St.Kilda Bashing

[Sainternist]

When will it ever end?

Now Citizen Eddie is trying to demonise St.Kilda supporters. What next?

I'VE HAD A GUTFUL

[plugger66]

Has it come to this?

[GrumpyOne]

I refuse to be demonized..... I want to remain a Sainter.

[Sainternist]

Has it come to this?

To state the obvious - a combination of being back to back runners up, off field scandals, followed by poor onfield performances. The thing is, it seems to be snowballing more and more. The club has been put under the miscroscope and is getting nothing but negative press. It is serioulsly getting out of hand.

For me, the latest scandal involving McGuire and alleged racism almost feels like a personal attack.

Perhaps I'm being too precious? It just really hurts to think that the St.Kilda FC has become some sort of "Public Enemy Number 1" in the football world.

All of this could be potentially very damaging to the club's future.

[GrumpyOne]

Has it come to this?

To state the obvious - a combination of being back to back runners up, off field scandals, followed by poor onfield performances. The thing is, it seems to be snowballing more and more. The club has been put under the miscroscope and is getting nothing but negative press. It is serioulsly getting out of hand.

For me, the latest scandal involving McGuire and alleged racism almost feels like a personal attack.

Perhaps I'm being too precious? It just really hurts to think that the St.Kilda FC has become some sort of "Public Enemy Number 1" in the football world.

All of this could be potentially very damaging to the club's future.

Don't think so....... The filth have been public enemy number one for 100 years.... done them no harm.

[Junction Oval]

I heard a lady on the radio today, saying that the language from the filth supporters was "absolute filth", she was verbally abused and had a glass of wine showered over her - no excuse for this either.

[GrumpyOne]

I heard a lady on the radio today, saying that the language from the filth supporters was "absolute filth", she was verbally abused and had a glass of wine showered over her - no excuse for this either.

Wine?

How'd they get the cask in the ground?

Or was it something that sounded a bit like wine?

[stinger]

Has it come to this?

To state the obvious - a combination of being back to back runners up, off field scandals, followed by poor onfield performances. The thing is, it seems to be snowballing more and more. The club has been put under the miscroscope and is getting nothing but negative press. It is serioulsly getting out of hand.

For me, the latest scandal involving McGuire and alleged racism almost feels like a personal attack.

Perhaps I'm being too precious? It just really hurts to think that the St.Kilda FC has become some sort of "Public Enemy Number 1" in the football world.

All of this could be potentially very damaging to the club's future.

i don't know what the fella allegedly said ,,,nor is there any evidence that he was a saints supporter....

[Dr Spaceman]

I heard a lady on the radio today, saying that the language from the filth supporters was "absolute filth", she was verbally abused and had a glass of wine showered over her - no excuse for this either.

Wine?

How'd they get the cask in the ground?

Goon Bag inside false beer gut or pregnancy bump?




Although the false beer gut or pregnancy bump would have to be strapped over the real beer gut or pregnancy bump

[python]

Thought i'd post this here, not sure if it's been mentioned elsewhere, but I was reading an article on all the cats young players on the herald sun website

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/c ... 6069775148

Scott compares Vardy to Riewoldt, which is fine, I haven't seen him play so i cant say whether that's accurate or not, but then near the end of the article...

"St Kilda sniffed at Collingwood's offer of pick 30 and Sharrod Wellingham for Luke Ball in the same draft. Don't tell St Kilda fans, but Vardy might be handy alongside Riewoldt right now"

What does that have to do with anything? I don't usually buy conspiracy theories, but what other reason is that in there aside from getting another criticism of the club in? Vardy was taken at 42, nothing to do with collingwoods pick at all. Anyone got any legitimate reasons as to why the ball trade was brought up?

[SaintPav]

I heard a lady on the radio today, saying that the language from the filth supporters was "absolute filth", she was verbally abused and had a glass of wine showered over her - no excuse for this either.

and she was a filth supporter at that.

[Sainternist]

I heard a lady on the radio today, saying that the language from the filth supporters was "absolute filth", she was verbally abused and had a glass of wine showered over her - no excuse for this either.

Wine?

How'd they get the cask in the ground?

Or was it something that sounded a bit like wine?

Filth supporters drinking from wine glasses does sound odd. Unless of course Eddie put a stop to them sneaking in the "goon bag" because of its racist connotations

[starsign]

Definitely too precious on this one
You gottaUgh
If Eddie everywhere ever went out Nd sat with his rank Nd file filth he would be piping a different tune
And don't forget it was their lot of racists at Victoria park that sparked the winmar episode and opened the entire issue for AFL scrutiny and on field a tionp

[GrumpyOne]

You gottaUgh

I did.

[stkildathunda]

Thought i'd post this here, not sure if it's been mentioned elsewhere, but I was reading an article on all the cats young players on the herald sun website

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/c ... 6069775148

Scott compares Vardy to Riewoldt, which is fine, I haven't seen him play so i cant say whether that's accurate or not, but then near the end of the article...

"St Kilda sniffed at Collingwood's offer of pick 30 and Sharrod Wellingham for Luke Ball in the same draft. Don't tell St Kilda fans, but Vardy might be handy alongside Riewoldt right now"

What does that have to do with anything? I don't usually buy conspiracy theories, but what other reason is that in there aside from getting another criticism of the club in? Vardy was taken at 42, nothing to do with collingwoods pick at all. Anyone got any legitimate reasons as to why the ball trade was brought up?

