People saying he is an improvement on Hotton are missing the point entirely. Hotton was not in our best 22 and subsequently was delisted. For this to be worthwhile he has to be better than someone who is in our best 22 and I simply cannot see who he would be better than. We are full of average foot...

Gerreyn looked good

I'm pretty sure he is spruiking that his body isn't cooked - with 26 games to his name, there is fair chance he hasn't worn it out just yet They must be looking at him (amongst others no doubt) you would hope We definitely need someone else I would also be checking young guys with potential to be mo...

Negotiate the retirement of Crouch - pay him out if need be Replace him with McCrae (3rd rounder or less) - re shuffle his remaining 2(?) years of his contract to pay more of it next year than the following year Free up ( those 2 guys )money for the next year free agents LDU & Brayshaw Have a cr...

Leek Aleer

I hope we have a crack at getting him across

Every man and his dog knows we should have taken Petraca instead of McCartin - even at the time there were a only a few crazies who would argue the case for McCartin over Petraca - unfortunately a few of those worked for the saints But that horse bolted a long time ago - Petraca for early draft pick...

From my arm chair I can tell you that AFL football is still a tough and physical game They may not be behind the play king hits ( thankfully) but there is still a lot of physicality about it - I’m glad I’m not out there on the field Watch Windhager going about his business on Friday - he wasn’t just...

I also mentioned Bens hook shot miss from 35m out nearly dead in front when discussing our (lack of ) trained set shot routine on some other thread -

I was yelling at him ( on the Telly) as if he was still a saints player missing - that’s how frustrated I am with the way we go about it

Does it come with instructions?

1. Don’t spin the ball while you’re walking in because you might mix up the arrow and the kick zone
2..

Probably only needs a few basic rules

I wonder if the league will let us swap balls for our set shots ?

Absolutely no need for the AFL to comment on that free or any other free after any weekend They either need to STFU - ie make no comment OR Run out to the public a 20-50 page document each week outlining all the umpiring mistakes and inconsistencies over the weekend - because there are always heaps ...

This year it could be Logan the bogan McDonald and the other tall Amarti As long as it's not H McLean. They stole him from under our noses No - we just didn’t take him - could’ve had him for free pre season if i remember correctly- he was kicking arse for Sandy - but we didn’t take him During about...

They need a goal kicking coach
They need to learn how to kick a drop punt for a set shot on goal
The good teams do this well

I would think Collier- Dawkins should at least be on the radar

Just about fits into our demographic for what we had been spruiking

The short chipping round the backline put great pressure on us and totally took the pressure off them and resulted in some ridiculous turn over goals

Not sure why it happened ALL DAY

:wink: My recollection was that McCartin was well in the frame as the Number 1 Draft Pick And Petracca was marked down because his body size was a contributor to his performance as a mid versus that age group Plus some personality issues with Petracca My recall was that Bomtapelli was also marked do...

The rot set in after we hired that corkhead, Ben Dixon. We went from bad to worse under his "tutelage". Don't forget his best "technique" was to get the players to imagine the best sex they'd ever had, as they were lining up, and visualize their partner in that union standing be...

It baffles me that anyone could think that this was a deliberate act. Of course training would be different, just like he probably wouldn’t tackle as hard at training his own teammates as he would the opposition in a preliminary final. MB. If you watched this collision in slow motion numerous times...

His main problem seemed to be he couldn’t take his opportunities when he had them to play in the senior side - couldn’t find the ball If I remember correctly he had a shocker last time he played for us at senior level Definitely seemed to have potential but couldn’t show it when it mattered As someo...

Pretty sure he was fit to play - if he was badly missed that was the point I was making when I said - that says something I think

He didn't play Howard or Billings in the last few games of the season last year - that says something I think

Let’s add some blah blah blah - mostly a whinge fest this place

As someone has already said Sharman is a smart player and has the skill to deliver the ball where he wants it on a fairly consistent basis

As a result he is involved in some great team plays and is as reliable as anyone else in the team shooting for goal

I think he is definitely best 23

Hammer