Hey guy's this is my phantom draft. I follow it pretty closely this is my top 10. The top 5 may change order but they should all be the top 5. 1- Davies-uniake 2-rayner 3-Dow 4- brayshaw 5- stephenson 6-cerra 7- coffield 8-fogarty 9-clarke 10- bonar We have been linked to to coffield,Bonar Fogarty ...

I'll give it a go.

23) Florent
36) Macreadie
60) McCarthy

Gee I like Witherden, I know he is a hbf atm but I think he can transition and would've if he'd played this year. Looks like a Newnes clone but hopefully one who can play on the wing. Falcons boy too! I know I'm quoting myself here but I wonder if Macreadie, Sproule or Mutch would be bid on prior t...

Gee I like Witherden, I know he is a hbf atm but I think he can transition and would've if he'd played this year. Looks like a Newnes clone but hopefully one who can play on the wing. Falcons boy too!

They should take away 17 & 37 and pick 2 should be sent to the end of the first round.

Looks like GWS will get some sort of sanctions... It is a wet blancket becasause they only need points for Setterfeld and Perryman.. But surely guys like McCreadie and Mutch come into contention around pick 36?? Or if either ends up going earlier without GWS having points tp match, more opitions sl...

I wonder if Mutch will get matched. He seems like the ideal candidate for our list. Perhaps GWS will do us a favour as surely they don't need more mids picked in the second round. Plus, imagine having two Kobes on our list?

Also notice that Whiley got delisted by Carlton.

No I don't want Whiley but he had Barrett level of hysteria when he played NEAFL.

We've taken two GWS players and in both situations GWS said they were sad to see them go.

What I'm trying to say is keep doing that and not start getting their rejects!

And to think we nearly gave up 2 x 2nd round picks. We dodged a bullet and WCE should be kicking themselves. Mmm i don't think that's true. From memory, that's what they wanted. I don't think we ever really entertained it. Wold be disappointed for the club if i am proven wrong "What St Kilda i...

Can we not just pay him on the side and keep him fit to play him in Nath's number if Nath got injured? Are they identical twins or just born at almost the same time. Not identical as our Brown has more ability. :wink: Put it this way if 'Nath' starts spraying them, good chance it'll be Mitch :lol:

Agree that with the loss of Fisher - and Lee and Delaney - we are reliant on Carlisle and Brown as KPP defenders whilst we await the development of Goddard and Coghlan to AFL standard. The reliance on Dempster to "play above his weight" continues because we have "lost" 3 and gai...

Can we not just pay him on the side and keep him fit to play him in Nath's number if Nath got injured?

I'm hoping someone like Witherden slides to us. Its a big risk as his injury meant he couldn't do his midfield transition but sounds like a likely type. Villis sounds like a player on paper. SPP is the boom/bust Dusty type. Berry I hated but at 23 might be too good to ignore. Rotham is the perfect D...

Interesting or perhaps significant that we didn't lose a player. Saints were conservative and shrewd in the trade, we only added solid role players or depth, no superstars. It would have been nice to add a silky midfielder like Prestia or Mitchell. Love our deal with the Hawks, that feels like a wi...

So we spent a 1st, 2nd and 4th and gained a 1st, two 2nds, Steele (rated teens), Koby (former 22), Brown (former 10) and a 4th. Its a massive win in anyones language. We got the full back and two solid goalkicking inside mids which we needed. A Kelly/Shiel type next year (explosive silky mid) and we...

Interesting how the academies affect our picks. Lions have a couple before our first and GWS have a half dozen before our 60. Real chance these picks become 20, 30 and 45.

If Ameet gets in Giants ear, if pick 27 does get into their hands from Richmond, I'd be whispering pick 27 for 36 & 50.

72 points difference in Giants favour and gets us two picks in the top 30 to go with our mature aged guys. Use a future 4th or 3rd pick swap for Stevens and walk away.

Caddy gone to the tigers for picks....glad he didn't nominate us a few years back...he was so overrated....not what Richmond need but good luck to them. That deal Geelong get pick 24(785pts) & 64(101 pts) but give up pick 56(194pts) Values Caddy at 692 points = midway between pick 27 & 28 C...

Then let me rewrite it. So that would have been pick 13(1212pts) for 23(815pts) plus 36(502 pts). We go down 105 pts but given picks slipping due to academy picks closer to 150pts. But GWS has picks 51 (259pts), 55(207pts), 69(49pts) some of which they probably wont use. We may need one if we use p...

Any chance of us getting back into this year's first round Jaxons? Some although Deledio to GWS means more unlikely now than likely. So that would have been pick 15(1112pts) for 23(815pts) plus 36(502 pts). We go down 205 pts but given picks slipping due to academy picks closer to 250pts. But GWS h...

Any chance of us getting back into this year's first round Jaxons? Some although Deledio to GWS means more unlikely now than likely. So that would have been pick 15(1112pts) for 23(815pts) plus 36(502 pts). We go down 205 pts but given picks slipping due to academy picks closer to 250pts. But GWS h...

I think we should get JaJa Binks as our mascot. We have so many starting with Ja!

Jack x6, Jade, Jake, Jarryn, James (Jimmy) - thats ridiculous!

the amazing thing about heir trade with us is that it did not even seem to help with the Omeara situation. I mean... if they did that trade and then immediately sealed the Omear deal, one could understand that that was the price they had to pay.. but it seems like they did it without having any ide...

Massive lols at Hawthorn imo. They are trying to save face in the media by talking about ditching veterans to free up space for a massive offer in the coming years. But in reality they are treating the public like fools, and winning. This talk about creating space for the future is hilarious and I b...

Why have all the so-called ITK's disappeared at such an important time????? Makes me wonder????? You do make it difficult to read this forum. Either you are trying too hard to be relevant yourself or you are putting the hard word on Jaxons - either way its nauseating and I hope it won't push away t...