Votes vs Sydney

[battye]

Tough one this week

5. Dempster
4. Jones
3. Dal Santo
2. Goddard
1. Clarke

[spert]

5. Dempster
4. Jones

No one else wanted pill bad enough

[GoTheTorp]

A joke thread right?

[whiskers3614]

Were the commentators a bit harsh or did Raph really dog it?

[battye]

Were the commentators a bit harsh or did Raph really dog it?

I can't remember any huge clangers. He tried to take on the player a couple of times with only moderate success.

[bennymac5]

5-umm
4-umm
3-umm
2-umm
1-umm
Did I miss anyone?

[Middo]

Tough one this week

5. Dempster
4. Jones
3. Dal Santo
2. Goddard
1. Clarke

Seriously you are taking the P!!s , Raph while he's been playing ok , today he got his capabilities mixed up with his ambitions as you use the talent you have got and his is not taking the opposition on but giving the first option and yes I reckon he dogged it in the last !! As for Blake oh well ....great trooper but got nothing to give now ... Oh and Baker finished.

[Middo]

Were the commentators a bit harsh or did Raph really dog it?

I can't remember any huge clangers. He tried to take on the player a couple of times with only moderate success.

Clangers ...? He tried to take on the opposition instead of giving the best option which means CLANGER !!! He sells the next player into trouble ...and yes he dogged it going back with the flight of the ball in the last !!!

[BigMart]

Pulled out in the last quarter....not like him....but unfortunately he did...

[perfectionist]

Pulled out in the last quarter....not like him....but unfortunately he did...

First quarter incident might have influenced his decision.

[Raph's Disciple]

Dempster is the only person getting my votes

[dcstkfc]

5 Armitage
4 Goddard
3 Dempster
2 Geary
1 Jones

[perfectionist]

I'm surprised that the usual suspects haven't given Jack Steven some votes. He turned up again.

5. Sean Dempster (but should have been on the dual Brownlow Medalist)
4. Clint Jones
3. Dean Polo (says it all)
2. David Armitage
1. Brendon Goddard

[desertsaint]

jones
no one else, but if i have too...
dempster
bj
dal
steven
at least the last three stuck some tackles.

[avid]

5 Dal Santo -- played very well for about half the game
4 Dempster -- consistent and courageous
3 Goddard -- went missing for large slabs, but played well in between
2 Jones -- nothing spectacular, but good work in the clinches
1 Gram -- (the cupboard is bare, I admit) but he defended, found the ball, and attacked all day.

For those who thought Geary or Clarke earned a vote, I am astonished. They were terrible, almost all day.

[markinUSA]

5 Dempster
4 Jones
3 Armo
2 Dal Santo
1 Goddard

[BigMart]

Dempster
Dal Santo
Jones
Armitage
Ray

[stkildathunda]

5. Sean Dempster
4. Farren Ray
3. Nick Dal Santo
2. Clint Jones
1. Dean Polo

[borderbarry]

Sean Dempster
Dal
B.J.
Armo
Gram

We need someone to teach our blokes how to pass the ball.

[Dr Spaceman]

5 Dempster
4 Jones
3 Armo
2 Dal Santo
1 Goddard

Yeah that'll do:

5 Dempster
4 Jones
3 Armo
2 Dal Santo
1 Goddard

[Sainternist]

Surely, someone has to at least give one vote to Umpire Ray Chamberlain for getting cleaned up in the last minute?

[Old Mate]

Surely, someone has to at least give one vote to Umpire Ray Chamberlain for getting cleaned up in the last minute?

Army award

[SainterK]

5 Dempster
4 Jones
3 Armo
2 Dal
1 Farren

[Junction Oval]

5 Dempster - super defense all day.
4 Jones - in and under all day.
3 Gram - cleaned up well I thought.
2 Goddard - a great first and last quatrters.
1 Dal Santo - a very slick player. Lots of contested ball.

[Con Gorozidis]

too many people consult the stat sheet before they vote. dal had no influence and bj went completely missing for a full hour in the middle of the game. 5. dempster 4. Jones that's it.