I don't rate Ross Lyon yet....has done zero to date.... Paul Roos, Worsfold, Choco are different but all very good footy coaches...... Leigh Matthews is an outstanding coach of a good footy team (like Pagan) simplistic, but well respected...but not a good developer - does not teach well... Malthouse...

Hang on......I thought it was Jones was the best when he was at the saints, then Craig Starcevich who was the best in the comp....wasn't he mean't to be a great appointment.....now Misson.... And St.Mik How does F*** off sound....smart arses like you antagonise on the forum....and add very little......

If Geelong win the flag this season.....does that mean we will have one of their assistants as coach is 09, and their fitness person aswell.... :roll: Why are we always copying (stealing) personnel, ideas GP's from other clubs, can't we actually set a trend.... What is successful today, is outdated ...

Can see why they call Fizz Tripod......the skirt didn't sit that well on him, seemed to have a growth on his crotch...

Geary WILL debut in 2008.......likely to make an impact moreso in 2009....he is a bit light on at 72kg....good pace, good skills, finds the pill....Can play small fwd/small back.....improving defensive game Eddy physically is ready......big engine, finds the ball, has a solid game....his problem wil...

Are you sure he played brilliantly....he only played in the one.....Clarke Keating did most of the rucking and dominated...Beau played second fiddle against a kid in Josh Fraser.....I would suggest Beau had less than 5 touches... Beau McDonald was a reasonable tap ruckman at best who offered very li...

From what reports did Brad play well in the last half of the season in the seniors......He played the last 8 games in the Casey twos (except the final - Makepeace was a late withdrawel)......He is a struggler..(much in the same way Raymond was - just not up to it)..which is why he cannot hold a seni...

I can tell you from watching both Barry and Luke........Baz has more talent in his little toe.....and has done since he was 17......massive confidence issues/workload queries with Baz but his skill level makes Luke look ordinary in comparison.....Luke is a younger Beau McDonald, tall but poorly skil...

That's if they are lucky enough stay on the list until Nov...I think all their Contracts are up at the end of 2008 Xavier Clarke Fergus Watts Michael Gardiner Matty Ferguson Shane Birss Barry Brooks Brad Howard Andrew McQualter James Gwilt Clinton Jones Steven Milne If half of those come good in 200...

better than dunstall - credibility lost....

Fev is a tool - simple as that.......and it cannot be denied...FFS carlton suspended him this season..

Doesn't matter if he is quick - he is good.....cannot substitue ability...

Sam Mitchell is not quick, nor is Hodge....

Haselby - All Australian, B&F, Big game performer (Glendinning medallist), Rising Star winner.....not a bad resume

Nearly every poster on here assums that we are a big player in the Judd fiasco......why, because we have pick #9......Brisbane have pick #8, Bulldogs Pick #7.....etc.... WCE would want two QUALITY picks and a player or one Quality pick a QUALITY player and a Second Round pick.... We are well down th...

Sherman is from the Clarence Football Culb in Tasmania......definitely worth a look.....second rounder - or third rounder and a dud..

Hopefully Fev (27) is a part of the Judd Trade and we don't get a look in......least Fraser was a team player....prefer 200 games from Cyril Rioli than 80 games (40 dummy spits) from that tool...how effective would he be with us anyway - moving the ball at treacle pace Pettifer kicked 40 this season...

Very simplisic look at the lists output in 07 and how I think they will go in comparison in 2008.....whether they will improve or decline (and the degree) of course it does not take into account new injuries....but how the list could potentially go....I only considered AFL form...Players retiring, I...

One less possibility of getting Fev - thank god...... Excellent signing.......VIP at the saints, is a part of a group that have a close knit relationship (since 2002)....they were a distance apart with negotiations, so the Hamill retirement may have helped....worth 250-300K..... Maguire fit in 2008 ...

The smart thing would be to pick another highly rated kid for the future of the St.K F.C. all this talk of grabbing a short term (short sighted) player to get us into the top four is a joke......to win a Flag, a team must be consistently in the mix for a number of years......lack of patience has alr...

Courage over 'enforcer' anyday..... Max, Ball, X, Lenny, Baker, Maguire, Watts, Armitage, Harves, Attard, McQualter, Rix, Blake, Kosi, Gilbert, Riewoldt, L.Fisher - All naturally Courageous players, some are amongst the most couageous in the AFL.... More important is to have players who 1) win the f...

Why would there be that much room...... Do you not think that Kosi, Riewoldt, Dal had an increase in pay for 2008... All of those would have got and extra 100-200K Sam Gilbert's contract expired, Aaron Fiora's, Matt Maguire's has, X & R Clarkes.... Max Hudghton has gone to the Vets list saving a...

I think those questions have been answered - it's aweful....major recruiting blunder (and I would have hoped we picked him, if available )....I was also keen on Ryly Dunn

Evertime I have seen Geelong in the VFL.....about 6 times (live/box)....this bloke dominates......he is 22, and is SUPER quick midfielder, with good skills....must be a reason the cats have not even considered him.....reminds me of David Wojinski..... BTW - Is Kane Tenace not even getting a game in ...

I would have thought Voss would return to Qld, which is why I was surprised he had 'apparantly' signed with Casey....... I do know that he impressed all with his leadership skills at Casey.... I also know that Sweeney is well liked at Casey (preferred the VFL blokes).....but I too thought that he ma...

Just 40 other players.......

Will finish Top 4 in the B&F for the 3rd consecutive year, has strung games together and would lead most stats since 2005......he has been an All Australian, and 3rd in a B-Low.......not a bad player....

Apparantly he has already signed.....well rated at Scorps.....but like all sports contracts, there is a get out clause, if you get an opportunity at a higher level....the club has a moral obligation to let you go... Sweeney will be at Casey in 2008, unless he is Drafted or Rookied in 2008...(Melb, R...