I’m not writing this off like a lot of others are. I can recall two occasions where the club used our first round picks to prioritise the “types” of players we apparently needed against the best players available. First, picks 7 and 8 on Clark and Coffield. Second and perhaps the worst use of a numb...

I’ve only watch half the interview, but from what I’ve seen so far, I thought it was quite good. Interesting comment from Bassett regarding the previous mindset of the club - that success is cyclical and as long as we don’t piss people off, our time will come. A perspective that really seemed to res...

Confirming my GT dislike for all these years utter megalomaniac “CEO and coach” what a knob jockey Butters not much better but at least sacked him Give Lyon that side with Hamil Gehrig younger Harvey Hudgton Pecket Jones plus kids like Roo , Dal etc when they all came in = multiple flags Thomas did...

My question is are Collingwood just desperate for key forwards (hence the two year deal) and rolling the dice, or can Members realistically squeeze out another two years and we just decided he’s surplus to requirements? He was definitely a heart and soul player and as much as it pains me that he goe...

I liked it. I’m sick of being good AFL citizens and just taking it up rear end. The timing is interesting regarding Battle. Maybe the writing is on the wall that we’re going to get shafted on the compo pick and the club is having a behind-the-scenes crack. Although I do agree with Hanners somewhat, ...

While in one hand it may sound petty, but there is likely more than one side to this story. If players and staff alike are snubbing Battle, it may be more than just sour grapes. As good a player as Battle is, we aren’t losing a league top fiver. Maybe there is discontent as to how Battle handled the...

For those who tried to justify our most recent loss to Port because they’re apparently a bloody good side - LOL

Great career The most underrated player (by supporters) in my memory The only dual B&F whipping boy I know of 211 games 2 x B&F 1 x Runner Up B&F AA squad 7 years in leadership group Vice Captain (acting captain for a season) I respect all saints players, particularly the good ones. He ...

GT loves attention and this tweet is akin to what he does to obtain that. However, looking at his tweet objectively, I think it would be a bad move to trade Sinclair and Steele. They’re heart and soul players, two of our best and we “need” their experience, now more than ever. We tried that trading...

GT loves attention and this tweet is akin to what he does to obtain that. However, looking at his tweet objectively, I think it would be a bad move to trade Sinclair and Steele. They’re heart and soul players, two of our best and we “need” their experience, now more than ever. We tried that trading ...

AR: Is his diabetes a problem Trout: Nope, in fact it’s a positive, it’ll make him better because he has to manage it I s*** you not! His skin folds are off the charts, is that an issue? Nope, he hired a personal trainer We need this bloke to be a ripper! Yep, he’s our man Comes from a good family,...

As a kid my favorite player was Darrell Baldock, then a bit later a Tony Lockett fan. Barry Breen and Andrew Thompson were also given the honor of wearing the revered number 4 jumper. Can anybody recall the recent circumstances where the number 4 has been allocated? Clint Jones, which I thought fla...

i have just read the Statement the club released. Having read it now a few times it is concerning to me that the club has openly admitted that they considered recruiting this person, in spite of what has happened and other clubs and the AFL cutting him lose.- yes not guilty in court yet doesn't mea...

Max was an excellent key back. Zac was serviceable. There is a difference Curly. Of course there is but don't downplay Zac Dawson. Can't remember having a key forward kick a big bag on him while he was with us. Every key forward has a bag kicked on them, even if only sporadically. Even Max had his ...

About bloody time!!!

Don’t underestimate the strength a rebrand can have to an organisation, especially one marred with so little success.

Max was an excellent key back. Zac was serviceable.

There is a difference Curly.

Bruce was useful at best - noting the contribution at WB (where he kicked 10 against a bottom side on one occasion but not much else) I seem to recall WB put him back to defence where he started out And all is now revealed - Vottex is Donald Trump!!! In the last two season though, King has been pla...

I can 100% assure you we will not pay overs. Josh will do what’s best for his family-as he should ; yet the St Kilda footy club decade after decade cut loose great players often for little return Like who? only ones I can think of the last 30 years is Hall and maybe acres. and Considering Hall want...

Luke Penny was a full back in the traditional sense. He only played two and a half seasons with us. In his first two full seasons, he took 23 and 17 contested marks. In the same years Matt Maguire took 21 and 22 contested marks. Once Penny did his knee in 2005, missing the finals, Max eventually to...

I’m sure Goodwin wants his best players like Billings to be in tip top form in the run up to September. I’m sure Billings will get good numbers at Casey. Looking forward to the VFL this week and I’ll be a keen watcher …NOT NOT watching? Pity. As the forum numbers man, I was hoping you'd post a bit ...

tony74 wrote: ↑Sat 03 Aug 2024 10:13am I can 100% assure you we will not pay overs. Josh will do what’s best for his family-as he should

No. Instead, you’ll let him walk out for the sake of your own pinheadedness and overpay less performing players who were selected earlier in the draft.

Luke Penny was a full back in the traditional sense. He only played two and a half seasons with us. In his first two full seasons, he took 23 and 17 contested marks. In the same years Matt Maguire took 21 and 22 contested marks. Once Penny did his knee in 2005, missing the finals, Max eventually to...

Luke Penny was a full back in the traditional sense. He only played two and a half seasons with us. In his first two full seasons, he took 23 and 17 contested marks. In the same years Matt Maguire took 21 and 22 contested marks. Once Penny did his knee in 2005, missing the finals, Max eventually to...

CURLY wrote: ↑Thu 01 Aug 2024 12:56pm David Neitz used to get hold of Max for some reason. Max had a tremendous leap and closing speed chose to punch more than Wilkie.

That was in 2006 from memory.

I’m sure Goodwin wants his best players like Billings to be in tip top form in the run up to September. I’m sure Billings will get good numbers at Casey. Looking forward to the VFL this week and I’ll be a keen watcher …NOT NOT watching? Pity. As the forum numbers man, I was hoping you'd post a bit ...