MRP - Joey 1 game

saintbrat · Post: # 1072215Post **saintbrat** » Tue 10 May 2011 4:49pm

for bumping >>>>>>>>>

and Judd major fine for instigating the meleee....

many other fines..

SEN

Saints43 · Post: # 1072216Post **Saints43** » Tue 10 May 2011 4:50pm

Montagna got a week according to SEN.

Can't appeal due to bad record.

Solar · Post: # 1072219Post **Solar** » Tue 10 May 2011 4:52pm

Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!

SainterK · Post: # 1072222Post **SainterK** » Tue 10 May 2011 4:54pm

Out Joey in Polo.

He was silly, should apologise too IMO.

plugger66 · Post: # 1072225Post **plugger66** » Tue 10 May 2011 4:55pm

Solar wrote:Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!

So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player.

White Winmar · Tue 10 May 2011 5:00pm

Hang on a minute P66, did you see how slight the contact was? Nor was it repeated, as in what the lions did to Roo. A week for that? Good grief!

CURLY · Post: # 1072233Post **CURLY** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:03pm

plugger66 wrote:
Solar wrote:Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!
So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player.

Stop being a tool for once. How many weeks did Jack Riewoldt get last year for punching Pears broken hand?

Dr Spaceman · Tue 10 May 2011 5:05pm

Joey was silly at best.

Can't really complain about the 1 week IMO.

plugger66 · Post: # 1072238Post **plugger66** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:06pm

White Winmar wrote:Hang on a minute P66, did you see how slight the contact was? Nor was it repeated, as in what the lions did to Roo. A week for that? Good grief!

But they changed the rules after what happened to Rooy. Joey new that, I new it and you know it. It is dangerous to hit an injured player however slightly. Joey could see he was injured. Why the hell would he do it. It certainly aint tough. Dont worry if the boot was on the other foot there would have been a 5 page thread now asking for the Carlton player to be hung.

plugger66 · Post: # 1072242Post **plugger66** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:08pm

CURLY wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Solar wrote:Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!
So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player.
Stop being a tool for once. How many weeks did Jack Riewoldt get last year for punching Pears broken hand?

Was it broken during the game? By the way why I a tool. Is it because I see things clearly and not through fogged up eyes like some.

CURLY · Post: # 1072244Post **CURLY** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:10pm

plugger66 wrote:
CURLY wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Solar wrote:Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!
So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player.
Stop being a tool for once. How many weeks did Jack Riewoldt get last year for punching Pears broken hand?
Was it broken during the game? By the way why I a tool. Is it because I see things clearly and not through fogged up eyes like some.

No its because you try to justify blatant bulls*** with more bulls***. For Joey to get a week for that is comical at best. Zac got a week for a tummy punch yet a WC player slams one into Heath hOcking and nothing no charge. Its becoming more and more of a joke.

saint66au · Post: # 1072245Post **saint66au** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:10pm

Did Joey bump Curnow as he was originally coming off or after he returned to the field?

stkildathunda · Tue 10 May 2011 5:11pm

saint66au wrote:Did Joey bump Curnow as he was originally coming off or after he returned to the field?

When he was initally running off the ground.. Kosi hit him when he returned

saintbrat · Post: # 1072249Post **saintbrat** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:12pm

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/n ... 6053074940

interesting to hear some who are commenting ,,,,,, Hard men.. bit like the ' spirit of the game' comment from last week..

my how the game has changed...

Judd Double what others copped.

Seven players have been fined for taking part in a quarter-time melee that started when Montagna's teammate Justin Koschitzke again bumped Curnow, after he had returned to the field with his shoulder strapped.

Carlton skipper Chris Judd copped a double fine for starting the melee and teammates Heath Scotland, Marc Murphy, Aaron Joseph and Mitch Robinson also copped financial sanctions.

Also fined were Saints Jason Gram, Sam Gilbert and David Armitage

.

plugger66 · Post: # 1072251Post **plugger66** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:13pm

CURLY wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
CURLY wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Solar wrote:Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace!
So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player.
Stop being a tool for once. How many weeks did Jack Riewoldt get last year for punching Pears broken hand?
Was it broken during the game? By the way why I a tool. Is it because I see things clearly and not through fogged up eyes like some.
No its because you try to justify blatant bulls*** with more bulls***. For Joey to get a week for that is comical at best. Zac got a week for a tummy punch yet a WC player slams one into Heath hOcking and nothing no charge. Its becoming more and more of a joke.

