McQualter you dud!

saintkid · Post: # 1071362Post **saintkid** » Mon 09 May 2011 10:12pm

Seriously how the #@#$! does that moron coach of ours comntinue to play one of the most hopeless players to ever wear the red, white and black! He is bl*#dy useless and another of his regular clangers cost us a goal again!

saint58 · Post: # 1071413Post **saint58** » Mon 09 May 2011 10:38pm

saintkid wrote:Seriously how the #@#$! does that moron coach of ours comntinue to play one of the most hopeless players to ever wear the red, white and black! He is bl*#dy useless and another of his regular clangers cost us a goal again!

let me guess you are not happy right.

Well you are right mcqualter has been a dud all except for 2008/9 he had ok seasons but we had other great players around him.He is now shown up and has been for a long while.

He carnt kick does not tackle is slow and turns it over so what use is he better off persisting with the young guys at least they will give a go.

Ralphy · Post: # 1071417Post **Ralphy** » Mon 09 May 2011 10:39pm

saint58 wrote:
saintkid wrote:Seriously how the #@#$! does that moron coach of ours comntinue to play one of the most hopeless players to ever wear the red, white and black! He is bl*#dy useless and another of his regular clangers cost us a goal again!
let me guess you are not happy right,just a guess.

Well you are right mcqualter has been a dud all except for 2008/9 he had ok seasons but we had other great players around him.He is now shown up and has been for a long while.

He carnt kick doenst tackle is slow and turns it over so what use is he better off persisting with the young guys at least they will give a go.

Should add gram to that list, sorry bloke ya spend way to long looking into a mirror,

BigMart · Post: # 1071441Post **BigMart** » Mon 09 May 2011 10:49pm

What has gram done wrong.....specific

I think the coaching has been woeful....

jonesy · Post: # 1071446Post **jonesy** » Mon 09 May 2011 10:50pm

BigMart wrote: I think the coaching has been woeful....

Wow...something different

BigMart · Post: # 1071489Post **BigMart** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:03pm

What do you think jonesy....rather than just commenting on what i think...

Goddard......is he in the right position, match up???

Game breaker, and now he has turned him into a tagger......and nick, our other gun, reduced to playing as a crash and bash target for the high ball.....

What next, milney playing as a small defender.....dal a tagger

I think one of ross's aims is to make every player on the list be a GOP

Thinline · Post: # 1071492Post **Thinline** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:05pm

BigMart wrote:What do you think jonesy....rather than just commenting on what i think...

Goddard......is he in the right position, match up???

Game breaker, and now he has turned him into a tagger......and nick, our other gun, reduced to playing as a crash and bash target for the high ball.....

What next, milney playing as a small defender.....dal a tagger

I think one of ross's aims is to make every player on the list be a GOP

Apply for the job, Big Mart. You know everything. You'd be a shoe in.

NoMore · Post: # 1071506Post **NoMore** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:09pm

Its fair to say that Mini may well be the biggest dud of the year

Add to that Jones and Blake at least

oh yeah and i forgot Baker

We are in big trouble

jonesy · Post: # 1071510Post **jonesy** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:10pm

Thinline wrote:
BigMart wrote:What do you think jonesy....rather than just commenting on what i think...

Goddard......is he in the right position, match up???

Game breaker, and now he has turned him into a tagger......and nick, our other gun, reduced to playing as a crash and bash target for the high ball.....

What next, milney playing as a small defender.....dal a tagger

I think one of ross's aims is to make every player on the list be a GOP
Apply for the job, Big Mart. You know everything. You'd be a shoe in.

Knows everything when we lose...didn't hear from him in 2009/2010

As for BJ playing on squibbsy Mart,he's virtually our premier player,not asking him to much to play on someone decent,it's what good players are supposed to do

Him and Roo are out of form,hardly Lyon's fault.

BigMart · Post: # 1071512Post **BigMart** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:10pm

Just an pbservation, what do you think?? Again instead of a silly comment, give us a thought....

One things for sure....we will have another coach in 2012...

It will not be me...No, but it will be another...

And all the in ross we trust posters will turn on him soon....around R13...perhaps you will be one

I for one think ross has been outstanding, until this year....he made a fatal decision

WinnersOnly · Mon 09 May 2011 11:13pm

How does the AFL gumby keep getting a game?

NoMore · Post: # 1071529Post **NoMore** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:15pm

But in all serious
Mini cost us 2 goals in the opening 5 minutes
It is a disgrace

saintkid · Post: # 1071538Post **saintkid** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:18pm

So tired of seeing the same ineffective, negative footy from McQualter the superdud. Lyon the moron needs to give a chance to more young players that naturally try to take the game on like Sippos did in the last quarter. McQualter would try to go sideways even if he was in the goalsquare! He is pathetic, no wonder Maxwell showed him absolutely no respect in the GF. Ran off him at will because he knew the dud was never going to be damaging on the scoreboard.

saintspremiers · Mon 09 May 2011 11:20pm

NoMore wrote:But in all serious
Mini cost us 2 goals in the opening 5 minutes
It is a disgrace

Mini is a hack.

He's finished in the AFL IMO.

meher baba · Mon 09 May 2011 11:32pm

Mini won some hard ball and made some good tackles, including a crucial holding the ball. He made some mistakes, but he wasn't Robinson Crusoe there.

