hope everyone would be willing to wait ten years like the pies did, if he'd been cut when the Buckley deal went through we'd all think he is a washed up failure.

right place, right time.

Winston Churchill analogiesâ€¦ pftttâ€¦

At this point, I would wait ten years for a guarantee

maverick · Post: # 1144697Post **maverick** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:38pm

dragit wrote:I will burn down our new 12mil$ training facilitiesâ€¦

b.t.w. I hope everyone would be willing to wait ten years like the pies did, if he'd been cut when the Buckley deal went through we'd all think he is a washed up failure.

right place, right time.

Winston Churchill analogiesâ€¦ pftttâ€¦

At this point, I would wait ten years for a guarantee

Enrico_Misso · Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:40pm

bigred wrote:I dont like MM.

For various reasons.

Mister Magic seems a fairly affable chap to me.
But I'm not convinced he can coach.

maverick · Post: # 1144701Post **maverick** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:40pm

dragit wrote:I will burn down our new 12mil$ training facilitiesâ€¦

b.t.w. I hope everyone would be willing to wait ten years like the pies did, if he'd been cut when the Buckley deal went through we'd all think he is a washed up failure.

right place, right time.

Winston Churchill analogiesâ€¦ pftttâ€¦

At this point, I would wait ten years for a guarantee

St Lenny · Post: # 1144702Post **St Lenny** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:41pm

I survived Alex Jexalenko and all those delistings at that time. Mick Malthouse would be a piece of cake.

Enrico_Misso · Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:42pm

bigred wrote:I dont like MM.

For various reasons.

That said, I wouldnt mind a flag or two....or three.

meher baba · Mon 19 Sep 2011 1:47pm

bigcarl wrote:Nah. I'd take him just to spite Ross Lyon and Collingwood. Plus, despite his nasty nature, he can coach.

Hi bigcarl: I'm flattered that you are using a quote from me in your signature line, but I trust you realise it was a joke.

I personally believe Lyon was a good coach and performed his role well at our club. What has made me unusual on here (less so lately) is that I also strongly that GT was a good coach and was also good for our club.

dragit · Post: # 1144710Post **dragit** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:09pm

maverick wrote:
dragit wrote:I will burn down our new 12mil$ training facilitiesâ€¦

b.t.w. I hope everyone would be willing to wait ten years like the pies did, if he'd been cut when the Buckley deal went through we'd all think he is a washed up failure.

right place, right time.

Winston Churchill analogiesâ€¦ pftttâ€¦
At this point, I would wait ten years for a guarantee

If it was a guarantee, so would I, alasâ€¦

St Lenny · Post: # 1144715Post **St Lenny** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:16pm

I survived Alex Jexalenko and all those delistings at that time. Mick Malthouse would be a piece of cake.

bigcarl · Post: # 1144718Post **bigcarl** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:18pm

meher baba wrote:
bigcarl wrote:Nah. I'd take him just to spite Ross Lyon and Collingwood. Plus, despite his nasty nature, he can coach.
Hi bigcarl: I'm flattered that you are using a quote from me in your signature line, but I trust you realise it was a joke.

I personally believe Lyon was a good coach and performed his role well at our club. What has made me unusual on here (less so lately) is that I also strongly that GT was a good coach and was also good for our club.

Okay, I'll take your name off it but leave it up there. Didn't want to use it without a credit

dals_da_bomb · Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:18pm

im trying to follow all the hate for MM..
is it just for the milne saga?

come on people.. grow up! The guy has won premierships.. more then we have won in our history!

I dont mind either way. I think his got a proven record and it everyone else wants him and we can get him then why not?

Im not fussy.. i just want a coach and a cup.

Konstantinos · Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:34pm

dals_da_bomb wrote:im trying to follow all the hate for MM..
is it just for the milne saga?

come on people.. grow up! The guy has won premierships.. more then we have won in our history!

I dont mind either way. I think his got a proven record and it everyone else wants him and we can get him then why not?

