Delistings?

Buckets · Post: # 1011553Post **Buckets** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:05am

How many players will we delist? And who will be the unlucky ones?

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:07am

Cahill ??

borderbarry · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:18am

How is Wil Johnson coming on? Is he worth persevering with?

Tom_Sainter · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:21am

Would think Cahill, Johnson, L.Fisher and J.Smith will all be de-listed

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:22am

borderbarry wrote:How is Wil Johnson coming on? Is he worth persevering with?

not IMHO. bit of a blue-eyed cod from all reports. just doesn't have enough mongrel in him.

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:23am

Tom_Sainter wrote:Would think Cahill, Johnson, L.Fisher and J.Smith will all be de-listed

good call

JABBER · Post: # 1011595Post **JABBER** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:36am

King, Lovett, , armitage Blake J Smith Johnson.L fisher J allen (rookies)

Walsh and Simpkton promoted

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:38am

king lovett allen yes blake no

ausfatcat · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:43am

lol blake seriously?

Your suggesting the saints delist blake.

Just about all your posts make me laugh jabber, I just dread the day you accidently get something right.

fingers · Post: # 1011612Post **fingers** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:53am

ChicagoSaint wrote:
borderbarry wrote:How is Wil Johnson coming on? Is he worth persevering with?
not IMHO. bit of a blue-eyed cod from all reports. just doesn't have enough mongrel in him.

What is a blue-eyed cod?

ausfatcat · Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:54am

soft I think fingers

Buckets · Post: # 1011616Post **Buckets** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 11:55am

So if we were to get rid of the following:

King - Retired
Lovett - Knob
Smith - Retired
Allen - Retired
L. Fisher - Retired
Cahill - Delist
Johnson - Delist

Now 2 are on the Rookie list yeah?
Walsh is already promoted
Simpkin a possibility???

How likely is it that we will be able to effectively pick 3-4 young kids from the draft that is already compromised by the Suns and our first pick is early 20's?????

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 12:36pm

ausfatcat wrote:
fingers wrote:
ChicagoSaint wrote:
borderbarry wrote:How is Wil Johnson coming on? Is he worth persevering with?
not IMHO. bit of a blue-eyed cod from all reports. just doesn't have enough mongrel in him.
What is a blue-eyed cod?
soft I think fingers

and slow. plods around on the bed most of the time.

saintly · Post: # 1011671Post **saintly** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 12:55pm

ChicagoSaint wrote:Cahill ??

why Cahill?

FQF · Post: # 1011672Post **FQF** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 12:57pm

saintly wrote:
ChicagoSaint wrote:Cahill ??
why Cahill?

Getting no where apparently.

dcstkfc · Post: # 1011674Post **dcstkfc** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:02pm

ausfatcat wrote:lol blake seriously?

Your suggesting the saints delist blake.

Just about all your posts make me laugh jabber, I just dread the day you accidently get something right.

Not to mention he has a contract.

Blake will be top 10 in the BnF for the 4th straight year.

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:05pm

FQF wrote:
saintly wrote:
ChicagoSaint wrote:Cahill ??
why Cahill?
Getting no where apparently.

just not tough enough.

mad saint guy · Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:11pm

Retire: King, Baker, Smith
Delist: Lovett, Johnson, Cahill, McGrath (r), L.Fisher (r), Allen (r)
Promote: Simpkin, Walsh, Gaertner

Leaving three senior spots and six rookie spots. If we need room for another player Pattison could go.

ChicagoSaint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:15pm

they may be hoping patto can develop into a mentor.

older saint · Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:17pm

mad saint guy wrote:Retire: King, Baker, Smith
Delist: Lovett, Johnson, Cahill, McGrath (r), L.Fisher (r), Allen (r)
Promote: Simpkin, Walsh, Gaertner

Leaving three senior spots and six rookie spots. If we need room for another player Pattison could go.

