Get a room you 2

So, I assume you are a better player if you floss? Seriously?? Geary and newans shouldn't be playing afl football. I prefer gaff not brushing his teeth for a week playing with us than having Geary and newans playing with beautiful white shiny teeth and nice breath. Those 2 should not be playing afl ...

Irrelevant. We didn't. He wouldn't be the player he is now as he wouldn't have the support if with us. Collingwoods list is better than hours and by a long way. Their forward set up is better than ours. And their midfield is one of the best in the league with pendelbury, Adams, treloar and the best ...

He was finished 2 years ago.

Sounds like he is not anyone's first choice but I think the best thing about him is he will be cheap. 3 years is a concern as is the injuries but if Weller and Lonie go he will be an adequate replacement for one of them. And he does look quick and we are in need of speed. He's a midfielder. Not a l...

Stupid post. Why trade Carlisle?he holds up our defence. Crazy. He's 27 by end of year. 28 by the time you want to trade him. Seriously? Glad you're not our list manager freeman had to go. Kent has played 6 years and played many more games and is tough and hard. Freeman body won't hold up to the rig...

Everyone is traceable with a crap side like us. Keep gresh and Carlisle and everyone is up for sale. Bottom 4 not acceptable.

Gresh and Carlisle. That's it.

Shiel breaks lines too. Shiel much better user of the ball and a stronger body.

We need to get Geelong first round pick for Steven and on trade to gws with our first round to get Dylan shiel. He's. A gun and a player we need. Only 25 and Steven is going on 29. No brainer. Great player but won 4 bfs in a crap side. Who's going to take votes from him besides Ross and Steele? I'm ...

We get Geelong first pick and gjve our 2 first round draft picks to gws for shiel.

Understand but not many players play well. I would have Shiel for Steven in a heart beat. Steven going on 29. Shiel is 25.it like Steven is taking votes from many people. We have no superstars. Let's see how he goes in a top 4 side. Wouldn't make top 3 good player but he is a good player in a shite ...

No player is playing well under richo. No player is being developed. If you loathe your boss you don't play for them.. Simple as that. Lonie would thrive at Collingwood. Why? Because players play for the jumper. Players love Buckley. Just like when the saints loved Grant Thomas. We don't play for th...

There's been much conjecture about Geelong interested in Steven. I would definitely be interested in trading Steven if we receive their first round draft pick. Why? He's 28 going on 29. Could also put us in the frame to land Dylan Shiel by giving gws our first 2 round draft picks which means we get ...

Richo has 33 percent win ratio.hiw he keeps his job is beyond recognition. It's like in a sales job. If you after 5 years we're meeting 33 percent of budget, you be be sacked. That's why people express their views. We as supporters and members deserve success and clearly, under richo, we will never ...

Waste. Typical. St kilda to do this. Playing in China is a waste. As if China cares. Seriously.

Waste. Typical. St kilda to do this. Playing in China is a waste. As if China cares. Seriously.

Bottom line is richo needs to go. He can't get the best out of his players. They don't want to play for him. You can see it. Keeping him will make us more in debt as many members won't sign. If 5000 members don't sign, that's over a million dollars in lost revenue which is a lot more than richo wage...

Can't compare the 2. One is AA and one of the best readers of the game in the afl and takes pack mark's and a beautiful kick. Mccartin can't read the play, can't mark and can't kick. He gets pushed off the ball too easily. No comparison. He won't make it. Too unfit and too slow and been in the syste...

I tend to think if we had the right coach, development coaches and a better culture, I think our players would be a lot better. I tend to think it's the players not getting the right development to get the best out of themselves, ie Billings, Mccartin when fit, Savage, Newans, Dunstan, Spencer, Acre...

notice how long ago those players were? Waste of money going to the bush better spent on putting more resources into the tac, wafl ect Mate there was no tac on those days. Seriously. That was 35 years ago. Get with the times. St kilda just have a terrible bunch of coaches and no development of play...

Best ruckman we got. Richo didnt give him a go. 2016 he was in my opinion All Australian at one point. Go injured and was never given a fair go.

I'm afraid nothing like him. Del Santo was a beautiful player to watch and knew where to run. Billings disposal let's him down. Del was a smarter player. Much smarter. He had a football brain. Billings doesn't.

Edited.

Whoops forgot Steele. Out goes lonie. Savage on bench.