Im not fussy.. i just want a coach and a cup.

I second this. And btw, I really like your avatar, although it's abit too big. hahahaha.

dragit · Post: # 1144740Post **dragit** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:35pm

Konstantinos wrote:
dals_da_bomb wrote:im trying to follow all the hate for MM..
is it just for the milne saga?

come on people.. grow up! The guy has won premierships.. more then we have won in our history!

I dont mind either way. I think his got a proven record and it everyone else wants him and we can get him then why not?

Im not fussy.. i just want a coach and a cup.
I second this. And btw, I really like your avatar, although it's abit too big. hahahaha.

reminds me of ross walking off the groundâ€¦

Con Gorozidis · Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:36pm

evertonfc wrote:Having former St Kilda defender Mick Malthouse come back to the club next year sounds like a pretty good deal to me.

agree. what kind of nuffies would be upset about it? ill bet you milney would even be pumped after a while.
id be air fist pumping.

desertsaint · Mon 19 Sep 2011 2:38pm

i've managed to put up with lyon coaching us for years. hard when you dislike a coach. but mick coaching us? aaargh - no doubt i'd grin and bear it, but my teeth may crack.

Eastern · Post: # 1144762Post **Eastern** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 3:02pm

HSVKing wrote:I'll buy 2 memberships.

People like you with too much money aren't counted

!!

matrix · Post: # 1144946Post **matrix** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 7:37pm

did someone say on melb radio this morn that its rumored we offered 2mill a year for 4 years??

coz that rumor made it all the way to sa

unreal
as f****** if
8 mill
we must be rolling in it

Dr Spaceman · Mon 19 Sep 2011 7:44pm

matrix wrote:did someone say on melb radio this morn that its rumored we offered 2mill a year for 4 years??

coz that rumor made it all the way to sa

unreal
as f****** if
8 mill
we must be rolling in it

If that rumour was true Moneybags would still be at Seaford!

matrix · Post: # 1144957Post **matrix** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 7:47pm

i know
amazing huh

2 mill a year ffs

sainter35 · Post: # 1145005Post **sainter35** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 8:39pm

Eastern wrote:
HSVKing wrote:I'll buy 2 memberships.
People like you with too much money aren't counted !!

Well I don't have much money but I'll make it 3!

I don't think MM coaching the club is a realistic proposition anyway but I'm staggered by the response in this thread.

I don't like him either but he's an exceptional coach. If he gave even the slightest indication that he was available our board would be crazy not to make a big play for him.

Milney is professional enough to sit down with him and sort out their differences. He's getting to the end of his career and wants a flag.

Talk of burning memberships and not renewing makes you lot sound like Richmond supporters by the way. We're better than that.

Leo.J · Post: # 1145014Post **Leo.J** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 8:47pm

No way.

Stephen Theodore · Mon 19 Sep 2011 8:53pm

Sorry to all the doomsayers out there, but if M.M. can lead us to our 2nd flag, I couldnt care less whats happened in the past.

Sneaking feeling if Milney was holding the premiership cup in his hand, he also couldnt care less.

noblejohn · Post: # 1145051Post **noblejohn** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 9:21pm

Hate him,despise him, detest him
But I love St.Kilda more
Stay on board

andrewg · Post: # 1145061Post **andrewg** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 9:38pm

I wold have a celebration beer. A good coach who will beat Freo next year!!!

joffaboy · Post: # 1145102Post **joffaboy** » Mon 19 Sep 2011 10:11pm

plugger66 wrote:
The Fireman wrote:How can you support someone you simply detest?
I'm in no hurry to become a hypocrite , the man is a dog of a person.
I support the Saints not the coach. I detested Brian Wilson when he came to our club. I wasnt going to throw in my membership though.

I agree.

I support the Saints not some deadbeat lying coach.

Couldn't care less about if MM coaches us.

Thought he was a see you next tuesday, for years, will still thinks so except he will be a see you next tuesday in Saints colours, just like the last two coaches.