How many flags with the Judd-Harvey-Hayes-Dal Santo midfield

[remboy]

We would have won the same number as if we'd had a forward line consisting of Riewoldt, Koschitzke, Gehrig and Hamill.

[matrix]

If we really wanted to get into it...

We should have taken

Chris Judd (3) over Luke Ball (2)
Jimmy Bartel (8) over Xavier Clarke (5)
Sam Mitchell (36) over Matt Maguire (21)
Dane Swan (58) over Josh Houlihan (49)
Brian Lake (77) over PASS (67)
Nathan Bock (RD 25) over Josh Dicketts (RD 2)
Aaron Sandilands (RD 33) over Ben Schwarze (RD 18)
Ben Rutten (RD 40) over Chris Smith (RD 34)

That's just from one year as well....

christ we wouldve won 48 flags already with that line up

[noreason41]

what if's are a waste of time --- what if Milne had of actually run to the ball or made an effort to try and kick a goal instead of watching it bounce through for a point... how many times has Milne not made an attempt to kick a goal when the ball is 2 metres away from him and 1 metre away from goal???? never

he didn't even need to try and pick up the ball he could have gone for a soccer goal, why would you not make an effort to win the game & kick a goal when it was there for the taking???

If you'd seen the game at least once you'd know it was obvious to everyone that the ball bounced away from milne.

[Old Mate]

I think over the last 10 seasons they would have won 12 flags