The talk out of preseason was about how fit paddy was and he was going to be hitting the wings and running back towards goal (membrey interview). He is no where near AFL fitness and has no second effort once the ball hits the ground. The players don't seem to have confidence to kick the ball to him,...

Let’s just hope it’s the same as last time and the scan shows nothing. Can’t think of a player who has had a worse run with hamstrings, he can’t even get on the park to play a VFL reserves game.

Can you post the article

Love to hear some updates on freeman if anyone is at the game

Thanks mate! All sounding positive. Would be great to get at least 10 games into him this year at AFL level

Can someone who has a herald sun subscription post this article http://www.heraldsun.com.au/subscribe/news/1/index.html?sourceCode=HSWEB_WRE170_a&mode=premium&dest=http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/nathan-freeman-six-weeks-away-from-return-to-footy/news-story/08bb6892f0ba54f1f782c65558db...

Would rather see Goddard get a run at it. He is the future not Lee. Think lee might get monstered a bit

Remember when everyone had spencer white in their team for round one? What a joke that was.

If Sloane selects us as his preferred team i think we will be able to trade for him and keep our first round pick (most likely top 5). Cant see us trading a top 5 pick for a 26 year old who has never been All Australian. Sloane would be a massive get for us and fit in perfectly

Will be delisted at the end of the year. People have massively overrated him on the back of one highlight. Wish him all the best on his future endeavours

Spencer started his own preseason a month early and still can't get fit enough. Didn't even get picked to play a preseason game. Only got offered a 1 year contract last year. Will be rookie listed at best next year.

Spencer had his chance late last year and looked terrible. Cant mark, can't kick and can't develop a tank even after an extended preseason. Won't be on the list next year.

Out of the GWS players I would think our order of preference would be treloar, hoskin Elliott then sheil

Spencer White is the most over rated player on our list. Got no idea what people see in him. He is a worse verison of Stanley.

Who were the best players in you opinion?

Can someone copy and paste the article here. The hearldscrum won't let me read it.

Shenton Delaney Dempster

Roberton Fisher Acres

Savage Steven Newnes

Tempelton Reiwoldt Weller

Membrey Bruce Sadd

Hickey Dunstan Armitage

Goddard Mccartin Geary Sub Lonie

People over-rate spencer white so much its ridiculous. He is nothing special at all and is a very poor set shot for goal. He started preseason a month early and still can get himself fit enough. I don't see him on the list next year.

Fitness guru got to go. Thats 5 hamstrings in 2 weeks. What a joke.

Very very happy with how the draft went. Really like all four players. Lonie looks like a star in the making. Should be a fan favourite. Our team is starting to take shape with the addition of key position players Mccartin and Godard. Mckenzie looks a gun as well and being a left footer is handy.

Feel sick in the guts at the thought of drafting McCartin. What in the hell are they thinking? The modern game demands players being able to play multiple positions. Where is chubby fat ass Mccartin going to play apart from full forward? Can anyone show me one highlight where he looks half athletic.

Mccartin will be a bust. His highlights are laughable. All he does is run 20m leads in straight lines. There is nothing impressive about him at all.

Dempster Delaney Wright Savage Fisher Webster Montagna Steven Newnes Billings Roo Petracca Templeton Bruce Membrey Hickey Dunstan Armitage Acres Weller Ray Geary Emg Ross Gilbert Murdoch Not a bad team on paper. We have some great young players coming through. Gilbert is prob a bit stiff but think h...

If GWS are desperate to get the number 1 pick the only way I see us trading it would be if they include one of Boyd, Cameron, Shiel, Treloar, Hoskin-Elliot or Whitfield. I would be happy to take a straight swap for either Cameron or Boyd. If they think one of those players will leave next year (most...

Think we will throw everything at GWS to get Boyd. Not sure the Number 1 pick alone will get the job done. Could see us trading Pick 1 to GWS for Pick 2 + Jaksch. We get a KPP in Jaksch and a key forward in McCartin to replace Riewoldt.