This will be one of the key questions of this season. While we all know the impact RoMo has as a ruckmen and midfielder, but as a FWD he would cause such problems for the opposition defenders and would also give us a really well balanced forward line. He can take a big mark, will bring the ball to g...

Thanks for that!👍 Billings Long Clak Jones outstanding King kicked 4-5 King probably should have kicked a few more...put one out on the full, dropped a sitter running into an open goal and missed a set shot dead in front. But he had presence and made his more experienced opponents think twice. Jone...

The fact that there are 5 players traded in is not an issue. The success and/or failure relates to who the players that came in. Hill & Jones makes us a better team. Hill gives us that outside run and drive that we have lacked for a long time, ditto Jones, massive plus for our team. Howard seems...

Not until we have the AFL version of Pat Mahomes lining up at CHF for us.

Is there any possibility that the Club are prepared to let Bruce go because they're thinking (long term) Ryder - 1st ruck Marshall - CHF (relieving ruck) Battle replaces him when he goes into ruck Winks - FF Membrey - HFF B King - FB (replacing Brown) Carlisle - CHB - Battle eventually take his spo...

Jarryd Roughhead as a rookie? Would be a good teach for younger players and could be our 2nd backup ruck man just in case....Not sure of his condition, but looks pretty fit. Could still perform his current role.

Why do people get so up in arms about “decisions” that haven’t and most likely won’t be made. It’s very unlikely that Masten will even be considered! As for Ryder, he is coming cheap and will be a perfect backup ruckman if the unthinkable happens and Marshall goes down. it’s pretty obvious that you ...

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Wed 28 Aug 2019 8:03am 1. How about if the player is with another club, like say Ablett or Dangerfield.

It's not only OK....we have a responsibility to do it!

Ha ha, understand where you might be coming from, but it is just a forum for people to do just that. I think many, if not most people on SS are of reasonable age (like myself) and have invested lifetimes of committment and emotion to a club which hasn't had a lot of success. For me generally speaki...

1. I will not type in a post that I wish ‘Player X’ would just f**k off. It is really nasty. While all players have different levels of ability, they all give everything they have got. You wouldn’t say it to there faces, so typing it just weak. 2. I will not suggest a trade that includes one or two ...

Bit disappointed with the team. Have absolutely no idea why you would play Gwilt ahead of Bruce, even if Gwilt was in form! And if you are going to rush anyone in I wish it was Acres. The remaining games this season is about finding out which middle of the road players will be part of the future, we...

Ridiculous to leave Bruce out again - Richmond have brought back Vickery to stretch our defence as WCE did last week. Once again the coaching staff to expect Gwilt to play tall? Problem being Gwilt is now the worst key defender in the comp he must have caused at 5 goals against last week he is disg...

Really disappointed for Murdoch, not really given an opportunity to prove himself.

Why not play him? He looks pretty solid and is the exact type of player that we need to get games into.

You might be able to find examples where winning the hitouts does not equate to winning the game, however I think the majority of times the winner of hitouts will equate to a win. If you look through history, there would be times when the team with less inside 50s have won but would you say that tha...

Would you be willing to part with either Steven or Armo plus our 1st round pick? Armo yes. Steven no. Maybe get them to include one of their top 20 picks as a sweetener and get another outside mid. . This is so unlikely to happen.... But if he is out of contract and chooses us, GWS would have to ta...

skeptic wrote:LT, would you go after Riewoldt jnr?

In a perfect world our new power forward would be 21 or younger (ie Patton) but you wouldn't say no to a 2 x Coleman medallist, especially after his lazy 11 yesterday

Forward line the key. Stanley and Lee are the keys. Need some high marking, pack breaking FWs who can provide a target and straighten us up. If one of them can be that man, then regardless of everything else, that would mean we are on the right track. If not (even if they are) we need to focus our a...

Jack is a good player... Not elite. Disagree...I think he is elite, although not in peak form. Apart from not being 100% fit, he is also is struggling with the extra attention, from not having Dal Santo around to take some heat. Even elite players (excl GAJ) need to get used to being tagged. Also w...

Reckon Stanley is worth more that Joey on the open market. He has the potential to ba a superstar with a good team around him. Joey's close to the end of his career. I would totally disagree at the moment. Joey would be a 20 to 30 pick. If Stanley was delisted i doubt he would get picked up. I thin...

Who do you believe are the hottest property players on the list, as who would demand the highest trade value.

1. Billings
2. Steven
3. Dunstan
4. Longer
5. Armitage
6. Webster
7. Hickey
8. Montagna
9. Wright
10. Templeton
11. Pelchen

After Roo, a bit light-on for Tall FWs although could fix that with a year of tanking and smart selections in next years draft.

Apart from that, the list of young players (<24) are really starting to take shape.

Yes, we should be in the position to snare a big name player in 2015/16 but hopefully it would be a trade, not FA. There would not be a FA that would suit our age bracket as they would have to be at least 26 to be a FA. We would want to somehow snare a big name player in a trade. Maybe someone who w...

Wasn't really fit, especially match fit when he came back. I agree with HTB. A full preseason and better match ups could be the tonic that he needs.

Over the past couple of seasons Jimmy Gwilt has been a victim of circumstance and injury. The lack of a genuine Full Back has meant that Jimmy has had to play in a position not suited to him and was often left out to dry. Before Dawson left and when Fisher was fit and flying, Jimmy was able to pick ...

It has been mentioned by someone on Bigfooty that the club warned Saad about these drinks, but he did adhere to their advise. IF that's true, that changes things...