Gardi Knee?

bangerisking · Mon 20 Jun 2011 7:57pm

Just had word that Micky G has done a knee apparently reported on 3aw can anyone confirm poor bloke it it's true

saintbrat · Post: # 1093184Post **saintbrat** » Mon 20 Jun 2011 8:01pm

Hence I rarely listen to aw and their rumours

will it be repeated 'On the Couch"

Megsie · Post: # 1093203Post **Megsie** » Mon 20 Jun 2011 8:29pm

when supposedly did this occur?

friend saw him at a coffee shop few days back. Said he looked trim & fit
seemed happy to acknowledge people around who asked after his health.

Aw are rumour mongers.

bangerisking · Mon 20 Jun 2011 8:42pm

BT supposedly reported in tonight haven't heard anything else about it so hope it's rubbish

dragit · Post: # 1093490Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:10pm

Someone please tell me this is BS?

BringBackMadDog · Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:29pm

dragit wrote:Someone please tell me this is BS?

I saw him after the game on Saturday night he was almost in a canter, no limp at all. When was he supposed to have done it?

roskilde · Post: # 1093506Post **roskilde** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:35pm

i guess the tuesday injury report with misson will clear it up (hopefully)

hope the big monster is ok.

SaintPav · Post: # 1093508Post **SaintPav** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:39pm

roskilde wrote:i guess the tuesday injury report with misson will clear it up (hopefully)

hope the big monster is ok.

Don't bet on that report clearing too much up....

Whenever someone goes down, Dave says: "yeah, he pulled up really well and will be assessed during the week".

stkildathunda · Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:43pm

SaintPav wrote:
roskilde wrote:i guess the tuesday injury report with misson will clear it up (hopefully)

hope the big monster is ok.
Don't bet on that report clearing too much up....

Whenever someone goes down, Dave says: "yeah, he pulled up really well and will be assessed during the week".

Just dont trust anything the club releases about injuries.. We will only know the truth when Gardi either runs out at Sandy or doesnt in next few weeks...

roskilde · Post: # 1093518Post **roskilde** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:45pm

very true, he seems to describe just about every injury as "yeah 2 to 3 weeks" which i have decided now to mean anything from indefintitely out to a surprise entry in this weeks team!

Dr Spaceman · Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:51pm

stkildathunda wrote:
SaintPav wrote:
roskilde wrote:i guess the tuesday injury report with misson will clear it up (hopefully)

hope the big monster is ok.
Don't bet on that report clearing too much up....

Whenever someone goes down, Dave says: "yeah, he pulled up really well and will be assessed during the week".
Just dont trust anything the club releases about injuries.. We will only know the truth when Gardi either runs out at Sandy or doesnt in next few weeks...

Has he been flagged for the same comeback match as Hamill?

St Nick · Post: # 1093555Post **St Nick** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:00pm

We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.

dragit · Post: # 1093565Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:10pm

St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.

What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦

St Nick · Post: # 1093569Post **St Nick** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:16pm

dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.
What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦

The advantage would be that we could give more games to youngsters. If McEvoy got injured I would rather see Stanley or Walsh or another youngster come in and ruck rather than Gardi. Gardi won't be at the club next year so there is no point playing him again. If we were in the top 4 then that would be a different story. Unfortunately, we are in the bottom 4 (nearly).

dragit · Post: # 1093572Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:20pm

St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.
What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦
The advantage would be that we could give more games to youngsters. If McEvoy got injured I would rather see Stanley or Walsh or another youngster come in and ruck rather than Gardi. Gardi won't be at the club next year so there is no point playing him again. If we were in the top 4 then that would be a different story. Unfortunately, we are in the bottom 4 (nearly).

You haven't seen Stanley rucking have you?
Let me guess you've heard that he is very tall and also won the grand final sprint?
Gardiner doesn't need to retire in order to get games into players who aren't performing at VFL level, we're doing that already.

St Nick · Post: # 1093576Post **St Nick** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:26pm

dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.
What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦
The advantage would be that we could give more games to youngsters. If McEvoy got injured I would rather see Stanley or Walsh or another youngster come in and ruck rather than Gardi. Gardi won't be at the club next year so there is no point playing him again. If we were in the top 4 then that would be a different story. Unfortunately, we are in the bottom 4 (nearly).
You haven't seen Stanley rucking have you?
Let me guess you've heard that he is very tall and also won the grand final sprint?
Gardiner doesn't need to retire in order to get games into players who aren't performing at VFL level, we're doing that already.

Stanley won't improve playing for Sandi. He is the type of character that needs to be thrown into the deep end (seniors) so the penny can drop.

dragit · Post: # 1093578Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:29pm

St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.
What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦
The advantage would be that we could give more games to youngsters. If McEvoy got injured I would rather see Stanley or Walsh or another youngster come in and ruck rather than Gardi. Gardi won't be at the club next year so there is no point playing him again. If we were in the top 4 then that would be a different story. Unfortunately, we are in the bottom 4 (nearly).
You haven't seen Stanley rucking have you?
Let me guess you've heard that he is very tall and also won the grand final sprint?
Gardiner doesn't need to retire in order to get games into players who aren't performing at VFL level, we're doing that already.
Stanley won't improve playing for Sandi. He is the type of character that needs to be thrown into the deep end (seniors) so the penny can drop.

Please tell us more about his character, I don't know him personally at all?
His 2 senior games this year in the 'deep end' he was drowningâ€¦

St Nick · Post: # 1093582Post **St Nick** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:32pm

dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:
St Nick wrote:We are not in contention so Gardi should do the right thing and retire.
What advantage would this have over retiring at the end of the season? If McEvoy gets injured, Gardiner is the only other legit ruckmen on the list at presentâ€¦
The advantage would be that we could give more games to youngsters. If McEvoy got injured I would rather see Stanley or Walsh or another youngster come in and ruck rather than Gardi. Gardi won't be at the club next year so there is no point playing him again. If we were in the top 4 then that would be a different story. Unfortunately, we are in the bottom 4 (nearly).
You haven't seen Stanley rucking have you?
Let me guess you've heard that he is very tall and also won the grand final sprint?
Gardiner doesn't need to retire in order to get games into players who aren't performing at VFL level, we're doing that already.
Stanley won't improve playing for Sandi. He is the type of character that needs to be thrown into the deep end (seniors) so the penny can drop.
Please tell us more about his character, I don't know him personally at all?
His 2 senior games this year in the 'deep end' he was drowningâ€¦

Fair call, but if we want the Saints to re-build they have to play the youngsters. He may have struggled for 2 games but who knows what would have happened if he had the entire season to gain experience and confidence.

GrumpyOne · Post: # 1093588Post **GrumpyOne** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 2:57pm

Gardi Knee = Dicky Knee?

Moccha · Post: # 1093620Post **Moccha** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 3:45pm

Rumour file so it must be true

saintbrat · Tue 21 Jun 2011 11:23pm

Well h-S are not going with the rumour

With St Kilda having the bye, Michael Gardiner may play his first game of the season in the VFL after overcoming a knee injury.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6079509894

and I'll look for little smiles

Nick Riewoldt could rejuvenate his playing career with a run on the wing, says Richmond great Nick Richardson.

stinger · Post: # 1094072Post **stinger** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 5:08pm

thanks bratty...save me the trouble....