Brad Hill is the player that has really improved Freo - his run and carry is invaluable - and that's the type of player that will improve us the most, too - a 600 metre per game player is what we need. Fyfe is expensive ... and another inside player - as good as he is. Hope it's not true about Fyfe...

I don't know how he fits into the side baring injury or loss of form. It seems from the outside we didn't want Bruce and McCartin to play together so they were just waiting for one to be in form and the other out of form. It would take that again for Marshall to play. The second ruck thing doesn't m...

I love the way Carey says he doesn't evn know Murphy's wife then on the other hand feels the need to communicate with Murphy on a number of occasions, to talk about it. The old bulls*** detector is going right off. In the least, Murphy is insecure about his wife's fidelity, so he's a fool for being...

Just like las week I'll say it again Roo will only miss, if injured He'll be rested vs Adelaide Would they rest him a week after a rest though? Good point P66 You are the second person who have said that. I can assure you I'm not him or her even though on BF he sounds like a guy. My name is Jacqui ...

BigMart wrote:Just like las week I'll say it again

Roo will only miss, if injured

He'll be rested vs Adelaide

Would they rest him a week after a rest though?

Great news IMHO. Not only will NZ secure our club but it will make us the biggest club in the AFL....... 1. Within 20 years I can see 15,000 kiwi based 2 game members. 2. Most kiwi's already living in Australia will start barracking for St Kilda. 3. Every kiwi that emigrates to Australia will 'auto...

Guys we are crap thats the reality of it. Last week we werent great. Shouldve been 130 points. Hawks werent even playing. If you think we have a chance tonight you are only setting yourself up to be dissapointed. Love the saints for who we are. A small struggling team who will always manage to neve...

The don't think so Tim... I have been given the green grass from there.... public enemy #1 well, maybe my old buddy P66 has taken the mantel now?... You'll soon learn I am the bad man on here... because I readily criticise the club or players for what I consider poor performance It's not popular op...

The don't think so Tim... I have been given the green grass from there.... public enemy #1 well, maybe my old buddy P66 has taken the mantel now?... You'll soon learn I am the bad man on here... because I readily criticise the club or players for what I consider poor performance It's not popular op...

The don't think so Tim... I have been given the green grass from there.... public enemy #1 well, maybe my old buddy P66 has taken the mantel now?... You'll soon learn I am the bad man on here... because I readily criticise the club or players for what I consider poor performance It's not popular op...

Sorry Jack Stevo It's a quote from an old sitcom.... maybe you weren't around in the 90s? Thank you for being objective That's fine. No idea about the sitcom but I was around in the 90's. Look forward to more posts. It seems a few on here don't like your opinions. Hopefully I will be objective as y...

The don't think so Tim... I have been given the green grass from there.... public enemy #1 well, maybe my old buddy P66 has taken the mantel now?... You'll soon learn I am the bad man on here... because I readily criticise the club or players for what I consider poor performance It's not popular op...

My opinion is one strike, your out, too many chances makes it too easy!!!!! How many Ben Cousins cases will we have in 10 years????? Society far too soft on Drugs as a whole, IMO!!!!! The AFLPA could turn around tomorrow and drop the out of season testing for recreational drugs. It doesn't impact o...

I don't think it takes any balls to say any of that stuff now... it's widely accepted we dropped the ball. Maybe at the time, when I copped vitriol from the usual customers (some are still doing it) Of course P66 and Joffa Moreland led the charge, but their little chronies loved to join in with thi...

stonecold wrote:Whitfield is a drug cheat, why else would he avoid testing, no thanks!!!!!

He took illicit drugs as probably does half our list. They shouldn't even be testing for that.

I think Kelly is pure class and will get $1M on the market, but would it be a good idea for Saints to pay that on a young mid? How would that sit with the playing group. Whitfield would be much cheaper and we'd have more chance in my opinion. I don't think players care about what others are getting...

I don't know who will be in the side in 2020 or if we will make the GF but I would expect at least 8 players who aren't at the club now to be playing a lot of games then.

longtimesaint wrote:

saintspremiers wrote:Seems like The Tractor got bogged today.

So far he has not lived up to the level of hype.
I'm glad we chose Paddy.

Well if we are being honest neither has he.

We should contest any penalty Koby gets on the grounds that the man closest to it awarded him a free kick for a good tackle. How in he hell is a player supposed to Know where he stands if the umpire rewards him for an action that is only later deemed illegal. Also, there was no real damage done. No...

The only way I will accept is when they start pinging defenders and ruckmen who are continually allowed to punch the ball out without penalty. One of the stupidest rules in any sport in the world Surely they are able to defend. i agree But they still not trying to keep the ball in. Absolutley no di...

stevie wrote:The only way I will accept is when they start pinging defenders and ruckmen who are continually allowed to punch the ball out without penalty. One of the stupidest rules in any sport in the world

Surely they are able to defend.

didn't see it that way at all. i saw him initially attempt to handball it to the clear patch in front of him away from congestion. when he saw the boundary so close he tried to regain possession of the ball but fumbled it. Benefit of the doubt a no brainer in that situation. That's exactly what hap...

So .. All those who want to trade Longer , what if it's a serious injury? I hope it's not at all serious as I'm sure everyone does, but surely some of you may now see why we have our ruck depth, and why we need to keep it. Hickey and Longer are both required They may both be required but there is n...

So .. All those who want to trade Longer , what if it's a serious injury? I hope it's not at all serious as I'm sure everyone does, but surely some of you may now see why we have our ruck depth, and why we need to keep it. Hickey and Longer are both required They may both be required but there is n...

I think it is pretty obvious we will only get one as best. And just as obvious is the club should make a play for a FA first. Why would you pay for someone if you don't have to and as good as Kelly may become he wont be better than the other 2, certainly on the inside, and probably on the outside. I...