Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

In
Kosi
Zac

Out
Blake
Lynch

[saintspremiers]

In
Kosi
Zac

Out
Blake
Lynch

Mods, it's time to ban plugger.

How dare he not select Walsh.

As we speak, 99% of the forum is "outraged"

Plugs, the ins as you allude to are obvious, but I'd have Lynch and Baker out.

I assume you meant Baker out not Blake??

[SainterK]

In Kosi Zac Walsh (sub)
Out Blake Lynch Baker

[saintspremiers]

In Kosi Zac Walsh (sub)
Out Blake Lynch Baker

Fair call also.

[shmic_s]

In Kosi Zac Walsh (sub)
Out Blake Lynch Baker

+1

And really hope we see it!

[Spinner]

What I want.



IN: Walsh in, Kosi, Dawson


Out: Lynch, Blake, Geary



What will happen, probably what P66 posted.

[St Chris]

In: Dawson, Kosi

Out: Lynch (Omitted), Dempster (Concussion)

Walsh will be emergency, just putting a question mark over Roo's head, to keep the Kangas sniper coach on his toes.

Dempster to get the week off, after 2 really big hits in the last 3 months.

[stkildathunda]

OUT: Baker, Lynch
IN: Kosi & Dawson

EMG: Baker, Lynch, Walsh

[InkerSaint]

In: Walsh Kosi Dawson
Out: Lynch Baker Geary

[samoht]

Lynch .. is too good for VFL football but appears to lack the necessary pace at AFL level. He's had plenty of chances to prove himself in the seniors.

Walsh on the other hand doesn't lack pace .. so should be more comfortable than Lynch at AFL level ? .. the transition should be easier for Walsh.
.. but will we ever find out ?

In Kosi, Dawson
Out - Lynch, + ?

[Spinner]

Lynch .. is too good for VFL football but appears to lack the necessary pace at AFL level. He's had plenty of chances to prove himself in the seniors.

Walsh on the other hand doesn't lack pace .. so should be more comfortable than Lynch at AFL level ? .. the transition should be easier for Walsh.
.. but will we ever find out ?

In Kosi, Dawson
Out - Lynch, + ?

Plenty of chances?

The bloke has played 4 odd games, some including the sub.

[thequarry]

Would love to see Walsh get a game but I think the selectors will continue to pick conservatively for games that have something riding on them. It comes down to weighing up team balance vs. the risk of playing a first gamer.

I think the three players at most danger of getting dropped - it seems everyone is in agreeance here - are Lynch, Baker and Blake. Kosi and Zac come in for sure barring a mishap at training/another illness. Walsh is the popular "next in line", but is there actually a spot for him? I might be wrong (please correct me if so) but I thought Ross hinted at playing Roo, Kosi and Goddard as well through the forward line; he certainly gave Tommy a wrap on Monday night and said "in the short term and longer future we see him as a power forward and an explosive athlete and we think we’ve got one there and at the right time he’ll come in". I thought he might have been a bit more explicit (or, at least, less vague about his chances) if he was to be coming in this week.

[mohannair]

Any latest report on Dempster? If he does not come up then Baker keep his place or else he goes.

Other changes as indicated by most of them is the inclusion of Zac & kosi.
Lynch & Baker goes.

[Eastern]

I think Bakes will hold his spot this week (could be his final game) as North have a number of small forwards.

Kosi & Zac come straight back in

There would have to be injury ???? over Dempster (Head-Concussion) and Blake (Corkie)

Lynchy could be in trouble

That could leave ONE spot for ?????????? Maybe Tommy Walsh. Has anyone else done enough at VFL level to warrant a call-up !!

[matrix]

out
dunno

in
not tommy

[Eastern]

out
dunno

in
not tommy

You've just been crossed off barks4eva's Christmas Card list !!

[matrix]

prob

im of the stance that i want him to play, should already be playing, but wont get picked this week

and so
let the forum meltdown begin at around 5.05pm

[bigcarl]

In Kosi Zac Walsh (sub)
Out Blake Lynch Baker

Yep, but make Kosi the sub

[Stephen Theodore]

What I want.



IN: Walsh in, Kosi, Dawson


Out: Lynch, Blake, Geary



What will happen, probably what P66 posted.

+1

[borderbarry]

IN.. Tommy Walsh

Out.. Dont care.

[Invosaints]

In: Kosi, Dawson

Out: Lynch, Blake


Standard ross selection.

[Dr Spaceman]

In: Kosi, Dawson

Out: Lynch, Blake


Standard ross selection.

In: Stems

Out: Thorns

Standard rose selection

[desertsaint]

surely dempster was concussed?
so dempster and lynch out.
kosu and zac in.
someone - geary? out for walsh i hope!

[Junction Oval]

Most Posters in agreement this week

Out :
Baker
Lynch
Blake

In :
Kosi
Zac
Walsh

Possible - Out - Dempster (concussion). In - Baker.

Now let's see whether the selectors know what they are doing.

[hayes66]

Worst Result

in: dawson, kosi
out: Baker, lynch

and we lose (no change, no risk, no reward, not good enough)

Better Result

in: walsh
out: who cares

and we lose (walsh gets a game we get excited, dissappointed with loss but at least some change to try and improve)

Better Result

in: dawson, kosi
out; baker, lynch

and we win (happy cause we win)

Best Result

in: walsh
out: who cares

and we win (happy with win and excited with walsh, get a glimpse of possible forward or back key position post)


can not believe walsh wasnt even an emergency last week!