We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

SaintPav · Post: # 1069460Post **SaintPav** » Wed 04 May 2011 9:30am

Cairnsman wrote: it is my view that club comes before individuals then so-be-it.

Take a good dose of your own advice.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1069464Post **Mr Magic** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:19am

Cairnsman wrote:Get used to the heat being poured on Roo and BJ because most pundits can see that there is something wrong with them. They are not above the club.

And herein lies the problem.
Please point out any post in this debacle of a thread which argues that you don't have the right to criticize Roo or BJ or any other player.

The objection from me (and seemingly most others) is purely to your characterization that they are a 'cancer' in the Club.

You just don't understand that might be insensitive to some?
You just don't understand that it might be objectionable to some?
You just don't understand that it might be hurtful to some?

Or you just don't care?

Thinline · Post: # 1069468Post **Thinline** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:26am

He kind of strikes me as a cross between Bob Katter and Andrew Bolt. Character-driven opinion. Yeah, the term's gonna turn a few heads, but really, that's why he used it, so there, he wins. Yawn. It's hardly a new trick.

Dr Spaceman · Wed 04 May 2011 10:27am

Mr Magic wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Get used to the heat being poured on Roo and BJ because most pundits can see that there is something wrong with them. They are not above the club.
And herein lies the problem.
Please point out any post in this debacle of a thread which argues that you don't have the right to criticize Roo or BJ or any other player.

The objection from me (and seemingly most others) is purely to your characterization that they are a 'cancer' in the Club.

You just don't understand that might be insensitive to some?
You just don't understand that it might be objectionable to some?
You just don't understand that it might be hurtful to some?

Or you just don't care?

Agree MM

Although the word cancer may have several definitions its use in this thread would be hurtful to those whose life's have been touched by the disease.

But also, the use of the word is extremely disrespectful of two great servants of our footy club.

IMO of course.

bigcarl · Post: # 1069529Post **bigcarl** » Wed 04 May 2011 4:05pm

Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?

New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.

Cairnsman · Post: # 1069533Post **Cairnsman** » Wed 04 May 2011 4:15pm

bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.

Would Roo work at CHB?

plugger66 · Post: # 1069552Post **plugger66** » Wed 04 May 2011 5:22pm

Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?

Only at the GC.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1069565Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 04 May 2011 5:53pm

Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?

Thought you wanted him (and Goddard) 'cut out'

Cairnsman · Post: # 1069567Post **Cairnsman** » Wed 04 May 2011 6:02pm

MCG-Unit wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?
Thought you wanted him (and Goddard) 'cut out'

Just the cancer

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1069570Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 04 May 2011 6:06pm

Cairnsman wrote:
MCG-Unit wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?
Thought you wanted him (and Goddard) 'cut out'
Just the cancer

Well you wrote 'We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)'

What does that mean, apart from being a disgraceful heading ?

Cairnsman · Post: # 1069575Post **Cairnsman** » Wed 04 May 2011 6:20pm

MCG-Unit wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
MCG-Unit wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?
Thought you wanted him (and Goddard) 'cut out'
Just the cancer
Well you wrote 'We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)'

What does that mean, apart from being a disgraceful heading ?

If it is a serious question then read back through the post and you might find your answer(s).

desertsaint · Wed 04 May 2011 6:32pm

trade them both to the suns so you can continue to support them?

ralphsmith · Wed 04 May 2011 9:42pm

God

Ddd

ddd

Ard.

No, we shan't be removing him from the team.

SaintPav · Post: # 1069608Post **SaintPav** » Wed 04 May 2011 9:52pm

Cairnsman wrote: I'd trade Goddard.

You make me want to puke. You are a weirdo.

DWOODROW · Post: # 1069622Post **DWOODROW** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:10pm

Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?

I reckon Goddard would be much better there.
I really reckon he was made to play this position

SaintPav · Post: # 1069627Post **SaintPav** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:16pm

DWOODROW wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?
I reckon Goddard would be much better there.
I really reckon he was made to play this position

Only problem is that the CHB as we knew it is basically obsolete with the way the game is being played at the moment.

