I'm not convinced Lyon is a good coach at all yet.

I think Lyon is doing well.

Same poster, and only 9 mins between posts. Amazing

So, our list is talented, and RL can coach. So we all agree now? Great, let's move on. :wink: I don't agree. We've played 1 month of good footy in 2 years. Even during that month, we still haven't played 4 quarters. The reason we've won, has been due to the efforts and ability of the following play...

The game plan hasn't changed it's just finally being executed properly. The massive midfield rotation Lyon has implemented is starting to pay dividends, we now have upwards of 12-13 guys going in there throughout the course of the game, and no longer relying on Bally and Hayes to do all the grunt wo...

2008 VFL Seniors Coburg Tigers 2.3 4.5 10.12 14.14 (98) Casey Scorpions 5.3 12.7 16.10 23.13 (151) GOALS: Coburg Tigers: Schulz 5 Pettifer 2 Howat 2 Carnell Tivendale Connors Collard Horne Casey Scorpions: Milne 4 Rix 3 Clarke 2 O'Bryan 2 Miles 2 Dunne 2 Garrubba 2 Birss Waite Howard Steven Haretuk...

We're not going to win games against anyone other than Melbourne and Freo if we can't kick more than 10 goals. He'll be back. Ideal side for the rest of 2008 B: Blake, Hudghton, Gilbert HB: Gram, S.Fisher, Goddard C: Armitage, Hayes, Montagna HF: Birss, Riewoldt, X.Clarke F: Allen, Koschitzke, Miln...

Well you certainly can't complain about the players' effort tonight, but if it was against anyone but Freo (or Melbourne) we would have copped a spanking. Fremantle put in the most undisciplined, selfish, weak effort I have seen from any team in the past few years. Riewoldt - Probably played the be...

He was asked whether he subscribes to the view that he needs to revitalise and refresh the list and he said Yes and he talked about the quality of some of the recycled players he has drafted,which has only cost the club pick 26 effectively,and how the previous regime traded away first round draft p...

Why do people think list management is not part of a coach's responsibilties? It is one of his most important roles. It is his job to ensure the list does not fall back rapidly. Definitely the coaches responsibilty. Since Grant Thomas inherited a host of players due to the appointment of Blight and...

Robert Harvey - Always a dodgy selection with a calf at 37yo......NO! Sam Gilbert - Has not played in 8 weeks, looked like 10..........NO! Should...... David Armitage played instead of Banger.........YES! Shane Birss played instead of Gilbert..........YES! Should....... Charlie Gardner have come in...

If the coaching panel know what there doing, they are doing a damn good job of hiding the fact..... What evidenve is there that shows that Ross knows what he is doing.... A NAB Cup! Win a game against good opposition, and there will be kudos....until then nothing from me ...we have beaten NO-ONE! I...

yes and in that 1.5 years he's brought in a heap of insta-retirees and good players have gone backwards or stayed stagnant. Even sides we've beaten we've done so on raw talent not any wizzbang strat from ross Its definitely all RL's fault, i mean GT did leave him the very talented kids that he draf...

Unfortunately i agree. We are better off playing the youngsters, hardly winning another game for the rest of the year and finishing as low as we can. The problem i see with us, is that we will continue to beat the rubbish below us (Ess, Car, Rich etc) and therefore finish as we have the past 2 seaso...

Once again the original poster compared Riewoldt's kicking to that of Fevola, Pavlich, Franklin and Hall.

This thread is laughable

Couldn't agree more. Riewoldt's goalkicking is about as reliable as the Melbourne train service running on time

so let me get this straight i'm not allowed to point out that Fev failed to score twice having set shots i'm not allowed to point out that Pav missed from 25 out directly infront i'm not allowed to point out that RIcho missed from 15m out i'm not allowed to point out that Roughhead missed from 20m ...

saintsRrising wrote:Fiora's last game you would expect

Lets hope so. For a guy that surely knows his career is on the line, he was pathetic again. He did have alot of mates though.

That shot Riewoldt just had from 48m pretty much sums up how ridiculous those percentages are. Doesn't make the distance so therefore not included as a missed shot on goal. His kicking is terrible

We should relocate to the Gold Coast, unfortunately they don't want to start with a rabble! I'm gutted!!! Lyon will cop a lot from this but so should 6 to 10 players, some of the most putrid, vile, inept performances by any human priveledged to wear a St Kilda jumper. Thank God the Clarkes aren't p...

Michael Gardiner would get my vote for worst player in the competition. Special mention to Michael Rix. Go on Joey!! I would have look at Grams game today.... I don't think I'll bother downloading this one LOL Im sure Gram's been horrible, but when it comes to the worst player in the competition, G...

i listened to the second half of the Carlton-Freo game today, and in that time FEV failed to score twice from shots at goal, and on another occasion just managed to squeeze it in for a point. Also PAV kicked one out on the full, and also hit the post from 25m out, directly in front, with the game o...

Ive seen a quicker looking group at the near by retirement village

We are absolutely shite. Two on one and they still f#@k it up

Jayden Attard (r) - Ordinary tagger. Not worth senior list spot

Did you actually watch any footy last year? [/code]

We never had such little improvement until Lyon took over. Every year we had a few players emerging from nowhere and a few reasonable players taking the next step and becoming guns. Under Lyon we've just had a couple of kids improve in their second year and two fringe players get more game time. It...

-5 please

Dunno Boppa. Looked at the last two seasons. I'm starting to wondering if it's the 'GT lovers' who keep brining him up. Anyway, We would have promoted Attard, we promoted Jones - I wouldn't staple that to my resume. Is Geary the other? He looks to have a bit about him. I'm still not as happy with d...