How the F*** does Wright get selected in front of a bloke who plays the same position and kicked 5 in the magoos last week? No doubt he puts in hard at training but surely he needs to Show some sort of form.. ever, to get selected? It was an absolutely mystifying selection. With no membry and Bruce ...

Without getting emotional, would someone care to outline Paddy’s attributes? The one thing you would think we’d be banking on would be his hands. He may be slow, unfit and only able to run in straight lines, but surely the recruiters would have banked on the ‘clunk’. On the basis of three years of e...

Any tech savvy sainters out there have advice on how I might get a hold of the match replay in the absence of Foxtel?

Interestingly after 5 goals in the first quarter, the player who did most damage to us on the scoreboard was Le Cras with 6 goals. So who had the responsibility for him? It should have been Dempster, who has a good record against him, as he does against most small/mid fwds. Unfortunately he was oth...

It was a mystery at selection and certainly no reason post game to think it was anything but complete fuckinh lunacy. Seriously, we are going to be so good in the midfield we will not need a single key position defender? It's just crazy. To be clear Dempster is not a kpd and should have been playing...

It's a bit of a catch22. If HB has his head on straight now and 100% committed to footy it's highly unlikely the Suns will let him go. If however they are shopping him with a deal we'd be willing to contemplate, I think you could assume he's still got unresolved issues.

The Riewoldt on the boundary 50m out set play is such a pointless exercise. Happens 15 times a game for maybe 1 goal

Fantastic offer Gill. I've sent you a pm, let me know if you get it. Very keen.

Massive last qtr. must have been at least 8 goals with the tigers hitting the front early on. Sandy really are a step ahead of the rest in terms of endurance, their last qtrs have been phenomenal

Couple of Jack's highlights from the Bombers game that I haven't seen mentioned, both from the third qtr I think. He ran back with the flight in defence and made the perfect spoil in the left pocket, not sure who on. Was super gutsy but also incredibly precise execution. He also kicked a carbon copy...

What exactly did he do that was good? He doesn't get much of the ball, he doesn't take many marks, his kicking not what it was reputed to be. I'm not really sure what he brings to the table.

I think he's been watching videos of Jodi Arnol.

Our kicking into 50 is as bad as I have ever seen it.

The ruck issue is so rediculously overblown on here. Fact is we have two very promising ruckmen with different skills sets, both with a lot to learn and develop into to become a-grade ruckmen. What they need is game time and patience. Clearly Longer brings more to the primary ruck role that Hickey i...

Unfortunate Lee isnt getting an opportunity given he has re-invented himself as a defender. Re-drafting Saad and then playing him in the first five games show the coaches don't get it right 100% of time. Sure they mostly get it right and know a lot more than the fans - but that doesnt make them per...

Lee is clearly the better performing player in the VFL, though Goddard has been very good also. But Lee has been either best on or close to it four weeks in a row and has well and truly earnt a call up. There's plenty of time to play Goddard, and far better games to debut in. It jut my opinion but I...

I'm not sure why people are so surprised and/or despondent about the last couple of losses. We didn't have a list that could legitimately compete at the start of the season and we certainly don't now with our two best players out. Just looking at the Carlton game, if you consider the two lists, who ...

Frees currently running at 18-7. Pendulbury has had mores frees than our entire team

I didn't see any of the game but F me, if I had to prove myself as an AFL footballer, key position fwd, coming off as injury interrupted pre-season, I would rather be playing just about anywhere in the league than the Saints forward line at the moment. Of the very few fwd entries we have, 80% go to ...

Dean Kemp played Teal Cup? Thats the whole point you <edited by mods>! We are talking about a top 2 pick in the draft- they dont have to come from the Teal Cup. Are you <edited by mods> Poster warned for abuse. The draft isnt restricted to TAC cup players - newsflash. And I thought you were going t...

Thought newnes had a really good game. Milera looked good with ball in hand and found some space toward the end but seemed incapable of kicking it either between the big sticks or to the advantage of a team mate. Worst game I have seen Schneider play, doesn't have the ticker for a rebuild I reckon

Yep, would rather they learn how to kick and lay a tackle

God please make it stop, I am fair ninkum going to spew

Love how Joey cops a ribbing but he has had it 15 times For starters he needs to be getting about double that as our best midfielder. Regardless his disposal has been terrible and decision making not much better. If that's a good game for him then he is a c grade player at best. I expect a lot more...

There are too many excuses being given out. They are significantly undermanned too and playing on our home ground and we have been absolutely thrashed. Coach has to have responsibility at some point. It's not being hysterical to say the coach has had a shocker and is generally struggling at the mome...

Love how Joey cops a ribbing but he has had it 15 times For starters he needs to be getting about double that as our best midfielder. Regardless his disposal has been terrible and decision making not much better. If that's a good game for him then he is a c grade player at best. I expect a lot more...