SaintPav · Post: # 1069628Post **SaintPav** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:17pm

ralphsmith wrote:God

Ddd

ddd

Ard.

No, we shan't be removing him from the team.

Excellent....the good old days....

DWOODROW · Post: # 1069630Post **DWOODROW** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:25pm

SaintPav wrote:
DWOODROW wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Anyone got any ideas?
New roles for Goddard and Riewoldt. Roo to wing, Goddard to FF.

See if that can't snap them ... and the team ... out of their malaise.

Gotta try something and it's worth a shot.
Would Roo work at CHB?
I reckon Goddard would be much better there.
I really reckon he was made to play this position
Only problem is that the CHB as we knew it is basically obsolete with the way the game is being played at the moment.

Could he play a role like fisher perhaps though.
I reckon his leadership(when he is up) would be beneficial to direct people around and rebound off half back.maybe I,m a little old fashioned

Thinline · Post: # 1069632Post **Thinline** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:26pm

I just want him to go out there like Ablett does for the Suns and say 'f*** it I'm better than this s***, I'm gonna rise above.'

He will soon. Too good not to.

DWOODROW · Post: # 1069635Post **DWOODROW** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:30pm

Thinline wrote:I just want him to go out there like Ablett does for the Suns and say 'f*** it I'm better than this s***, I'm gonna rise above.'

He will soon. Too good not to.

That sounds good to

Dr Spaceman · Wed 04 May 2011 10:30pm

Thinline wrote:I just want him to go out there like Ablett does for the Suns and say 'f*** it I'm better than this s***, I'm gonna rise above.'

He will soon. Too good not to.

It will happen one day - soon!

And then this thread will look even more stupid than it currently does; hard to believe I know

saint58 · Post: # 1069641Post **saint58** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:52pm

plugger66 wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
plugger66 wrote:Disgraceful thread.
Why so?
Because it is crap. Can you understand that.l

Why are we driving wedges through the club and players like this.With all the crap that was out in the media over the last 2 years other people have been gunning for us.

Lets stick it up them and hang tough ok we have problems and i think playing the kids is a good idear we could weed out the ones that carnt play.But iam allso very excited about the rest of this year and next year.

We are just reloading with a young energetic team some guys will have 30,40 games under there belt it is exciting times ahead.

Look how Armo,steven,smith,cripps,are playing good footy,as long as we keep trying the young guys and dont revert back to the old fellars.

OUR BLOODY WINDOW IS WIDE OPEN STILL KEEP THE FAITH

SainterK · Post: # 1069642Post **SainterK** » Wed 04 May 2011 10:54pm

Cairnsman, you can edit your first post and change the heading if you wish.

Perhaps 'Roo and Goddard are not above being dropped'

Or whatever the point is you are trying to make, have to be honest, I don't quite grasp it myself.

saintnick12 · Thu 05 May 2011 9:40am

BigMart wrote:I honestly believe people who critisise nick and to a lesser extent bj to anymore of an extent than they have been disappointing So far in 2011

Need to refresh thier memories.....

Given nick has given 10 years of excellence....possibly, arguably our greatest player....

Bj has, since 2007 gone from, good to very good to elite......

Same goes for dal, joey, sam, blakey, bakes, milney, lenny....this group has played through and largely been responsible for one of our greatest eras

Haven't been on here much lately (buying a house and selling mine = too busy), but I honestly cannot believe the way some supporters have dropped off our stars. I am absolutely staggered.
The above pretty sums up my feeling. Two of our greatest ever players are being blamed for destroying the club's chances and as a result people want to get rid of one or both of them....amazing...absolutely amazing.

Both have enough credits in the bank I would have thought.
Both were lauded as Gods virtually - about 7 games ago (BJ in GF one and two) and a few games before that Roo in the earlier finals.
Yet less than 10 games later people are accusing them of destroying the club and wanting to see what they are worth in the market place.
I honestly shake my head.
We wonder why people say we self destruct from the inside out....

IluvHarvey · Thu 05 May 2011 10:16am

WOW ............ just Wow!!

We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)

Re: We have to cut the cancer out (Goddard and Roo)