You anonymous Internet heroes are infantile in the way you all gang up on one player and bag the crap out of him. I'd like to see some of you on an AFL field. Actually I wouldn't: the rear end of a brown-stained pair of shorts in retreat is not a pretty sight.

Thinline · Post: # 1071564Post **Thinline** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:34pm

meher baba wrote:Mini won some hard ball and made some good tackles, including a crucial holding the ball. He made some mistakes, but he wasn't Robinson Crusoe there.

You anonymous Internet heroes are infantile in the way you all gang up on one player and bag the crap out of him. I'd like to see some of you on an AFL field. Actually I wouldn't: the rear end of a brown-stained pair of shorts in retreat is not a pretty sight.

Ha! I just envisaged 44 bespectacled jelly donuts in undersized footy gear unable to concentrate on the game for fear of missing the chance to sledge Raph on a net forum...

NoMore · Post: # 1071576Post **NoMore** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:41pm

meher baba wrote:Mini won some hard ball and made some good tackles, including a crucial holding the ball. He made some mistakes, but he wasn't Robinson Crusoe there.

You anonymous Internet heroes are infantile in the way you all gang up on one player and bag the crap out of him. I'd like to see some of you on an AFL field. Actually I wouldn't: the rear end of a brown-stained pair of shorts in retreat is not a pretty sight.

Thats funny
Last time i checked i wasn't paid good money to play AFL. i am paid to do my job and i do a much better job of it than what he is doing of playing football. It is not just tonight we have been bagging him. We are sick of seeing him out there. It is 2 years since he played a decent game. Just get rid of him

santazzi · Post: # 1071581Post **santazzi** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:42pm

BigMart wrote:Just an pbservation, what do you think?? Again instead of a silly comment, give us a thought....

One things for sure....we will have another coach in 2012...

It will not be me...No, but it will be another...

And all the in ross we trust posters will turn on him soon....around R13...perhaps you will be one

I for one think ross has been outstanding, until this year....he made a fatal decision

BigMart please elaborate on the nature of the fatal decision........

Verdun66 · Post: # 1071583Post **Verdun66** » Mon 09 May 2011 11:43pm

That will be the Ball decision.....

Devilhead · Mon 09 May 2011 11:46pm

Thought McQ did ok tonight - not our worst

BringBackMadDog · Mon 09 May 2011 11:53pm

BigMart wrote:What do you think jonesy....rather than just commenting on what i think...

Goddard......is he in the right position, match up???

Game breaker, and now he has turned him into a tagger......and nick, our other gun, reduced to playing as a crash and bash target for the high ball.....

What next, milney playing as a small defender.....dal a tagger

I think one of ross's aims is to make every player on the list be a GOP

What game were u watching? Goddard was beign tagged by Gibbs not the other way around

BringBackMadDog · Mon 09 May 2011 11:53pm

BigMart wrote:What do you think jonesy....rather than just commenting on what i think...

Goddard......is he in the right position, match up???

Game breaker, and now he has turned him into a tagger......and nick, our other gun, reduced to playing as a crash and bash target for the high ball.....

What next, milney playing as a small defender.....dal a tagger

I think one of ross's aims is to make every player on the list be a GOP

What game were u watching? Goddard was beign tagged by Gibbs not the other way around

saintkid · Post: # 1071623Post **saintkid** » Tue 10 May 2011 12:06am

NoMore wrote:
meher baba wrote:Mini won some hard ball and made some good tackles, including a crucial holding the ball. He made some mistakes, but he wasn't Robinson Crusoe there.

You anonymous Internet heroes are infantile in the way you all gang up on one player and bag the crap out of him. I'd like to see some of you on an AFL field. Actually I wouldn't: the rear end of a brown-stained pair of shorts in retreat is not a pretty sight.

Thats funny
Last time i checked i wasn't paid good money to play AFL. i am paid to do my job and i do a much better job of it than what he is doing of playing football. It is not just tonight we have been bagging him. We are sick of seeing him out there. It is 2 years since he played a decent game. Just get rid of him

Yep, what he said. Get rid of the dud.

Enrico_Misso · Tue 10 May 2011 12:28am

Two critical errors by Mini led to Carlton goals.
He's not good enough.

Teflon · Post: # 1071669Post **Teflon** » Tue 10 May 2011 12:35am

BigMart wrote:Just an pbservation, what do you think?? Again instead of a silly comment, give us a thought....

One things for sure....we will have another coach in 2012...

It will not be me...No, but it will be another...

And all the in ross we trust posters will turn on him soon....around R13...perhaps you will be one

I for one think ross has been outstanding, until this year....he made a fatal decision

This is just cr@p.

IF we as a club get rid of Lyon then we have lost ethe plot.

You have made some valid points in the past re Lyon but you over emphasis the coach and dont put enough emphasis on players being responsible for their performance.

Goddard was a star in 2009/2010....now you reckon Lyon is somehow turning him into a dud? Wake up. These guys are paid AFL professional footballers who when they cross that line are RESPONSIBLE for their efforts.

Stop taking the simplistic view and blaming the coach - start looking for where some of the blame lies. Riewoldts goal kicking is deplorable. Goddard is in/out of the game and is now struggling with some opposition attention - HE needs to work through that in the manner Hayes, Harvey etc have done before him.