Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
" I am a loyal person and at the end of my career it will be great to look back and know I am a St Kilda person for life. That was something that has heavily influenced my decision.â€
StNoodles wrote:Dowler and Peterson would be worth a look.
Dowler had limited opportunities with Roughy and Buddy. High draft pick.
Peterson has a bit of speed and X factor.
Dowler's a dud. NO WAY. Hawk supporters I know cringed every time he got picked. He slower than Kosi, and smaller than him and can't kick or mark as as well as him. He's not as aggressive either.
And Kos is hanging on by his fingernails as far as I'm concerned.
sainterinsydney wrote:Could Peterson be worth a gamble at pick 70 or 90 odd? If we could get Peterson with a late draft pick, maybe it would be worth it?
Potentially good player, but take a look at my post about him above.
Wayde Skipper could be worth a look at...even allowing for the fact that it was his run down and tackle of Xavier Clarke at Williamstown last year that resulted in X Clarkes knee injury
zebraman wrote:Wayde Skipper could be worth a look at...even allowing for the fact that it was his run down and tackle of Xavier Clarke at Williamstown last year that resulted in X Clarkes knee injury
Yes really looks the goods. We should try to draft him.
zebraman wrote:Wayde Skipper could be worth a look at...even allowing for the fact that it was his run down and tackle of Xavier Clarke at Williamstown last year that resulted in X Clarkes knee injury
Yes really looks the goods. We should try to draft him.
Hahahahahahaha, I love your consistency in sarcasm. It's comittment.
Thought Kayler-Thomson a bit stiff. Watched him a bit as I work with one of his relatives.
Promoted from rookie list at the start of the year due to the Hawks injuries and played Round 1. Played a few senior games but was in Box Hills best more often that not
The one thing every one of those players have in common is inconsistancy. Can remember almost all of them playing one blinder for the Hawks but remember hearing plenty of them for Box Hill too
saint66au wrote:Thought Kayler-Thomson a bit stiff. Watched him a bit as I work with one of his relatives.
Promoted from rookie list at the start of the year due to the Hawks injuries and played Round 1. Played a few senior games but was in Box Hills best more often that not
One soft-as-butter game against Essendon stamped his papers. Might be worth a look.
"... You want to pose a threat to the opposition in as many ways as you can, both defensively and offensively. We've got a responsibility to explore all those possibilities - and we will."
Not one of these players are worth a look at unless you are female and they are good looking. We complain we have to many ordinary players already and we want rejects who either cant play or have poor attitudes.
plugger66 wrote:Not one of these players are worth a look at unless you are female and they are good looking. We complain we have to many ordinary players already and we want rejects who either cant play or have poor attitudes.
Yes Leigh Brown and Goldsack are ordinary players IMO, yet they just played in a winning GF side - depends how they're coached, and used on the field........
Michael Barlow was considered an ordinary player, overlooked in drafts
MCG-Unit wrote:Yes Leigh Brown and Goldsack are ordinary players IMO, yet they just played in a winning GF side - depends how they're coached, and used on the field........
Michael Barlow was considered an ordinary player, overlooked in drafts
plugger66 wrote:Not one of these players are worth a look at unless you are female and they are good looking. We complain we have to many ordinary players already and we want rejects who either cant play or have poor attitudes.
Hamill & Gehrig were high class recruits.
King, Schneider, Dempster, Ray & Peake have either been very good or handy but were secured by trading draft picks.
Can people name one decent player we've picked up after they were delisted by another club?
I'm with p66 on this one.
No more rejects already! Let's back our established players+our developing players+kids we pick up in the 2010 draft.