Unless you know something we don't i would be at pains to delist McGrath. Size takes a long time. remember Sandilands was hopeless at 21 now look at him. Patience

saintly · Post: # 1011690Post **saintly** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:19pm

older saint wrote:
mad saint guy wrote:Retire: King, Baker, Smith
Delist: Lovett, Johnson, Cahill, McGrath (r), L.Fisher (r), Allen (r)
Promote: Simpkin, Walsh, Gaertner

Leaving three senior spots and six rookie spots. If we need room for another player Pattison could go.
Unless you know something we don't i would be at pains to delist McGrath. Size takes a long time. remember Sandilands was hopeless at 21 now look at him. Patience

the problem is mcgrath is already in his thrid year i believe. we would have to promote him. or delist him and then put him back on.

Dr Spaceman · Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:25pm

saintly wrote:
older saint wrote:
mad saint guy wrote:Retire: King, Baker, Smith
Delist: Lovett, Johnson, Cahill, McGrath (r), L.Fisher (r), Allen (r)
Promote: Simpkin, Walsh, Gaertner

Leaving three senior spots and six rookie spots. If we need room for another player Pattison could go.
Unless you know something we don't i would be at pains to delist McGrath. Size takes a long time. remember Sandilands was hopeless at 21 now look at him. Patience
the problem is mcgrath is already in his thrid year i believe. we would have to promote him. or delist him and then put him back on.

Clearly you wouldn't promote the guy.

But seeing as he's been injured, or when not, running around in the Sandy seconds this year, after failing to push for promtion previously, there's a fair chance he won't be snapped up by a rival club if we wish to go down the delist/re-rookie road.

Don't know too much about him but he's big big as opposed to just big. I believe he may also be quite quick and athletic for his size. So with all that in mind I would like to see him retained a bit longer in some capacity.

hotdish · Post: # 1011704Post **hotdish** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:35pm

SENIOR LIST

Delist:

Steven King
Andrew Lovett
Jesse Smith
Steven Baker (retiring?)
Paul Cahill (re-rookie)

ROOKIE LIST

Delist:
Leigh Fisher
Jarryd Allen

Promote:
Tom Simpkin (RL says he'll get more chances - http://tiny.cc/htlts)

Retain:
Blake McGrath
Tommy Walsh
Daniel Archer
Mark Hutchings
Steven Gaertner

NOTES:

Whats the veterans list situation?

Currently:

Lenny Hayes (V+) "Veteran outside list of 38"
Steven Baker (V) - "Veteran on list of 38"

Most teams have two players who are (V+), but we only have one. Why?

Surely Riewoldt will be promoted to the veterans list now.

saintlee · Post: # 1011705Post **saintlee** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 1:35pm

Dr Spaceman wrote:
saintly wrote:
older saint wrote:
mad saint guy wrote:Retire: King, Baker, Smith
Delist: Lovett, Johnson, Cahill, McGrath (r), L.Fisher (r), Allen (r)
Promote: Simpkin, Walsh, Gaertner

Leaving three senior spots and six rookie spots. If we need room for another player Pattison could go.
Unless you know something we don't i would be at pains to delist McGrath. Size takes a long time. remember Sandilands was hopeless at 21 now look at him. Patience
the problem is mcgrath is already in his thrid year i believe. we would have to promote him. or delist him and then put him back on.
Clearly you wouldn't promote the guy.

But seeing as he's been injured, or when not, running around in the Sandy seconds this year, after failing to push for promtion previously, there's a fair chance he won't be snapped up by a rival club if we wish to go down the delist/re-rookie road.

Don't know too much about him but he's big big as opposed to just big. I believe he may also be quite quick and athletic for his size. So with all that in mind I would like to see him retained a bit longer in some capacity.

The word on the AFL.com Saints chat that is happening at the moment, is McGrath has not come on at all, and will probably be cut.

plugger66 · Post: # 1011749Post **plugger66** » Wed 06 Oct 2010 2:37pm

Why would they delis Johnson. They will still have to pay him so what is the point. I think we have enough picks without delisting guys who need to be paid.

Delistings?

Delistings?

delistings