Votes St Kilda v Melbourne Round 9

[borderbarry]

5 - Montagna
4 - BJ
3 - Roo
2 - Steven
1 - Armo.

[avid]

5 Montagna
4 Reiwoldt
3 Gilbert
2 Gwilt
1 Jones

[matrix]

joey 5
gwilt 4
roo 3
bj 2
armo 1

[IluvHarvey]

Joey - 5
Jones - 4
Roo - 3
Armo - 2
Peake - 1

Tought Joey was super.
Jones not only killed Davey by closing him down, he ran off him and showed up Davey's defensive side.
Peake was great ran hard all day showed pace and gave 100% all day.

[stkildathunda]

5. Montagna
4. Riewoldt
3. Steven
2. Gwilt
1. Peake

[St Chris]

5. Montagna
4. Jones
3. Blake
2. Goddard
1. Steven

Honestly thought Steven was ordinary for 2 and a half quarters, and I was saying he should have been subbed off instead of Siposs. Fair to say I was surprised when I saw he'd had 27 touches and half a dozen clearances.

Blake went into the ruck after Kosi copped a couple of hits, and at least provided a contest. Kosi's efforts were laughable at best, Martin would just stand there, wait for Kosi to jump and miss, and palm the ball off to whoever he liked.

Goddard did some good things, but still not back to his best. His obvious strength is his foot skills, so need to use it more. But vast improvement.

I've seen a lot of votes for Roo, but I thought he had a poor game. Got plenty of it, but some really poor disposal let him down. Sold teammates into trouble far too many times.

[SainterK]

Joey
Armo
Peake
Dempster
Roo

[saintly]

5. Montagna
4. Jones
3. Blake
2. Goddard
1. Steven

Honestly thought Steven was ordinary for 2 and a half quarters, and I was saying he should have been subbed off instead of Siposs. Fair to say I was surprised when I saw he'd had 27 touches and half a dozen clearances.

Blake went into the ruck after Kosi copped a couple of hits, and at least provided a contest. Kosi's efforts were laughable at best, Martin would just stand there, wait for Kosi to jump and miss, and palm the ball off to whoever he liked.

Goddard did some good things, but still not back to his best. His obvious strength is his foot skills, so need to use it more. But vast improvement.

I've seen a lot of votes for Roo, but I thought he had a poor game. Got plenty of it, but some really poor disposal let him down. Sold teammates into trouble far too many times.

anyone know why goddard was handballing alot more then kicking? he does have great kicking skills.

[St Chris]

5. Montagna
4. Jones
3. Blake
2. Goddard
1. Steven

Honestly thought Steven was ordinary for 2 and a half quarters, and I was saying he should have been subbed off instead of Siposs. Fair to say I was surprised when I saw he'd had 27 touches and half a dozen clearances.

Blake went into the ruck after Kosi copped a couple of hits, and at least provided a contest. Kosi's efforts were laughable at best, Martin would just stand there, wait for Kosi to jump and miss, and palm the ball off to whoever he liked.

Goddard did some good things, but still not back to his best. His obvious strength is his foot skills, so need to use it more. But vast improvement.

I've seen a lot of votes for Roo, but I thought he had a poor game. Got plenty of it, but some really poor disposal let him down. Sold teammates into trouble far too many times.

anyone know why goddard was handballing alot more then kicking? he does have great kicking skills.

Probably just because opposition teams are wise to it now. They know once he gets the footy in his hands, they do everything to stop him from using his main asset.

[saintbob]

5 Monty
4 BJ
3 Armo
2 Gwilt
1 Peake

[Sainter_Dad]

126 Montagna
61 Jones
60 Gwilt
58 Riewoldt
44 Armitage
30 Peake
28 Goddard
19 Steven
12 Fisher
4 Blake
4 Gilbert
2 Dempster
2 Milne

Therefore:
5 Montagna
4 Jones
3 Gwilt
2 Riewoldt
1 Armitage