I think that Murphy avoided Carlisle after the game. I think he knew he had crossed the line. The fact that Geary and joey had a crack at him 30 mins later after the game shows the level of disgust with the act. Bad look for a good player. Straight to the tribunal I would think

Thought Gresham's game yesterday was exciting to say the least. He is tough moves well through even heavy traffic and has great hands and foot skills, he is a great pick up. Curran played very well but will find it hard to get back in to the seniors as we have so Many similar type players. Was impre...

This all happened whilst he was still a bombers player.

Take Bennell. GCS find out whilst he is their player. Get rid of him as soon as they can. Freo give hime a second chance

Essendon find out and get rid of him as soon as they can. Saints pick him up and give him a second chance

Simple Really

If weller comes for 14 then the trade period is a success whether Carlisle falls over or not. I think that this is the best time for this to break and gets an idiot with the world at his feet to maybe realize that the golden rug is only one more line away from being pulled from under his feet forever.

my thoughts would be to give them Seb Ross and our round two pick. I like Ross but I like Carlisle more. Then possibly trade our second round from next year for freeman

Was a good win and that is about all. White moved the best I have seen him all year until he got a lower leg injury in the last quarter Simpkin strained a hammy as well late and with the Sipposs injury and unlikely to play next week it was a must four points given the list available for next week. M...

He will be good. Pick 13 and under a Lyon regime should mean he is ripe for the plucking

I think this year was all about being able to limit game time in the kids. Everything the club has done this year is about the future, especially resting the kids, I think Schneider is playing a real team game although it is frustrating at times

Umpiring was terrible all round. Across all games that I saw. Inconsistent and over officiated. The holding the ball rule has gone too far the other way now. Blokes are being tackled mid air when taking the ball. Clearly no prior opportunity and pinged for not acting like a beached dolphin. Also, I...

Time to become the new Hawks in this league. Either at the end of this year or during next year we should make a serious play for this kid. To me the start of the new era is now and I am sure we can get him for a hell of a lot less than Boyd. A play at treloar as well and if you land both then 2018 ...

When the substitute rule goes next year and rotations are lowered again I believe two key ruckman will be a must for most sides

Having a tough day? Nup. Having a great day. Just sick of our supporters whinging about umpiring and took offence at the inference I was simple. Have a nice afternoon. Hope blaming umpires makes you feel good.[/quote] All good. Have a good Sunday evening. Sorry for the inference as well but I hate ...

Zero impact on the game. I repeat ZERO. You missed the point of the thread. It was about umpires not the result of the game. I will try to get a simpler heading of the thread for you next time Umpiring. Enough said. This was your post Einstein. Umpires were fine. We were terrible. What is your poin...

Zero impact on the game. I repeat ZERO. You missed the point of the thread. It was about umpires not the result of the game. I will try to get a simpler heading of the thread for you next time Umpiring. Enough said. This was your post Einstein. Umpires were fine. We were terrible. What is your poin...

plugger66 wrote:The other option is to muck around with it and then stuff up.

We have that play down to a fine art Plugger

8856brother wrote:

8856brother wrote:Zero impact on the game. I repeat ZERO.

You missed the point of the thread. It was about umpires not the result of the game. I will try to get a simpler heading of the thread for you next time

Sinclair being infringed off ball

Taking a players legs at one end by membrey is a free (that is after blatant jumper tug is ignored) same circumstance at other end is deemed head high contact?

Stepping the ball over is deliberate isn't it?

Why do we bomb it long to outnumbered players time after time?

skills coach. Seaford area with relocation prospects in moorabbin

Enough Said

Your eyes are not that bad kosi. Your appraisal of white was spot on in that contest. His second effort and third were really good in that contest but the attack on the ball at the start of it was second rate

Was conca's first game back from injury. Don't know about an epidemic but between today and tomorrow at the g I might be frozen and unable to attend work on Monday

20,000 if lucky. Good falls on the hills