Savage played a top game v Fremantle, probably his best in St Kilda colours Then there were the next 2 weeks This from one of the oldest and most experienced players on our List Time to move on In regards “replacements”, what you do do whether it be business or sport is that you continue to turn an...

If the list is actually good then 12 wins from his past 44 games says the previous coach was absolutely terrible.

Another 6 years lost.

Astute.

Currently fielding youngest team in the comp doesn't help. False. So at the start of the season, our games experience was 2550 which placed us 16th. Port who we played on the weekend came in 5th with 3167. With the loss of senior players at the start of the season, Carlisle, Steven, etc...I think i...

twirlyhair wrote: ↑Mon 03 Jun 2019 10:14am Currently fielding youngest team in the comp doesn't help.

False.

Ok so let's play Membrey in several different positions over the next 3 years and see how he goes You are talking about one of our most important players structurally and you call him B grade Great supporter Bruce would have stats better than Membrey if he was allowed to settle in the position he t...

In 2015 we were the reigning wooden spooners. Have a look at Bruce's stats from that year. He went ok, I can assure you and was up there in the Coleman iirc and definitely our best forward . Compare Bruce's stats in 2015 with Tim's stats from 2017 (where Timmy also announced himself as one of the l...

Which five players at St Kilda should get $800K a year? On potential you'd include Carlisle but on output and risks going forward, I wouldn't I'd go Stuv, Bruce , Steele, Gresh, and Billings What has Bruce done in the past 4 years that would put him remotely close to the top 5 players at the club? ...

Which five players at St Kilda should get $800K a year? On potential you'd include Carlisle but on output and risks going forward, I wouldn't I'd go Stuv, Bruce , Steele, Gresh, and Billings What has Bruce done in the past 4 years that would put him remotely close to the top 5 players at the club? ...

Which five players at St Kilda should get $800K a year? On potential you'd include Carlisle but on output and risks going forward, I wouldn't I'd go Stuv, Bruce , Steele, Gresh, and Billings What has Bruce done in the past 4 years that would put him remotely close to the top 5 players at the club? ...

Richo is finished, don't let 2 wins against terrible sides rattle you. His next step is out the door.

Alarm bells are ringing if our second highest ranked player averages 6 kicks per game - Daniel McKenzie… and if he is our second best player according to CD rankings, why didn't he get a game until round 10 last year? The main problem with that list of players is that only one is a genuine mid - St...

saintbrat wrote: ↑Tue 19 Mar 2019 6:22pm where are the 14 on the injury list reported by some media?

Longer, McCartin, Hannebery, King, Bytel, Carlisle, Roberton, Steven,

Also missing from JLT, assuming some have had injuries…

Pierce, Coffield, Acres, Austin, White, McKenzie, Clavarino,

Alarm bells are ringing if our second highest ranked player averages 6 kicks per game - Daniel McKenzie… and if he is our second best player according to CD rankings, why didn't he get a game until round 10 last year? The main problem with that list of players is that only one is a genuine mid - Ste...

Decent contract for someone who hasn't really done anything yet.

Geary has torn a calf.

To quote a line from an old Velvet Underground song

"I'm waiting for my man, twenty-six dollars in my hand.
Up to Lexington, 125, feeling sick and dirty, more dead than alive."

ambiphilia-lonsdaleite

pleasing.

Doggies comeback game for me. It was so unexpected and joyous. Steven running amok, Armo providing lots of outside run and line breaking, Rooey still dominating, Hickey standing up - it looked like anything was possible and gave great belief to the players Same for me, beating the premiers should g...

Paddy was & is the 100% right decision. That's good to hear… unfortunately our track record is patchy at best, so it's worth a discussion. Wright kicked 5 today and took 12 marks, can play in the ruck and is averaging twice as many effective disposals as Paddy this year. DeGoey looks pretty cla...

The reported offer from the 2014 trade period was GWS giving us pick 4 & 7 in exchange for pick 1 in order to get Petracca.

With Wright, who is looking like a beast taken at pick 8 and McCartin potentially still around at pick 4, perhaps we missed a great opportunity in our rebuild.

Discuss.

BigMart wrote:Seb Ross

2012 - 5p in one games
2013 - 13ppg
2014 - 14ppg (1 more CP and Clearance pg)
2015 - 18ppg (missed 8 with hamstring off bone)
2016 - 26ppg

The worry is the fact he has not progressed from his debut season We all got excited when a first year mid was able to average 17 and 5 tackles and win contested ball... Because we assume that as he progressed he would be a 25ppg player after a few years and ultimately a near 30 man Because with hi...

BigMart wrote:Templeton is better off elsewhere

Sandy.