I'm surprised Carlton don't use him in the backline, he certainly has the right pedigree. I've watched Jack through his junior years, since under 12's, and he's a decent kid, Certainly not arrogant. And he's a real team player, is willing to play any role required - even undersized ruck. He does a l...

I'm surprised Carlton don't use him in the backline, he certainly has the right pedigree. I've watched Jack through his junior years, since under 12's, and he's a decent kid, Certainly not arrogant. And he's a real team player, is willing to play any role required - even undersized ruck. He does a l...

So if Pickett plays against St Kilda this week is it Ok to Boo ?

This forum needs more knowledgeable people who understand football and St Kilda. I felt the forum was a better place when P66 was a prolific poster. Admittedly he did get into a lot of silly 'tit for tat' discussions, but since his departure this immature behavior has continued. If this forum really...

Reckon we got the rub of the green tonight

Agree he's good in the ruck, still it bothers me that his young body will get banged up.

Can't wait till Owens and Philipou are regulars in the midfield.

5. Wanganeen
4. Crouch
3. Owens
2. Marshall
1. Sinclair

Watching this reminds me of 2007 when Ross Lyon first coached St Kilda.

And they reckon a Leopard never changes his spots....

Brian Cook, their CEO, knows the club has over committed to a handful of inconsistent or injury prone players, their list is flawed and their Salary cap is bulging. Looks like we get to rejoice in their misery for a few more years. :lol: There must come a point when even the most incompetent clubs ...

Jack Steele and Marcus Windhager are proven.

Yep, some old Ross traits showing up. He also pretty much killed of Stanley's confidence before he got traded to Geelong. Hope that doesn't happen to Windy Richo traded Stanley, there was another Coach inbetween (Watters) who tried him as a half back. Stanley simply wasn't that good, never has been...

I'm a fan of Billings and his elite skills, either on a wing or half forward, but I'm convinced that our coach is obsessed with 'gut running' wings like Mason Wood, Ryan Byrnes and Brad Hill and Billings just doesn't fit his game plan. And our smallish half forwards like Butler are 'role players' wh...

Where are we at? We're 5th on the ladder at the bye with 7 wins and 4 losses. And unfortunately we dropped a game this afternoon we should have won against the Hawks, had we have won that we'd be in the top 4 and the 'experts' would have us 'odds on' to finish in the top 8. If you asked me before th...

Malthouse and Ian Stewart

Also interesting which Richmond players coached St Kilda

Is SOS turning us into Carlton? Didn't he try the same sort of thing when he left GWS..i.e recruiting the leftovers I don't know much about Dow, but I do recall Greg Williams telling him he 'wasn't hard enough'. Could be a package deal with Tom DeKoning " According to News Corp, St Kilda are s...

Is he eligible for Rising Star?

He deserved a nomination for Sunday's game, probably his career best.

....and former Saints super-star Andrew McQualter to take over...

Some tough decisions.

Owens is out.

In's from Membury, Billings, Windhager and Bytel.

But we need a 2nd ruck...

....and the 'not in's'.....Billings & Winhager

If Campbell did well, perhaps a senior game?

I'm beginning to worry about Rowan Marshall's work load as well as his effectiveness.

Reckon Byrnes has been quite good this year, he's provided great endurance rum on the wing which is the key to Lyon's game plan.

Reckon Byrnes has been quite good this year, he's provided great endurance rum on the wing which is the key to Lyon's game plan.

Pussies without Dangerfield and Selwood.

Humm........no King and no Billings and Marshall may need help.... Delighted to have Caminiti back, and support the decision to get Billings & King in good shape before a return. Interchange from Gresham, Clark, Butler, Cordy, Bytel, Paton, Campbell and Sharman.....hummm.... I'd like to see Clar...

In my time as a footy fan, the two most racially abused players would probably have been Sergio Silvagni and Syd Jackson.