As long as the top picks are any of the best top 10-12 I'll be fine. Even if we take Armstrong and Tauru I won't melt. We will be getting 2 of the best kids in a great draft.

Will come down to development after that

TheGreatZacsby wrote: ↑Tue 19 Nov 2024 3:21pm I’ve said this from the start.

Send Pick 7 and our F1 to North for a quality mid. Guarantee FOS / Draper / Smith / Langford.

Split Pick 8 for GWS 15/16 and grab best available.

That’s how you do Draft Night.

Yep, and North should jump at it.

We need A grade

We really need a top mid, we should be doing what we can to get at least one.
We have 7,8,32 and a full hand of futures.

Carlton got creative and now have pick 3 from nowhere.
We need to make some moves. Another B plus player isn't going to improve us, we need stars.

Really disappointing if we get two guys that are not pure mids The bulls*** of yeah, he will transition into a mid is rubbish 90% of mids are drafted mids 50% of drafted flankers were u18 mids Travaglia is a running back we have them and we need a midfield Tauru is a 3rd tall back Beware the bolter...

Really disappointing if we get two guys that are not pure mids The bulls*** of yeah, he will transition into a mid is rubbish 90% of mids are drafted mids 50% of drafted flankers were u18 mids Travaglia is a running back we have them and we need a midfield Tauru is a 3rd tall back Beware the bolter...

If we get Langford at #7, I'm splitting 8 If not Smilie and Reid Trade F1 for pick 20 (shanahan) Why would you trade future 1st round pick for 20 Normally I wouldnt, but the Top 20 are fantastic prospects. Have a look at Shanahan. Be very happy to snag him or even Taj Hotton (formerly top 5 rated) ...

If we get Langford at #7, I'm splitting 8

If not Smilie and Reid

Trade F1 for pick 20 (shanahan)

Looks like Langford is a chance to slide to us, if Norf take Tauru.

I'd be happy with that,and open to splitting 8 with GWS


Or take Reid

Not alot of speed in there though.

I'd like one of the mids we get to be a genuine speed freak.
Bo Allan seems to fit the bill for power and speed, issues with disposal efficiency though.

FOS Lalor Smith Draper Almost certainly gone before our pick If Tauru is taken by Norf (at pick 2 or 6) We have the possibility of Smilie or Reid Love to get them both , but would depend on Melbourne taking Armstrong, and I reckon they will take Smilie. Leaves us Reid with pick 7. If North take a mi...

Good call on Caminiti, Yorkeys, what a bonus he has been. Will be a really good player as he develops.

Pick 7 and F1 for North's p2 is being mooted
Pick 8 split for GWS 15, 16

I think I'd prefer to retain 7 & 8 and get a teens Pick for our F1. Surely Richmond would be interested.

Paton looks done to me.
Career ruined by Roughhead....he should feel guilty.

Hopefully we are trading our F1 for a teens pick this year.

Best of uck to Tim, one of my family favourites.
So many times he has taken that contested mark against bigger opponents.

He could well have a great year for the Pies. I wouldn't begrudge him a flag if it came to it. (As long as it wasn't vs Us)

Likely to be Reid and Smilie as long as one of the picks below us is for a tall.

Otherwise we'd get either Reid or Smilie, in which case we do a trade with GWS for 16, or we take Tauru....I like him.

Definitely need to trade F1 for a late first this year.

Reid
Tauru
Hotton
Hynes
Cole

Good haul

I'm hoping Tauru or Armstrong are taken earlier than our pick so we get a sliding midfielder.

Smilie.and Reid would be good

The Fireman wrote: ↑Fri 18 Oct 2024 8:51pm can't believe 4 voted for my mum

She shouldn't have dressed up as Django Unchained at that Journalist end of year party.
Have a word...

Reckon Phillipou, Milera and Wilson have been pretty good recently....all would go higher in a revised draft of their respective years.

More s*** from our favourite journalist.
He has to get called out on this vendetta

People are going put of their way to seek being offended these days. Must be some kind of endorphin rush.
Private function, no-one hurt. Play on

Geez that has come out of nowhere.

RIP Chris

I hope we're trying to get hold a one or two of the Tigers late first rounders for a F1.

F1 for 18 & 23?

Watching what Oliver has done to Melbourne's culture, a reluctant Smith would not be a good idea for us.

The numbers make sense as far as trade value, but I'd prefer picks 7, 8, 13 & 27, and just take the best available at each pick, and get McCrae for pick 47

Difficult to understand why we'd get rid of Campbell and Hayes only to recruit Pruess. Yep said it at the time. TC was a perfectly decent back up ruck. Thought he played really well against the Big O when we played Brisbane. Marshall gets monstered by strong ruckman. Why wouldn't we have given him ...

So far it's 9 for Barrett, and 1 for The Fireman's mum....pretty much what I anticipated.

Let's get to the bottom of this