Strange pick Barrat really came on in the second half of the season as a defender. He's slightly undersized to play as a genuine key defender, which is preventing him from garnering top 30 consideration despite impressive performances as a lockdown back and tagging midfielder. He went head to head ...

Why would Battle go to Hawks on less money, if he's thinking of his family's financial security? We keep hearing that Hawthorn is in the premiership window - wants to win a flag So he lauds the direction that the club is heading in under Ross Lyon, but still wants to get out the door because he doe...

Been having conflicted emotions the last few days considering what happens if we beat Carlton. Would love nothing more than to ruin their season, but is it worth Sliding to Pick 7? The Demons slaughtered their percentage, and Gold Coast couldn't bury the Tigers, so we'd overtake them both by percent...

Weitering would slot in nicely, but I'm almost certain they're not doing this because they expect to get Weitering. Up their salary cap, force them to release some mids, and at the same time show everyone we're cashed up enough to be putting out offers like that. Or we really have just lost the plot...

If that chump is in the best 40 defenders in Australia, then everyone that plays footy should be ashamed. He shouldn’t even be playing for Sandringham 2nds. Surely Lyon just scrubs him from the list. If you could do it you would do it yesterday. Durrr Annoyedsaint Give him a break ... indeed give m...

Proud of the boys fell short against probably the best side atm We will improve The bagging of the players on here is nothing short of embarrassing..s*** supporters People love to get on here and dog out the underperformers when most of them probably haven't had a kick in their lives. Sharman and B...

Bank the four points but learn from it and make some changes. Keeler or Heath for Caminiti, Windy for Jones, Garcia for Byrnes and Collard for Butler. Hastie needs game time probably at Sandy giving Jones a reprieve as the sub where he may have some impact later in a game. Not a lot of other option...

Hastie will presumably be the sub. I wonder why not Garcia? Hastie has got a bit more size to him than Garcia, which is probably what they want if he's coming in to replace Wood. As well as the fact that Hastie has played up on the wing where I'm not sure if Garcia is suited to the outside run, loo...

We all have to remember that Paddy Dow was recruited for that reason, he has the speed and the inside players will be needed to feed him. In every position (apart from the ruck) we have depth now. It's a long season, the players that are currently underdone will play a role. Wilson, Henry, Bonner a...

I’m a little perplexed as to why Crouch was dropped and Seb wasn’t. From what it seems Crouch is still a bit sore. Might need a little comeback through the VFL to get back to his best form. As for Ross, it really just comes down to he's all we have at the moment, even if he was painfully average ag...