Considering we were never offered Wellingham i find it very hard to believe. And also considering we took Winmar 2 picks later you would have to assume we would have taken him at pick 30

[Sainternist]

And don't forget it was their lot of racists at Victoria park that sparked the winmar episode and opened the entire issue for AFL scrutiny and on field a tionp

I brought that up in another thread. I attended that match. Filth fans were so feral that day I actually feared for my own safety after the macth.

Both myself and a mate decided stayed back in the Saints CS area a good hour after the game and then got the train home from Vic Park Station. By the time we got the station, there were drunken Filth fans brawling with themselves on the platform and even on the train tracks

[shmic_s]

Mark Robinson said it well:

Eddie said he and the Collingwood Football Club, wasn't on trial yesterday, but in a way it was. It's terrific for footy for Eddie to make a stand, but at the same time hollow. His coach called Stephen Milne a ''f.... rapist", and on Saturday night, Magpies fans chanted Milney was a rapist, and called Jimmy Gwilt a ''golliwog''. Use your power, Ed. Wade through your cheer squad with the same venom as you showed on Saturday night. Now that would be a legacy.

[stinger]

And don't forget it was their lot of racists at Victoria park that sparked the winmar episode and opened the entire issue for AFL scrutiny and on field a tionp

I brought that up in another thread. I attended that match. Filth fans were so feral that day I actually feared for my own safety after the macth.

Both myself and a mate decided stayed back in the Saints CS area a good hour after the game and then got the train home from Vic Park Station. By the time we got the station, there were drunken Filth fans brawling with themselves on the platform and even on the train tracks

nothing changes.....they were feral 60 years ago...used to spit on you...win lose or draw....

[Sainternist]

And don't forget it was their lot of racists at Victoria park that sparked the winmar episode and opened the entire issue for AFL scrutiny and on field a tionp

I brought that up in another thread. I attended that match. Filth fans were so feral that day I actually feared for my own safety after the macth.

Both myself and a mate decided stayed back in the Saints CS area a good hour after the game and then got the train home from Vic Park Station. By the time we got the station, there were drunken Filth fans brawling with themselves on the platform and even on the train tracks

nothing changes.....they were feral 60 years ago...used to spit on you...win lose or draw....

yeah, a friend of mine's grandmother, who was a geelong supporter, once spoke of an unpleasant experience in having beer tipped over her at that cesspool by filth supporters back in 50's. she also described lou richards as being the dirtiest player she ever saw to play the game

[stinger]

And don't forget it was their lot of racists at Victoria park that sparked the winmar episode and opened the entire issue for AFL scrutiny and on field a tionp

I brought that up in another thread. I attended that match. Filth fans were so feral that day I actually feared for my own safety after the macth.

Both myself and a mate decided stayed back in the Saints CS area a good hour after the game and then got the train home from Vic Park Station. By the time we got the station, there were drunken Filth fans brawling with themselves on the platform and even on the train tracks

nothing changes.....they were feral 60 years ago...used to spit on you...win lose or draw....

yeah, a friend of mine's grandmother, who was a geelong supporter, once spoke of an experienced of having beer tipped over her at that cesspool back in 50's. she also described lou richards as being the dirtiest player she ever saw to play the game

that he was...an ankle tapper and a behind the play thug.....

[Sainternist]

An associate of mine who is self-proclaimed St.Kilda Basher revealed that his grandfather played for us for two years and hates us to this day.

Does anyone remember a player from yesteryear called Les Willis?

[stinger]

An associate of mine who is self-proclaimed St.Kilda Basher revealed that his grandfather played for us for two years and hates us to this day.

Does anyone remember a player from yesteryear called Les Willis?

played 1945 to 47....19 games...two goals......wore no 33.....ex fitzroy reserves


..

[plugger66]

An associate of mine who is self-proclaimed St.Kilda Basher revealed that his grandfather played for us for two years and hates us to this day.

Does anyone remember a player from yesteryear called Les Willis?

played 1945 to 47....19 games...two goals......wore no 33.....ex fitzroy reserves


..

You were in your 30's then werent you?

[SydneySainter]

Thought i'd post this here, not sure if it's been mentioned elsewhere, but I was reading an article on all the cats young players on the herald sun website

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/c ... 6069775148

Scott compares Vardy to Riewoldt, which is fine, I haven't seen him play so i cant say whether that's accurate or not, but then near the end of the article...

"St Kilda sniffed at Collingwood's offer of pick 30 and Sharrod Wellingham for Luke Ball in the same draft. Don't tell St Kilda fans, but Vardy might be handy alongside Riewoldt right now"

What does that have to do with anything? I don't usually buy conspiracy theories, but what other reason is that in there aside from getting another criticism of the club in? Vardy was taken at 42, nothing to do with collingwoods pick at all. Anyone got any legitimate reasons as to why the ball trade was brought up?

We'll never live getting zip for Luke Ball down.

[SainterK]

"The deal failed yesterday when St Kilda rejected Collingwood's final offer of pick 25, which they would have obtained by trading their pick 30 and Sharrod Wellingham to North Melbourne"

How on earth does one then establish that Sharrod was offered to St Kilda?