Read the rule book. You will feel better. Zac deseved a week. Joey gets one for being very stupid.

SainterK · Post: # 1072252Post **SainterK** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:13pm

He deserves a week.

If anyone had done that to one of our players, you'd be disgusted.

He would do well to apologise.

That's not tough, and considering what happened to Bakes last year, he can't even plead ignorance.

saint66au · Post: # 1072253Post **saint66au** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:13pm

stkildathunda wrote:
saint66au wrote:Did Joey bump Curnow as he was originally coming off or after he returned to the field?
When he was initally running off the ground.. Kosi hit him when he returned

Well in that case the week is prolly deserved. As plugger said we all screamed blue murder when it happened to Roo. There was no rule about it then but there is now so what cause for complaint have we got apart from someone saying the AFL hate us and always change the rules after St Kilda players get hurt?

Beno88 · Post: # 1072254Post **Beno88** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:13pm

What a disgrace. Anyone who thinks what Joey did was wrong is a fool.
If you're on the football field and you knock someone down, you knock them down again if you can, and again and again. If they appear hurt, but still going, you hit them again. Top level football is ruthless, if you're running through the battlefield you're fair game.

saint66au · Post: # 1072255Post **saint66au** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:16pm

Beno88 wrote:What a disgrace. Anyone who thinks what Joey did was wrong is a fool.
If you're on the football field and you knock someone down, you knock them down again if you can, and again and again. If they appear hurt, but still going, you hit them again. Top level football is ruthless, if you're running through the battlefield you're fair game.

Pleae tell me that was sarcasm

plugger66 · Post: # 1072256Post **plugger66** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:17pm

Beno88 wrote:What a disgrace. Anyone who thinks what Joey did was wrong is a fool.
If you're on the football field and you knock someone down, you knock them down again if you can, and again and again. If they appear hurt, but still going, you hit them again. Top level football is ruthless, if you're running through the battlefield you're fair game.

I agree. Cant work out why GC players didnt whack Andrew Raines as he was coming off Saturday night. Also Rooy deserved it against Brisbane. It was very tough by Joey. Should be more of it.

Beno88 · Post: # 1072258Post **Beno88** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:20pm

saint66au wrote:
Beno88 wrote:What a disgrace. Anyone who thinks what Joey did was wrong is a fool.
If you're on the football field and you knock someone down, you knock them down again if you can, and again and again. If they appear hurt, but still going, you hit them again. Top level football is ruthless, if you're running through the battlefield you're fair game.
Pleae tell me that was sarcasm

Hard to pick?

stkildathunda · Tue 10 May 2011 5:20pm

Beno88 wrote:What a disgrace. Anyone who thinks what Joey did was wrong is a fool.
If you're on the football field and you knock someone down, you knock them down again if you can, and again and again. If they appear hurt, but still going, you hit them again. Top level football is ruthless, if you're running through the battlefield you're fair game.

So Farren should have jumped on Selwood after he was knocked out? Same with Jack Riewoldt... Maybe the West Coast guys should have laid into Jono Brown when he had his face knocked into a million pieces....

clarky449 · Post: # 1072261Post **clarky449** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:20pm

Absolute stupid from Leigh, should of known better. Now he will be sitting out against Hawthorn for a stupid act which should of never happened.

CURLY · Post: # 1072263Post **CURLY** » Tue 10 May 2011 5:20pm

Im sick and tired of people saying Zac or Joey deserved a week for being stupid. FFS there is no rule against that. If your even comparing what Joey did to what happened to Roo your also kidding yourself. The Brisbane players didnt just do it once they continued until Hamill and co intervened. Even still Roo was fair game as was Curnow. Get off the ground if your hurt.

saintdooley · Tue 10 May 2011 5:21pm

lost a lot of respect for joey after seeing that. what a d**khead.