B.M wrote: ↑Thu 21 Nov 2024 7:42pm Some KPP forwards hadn’t debuted by his current age

I will defer to your knowledge of kpp who hadn't debuted by 20/21 (which he turns in 2 weeks). Care to name a few from the modern era because I can't think of any who ended up making it.

Lol they are trolling. They saw the outrage from some corners and said "f*** it 5 defenders here we go"

He is only 20yo though. Yes, he is raw and come from a long way back. But he’s a powerful lad who’s shown glimpses I’m keen to see if he can play a bit at CHB He has only kicked more than two goals in a game once in 33 games. I hope he does make it (like I hope everyone in a Saints guernsey does), ...

Lucky to win the flag? Not sure they would see it that way. Getting players for less than they are worth, what does it matter where you finish? Might need to reread my post there BM. I didn't just say they were lucky to win the flag. And I think you are agreeing with me, Curly suggested it was unfa...

I'm not convinced Hammer makes it yet, averaging a goal a game basically so needs to have a big year coming up. So adding some more potential there is top of the list I think.

By essentially two top ten picks, do you mean pick 5 and pick 25? Ashcroft and Marshall both extremely highly rated. Ashcroft rated 1 by most and Marshall who was BOG in the Grand Final in a team Ashcroft was in. Lol, 'essentially' doing a lot of work there. The reality is, regardless of where they...

How about Garcia as a small/lockdown defender? Unless he can really step up I feel like he might get squeezed out of our midfield with the crop already in front of him and any new free agents/recruits. But he has pace, hates to be beaten and loves a tackle. Maybe a question on his overhead work, but...

By essentially two top ten picks, do you mean pick 5 and pick 25?

Which was a load of s***! Also, don’t like the fact it’s smaller and below the sponsor. I like the crest bigger and on the chest (heart) On the draftees, the crest was small and under the pec Looked crap I am once again begging people to read the clubs release about the crest. The new crest is larg...

Have you heard of best 2 available? Very debatable that these are best available. I think Allen and Armstrong are better prospects. Appears to be more need based recruitments to me. Defense is our best area of the field so unless we are planning 2-3 years ahead (and still I think mids and forwards ...

Have you heard of best 2 available? Very debatable that these are best available. I think Allen and Armstrong are better prospects. Appears to be more need based recruitments to me. Defense is our best area of the field so unless we are planning 2-3 years ahead (and still I think mids and forwards ...

Have you heard of best 2 available? Very debatable that these are best available. I think Allen and Armstrong are better prospects. Appears to be more need based recruitments to me. Defense is our best area of the field so unless we are planning 2-3 years ahead (and still I think mids and forwards ...

Would love to see the math on how a couple of 80 minute plane rides over 5 weeks is going to derail our whole season 8-) Not so much the plane ride that is the issue it’s the nature of the crowd. It is immense on Adelaide away days, never see more one sided crowds which definitely impacts performan...

So: No Fortius Quo Fidelius? No Strength Through Loyalty? Ummmm ...... https://www.saints.com.au/news/730079/strength-through-loyalty-the-culture https://www.amazon.com.au/Harves-Strength-Through-Robert-Harvey-ebook/dp/B006G72DIS https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Otv1TunwT8M https://saintsmembership....

desertsaint wrote: ↑Tue 19 Nov 2024 5:33pm bring back the latin.

The Latin is still there, just in the hem of the guernsey.

This just gets it out of the logo to make it more versatile for marketing.

https://www.saints.com.au/news/1694265/this-is-st-kilda-saints-unveil-new-crest It’s fine I guess, not sure it was overly worth the change. Good detail from that news post Due to the unified nature of the new logo, the Crest is now able to be enlarged in key areas, such as on the front of the guern...

Beno88 wrote: ↑Fri 09 Aug 2024 9:32am The "ST.K.F.C." will be replaced by "ST KILDA" and the ribbon including the motto will be removed.

Good call early.

Ribbon still there but minimised. Looks really good overall.

Cal Twomey’s phantom drafts have been incredibly accurate over the past 4 years, I think he’s barely got a pick in top 20 wrong over that time (last year only missed Phoenix Gothard). He would have some intel on travaglia for sure, we’ll be picking him. I still think north would be crazy not to tra...

Cal Twomey’s phantom drafts have been incredibly accurate over the past 4 years, I think he’s barely got a pick in top 20 wrong over that time (last year only missed Phoenix Gothard). He would have some intel on travaglia for sure, we’ll be picking him. I still think north would be crazy not to tra...

Cal Twomey’s phantom drafts have been incredibly accurate over the past 4 years, I think he’s barely got a pick in top 20 wrong over that time (last year only missed Phoenix Gothard). He would have some intel on travaglia for sure, we’ll be picking him. I still think north would be crazy not to tra...

Cal twomey has us taking travaglia and tauru Disaster if that happens Must get a mid Any of the highly rated but not Reid Bite the bullet and trade out 8 and next year F1 for 2 Go hard now Get a future 2nd back if need be Don’t get bit players He does have all 7 picks before it's being mids, but th...

Weird, you still don't seem to be able to tell me which number in your assessment of the difficulty of our 2025 draw (which you claimed was so superior) actually represents our 2025 draw. Why would I be worked up? All I am asking you to do is explain how calculation relates to the difficulty of our...

Fox footy have released another phantom draft: https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/draft/phantom-draft-afl-2024-fox-footy-afl-phantom-mock-draft-2024-predictions-live-trades-bids-formguide-date-time/news-story/be023112f1bf1fcc17d4189df93fa5ab They have Draper sliding to us (a good deal for us, but I ca...

Weird, you still don't seem to be able to tell me which number in your assessment of the difficulty of our 2025 draw (which you claimed was so superior) actually represents our 2025 draw. Why would I be worked up? All I am asking you to do is explain how calculation relates to the difficulty of our...

Oh sorry, I must of missed your explanation of which part of your calculation assessing the difficulty of our 2025 draw (again you used 12, 9.5 and 2.5) actually represented the difficulty of our 2025 draw? Maybe it was in a post I didn't see because you didnt reply to me? Good thing that you have ...