Would love a pm too please!

Would really appreciate a PM, thank you!

Take it with a grain of salt but...


"There is very strong mail coming through that St Kilda will draft Dayle Garlett with one of their second round picks at 24 or 25."

Seeing as we have three days to match the offer. Any chance we'd match it, if we received poor compensation?

If he was Band One we would get pick 4. But he wouldn't be Band One because it is based on past performance & future contract & age is a factor. Remember BJ got a big 4 year deal and Buddy a 9. So thats the precedent for Band One. Thomas will get a similar deal as BJ - 4 year at 700k. Repor...

How exactly?

They haven't proven anything.

Ask most neutrals and they say we've lost a fair few of our trades.

Just because we are active, doesn't mean it's a good thing.

Inflated by cross goal kicking to loose players in the back line If you actually read the article, they actually account for all types of kicks (length, backwards/forwards/sideways, how much pressure the kicker is under etc.) and rank the kick accordingly. However, yes it does seem pretty odd St Ki...

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-06-10/frawley-pledges-loyalty-to-struggling-dees To against that is. Time for St Kilda fans to give up hope of getting Frawley. The fact is, if by someone miracle he actually says he wants to play for the Saints at the end of the year, he is still contracted and in o...

Would love a pm as well, thank you.

in fairness, Ray hasn't has had a few goes and failed to put his stamp on his position in SW's reign I dare say that he may be done Makes you wonder why we didn't just trade him last year then when Melbourne were interested. It was obvious he wasn't going to get a go this year and most kids would b...

After looking at our fixture. I think we will come 14th above GWS, GC, Lions, Bulldogs, Power. So with this is mind who will we get pick 6 and 24? Who has been picked up pick 6 in the past? Pick 6 is cursed. Plus it's laughable that you think we'll finish above the Power. Stop living in the past...

Riewoldt is such a star. One of the few veterans in the team who hasn't given up this season. His kicking can be off at times, but there is a reason he is captain, he gives it his all.

Would love one as well, thank you.

Would love one as well, please.

Would love one as well, if anyone finds one. Thank!

Regardless if Heppell wants to come to St Kilda or not... how does everyone expect we will get him? He's not eligible for free agency, so we would have to trade. And I'm guessing it's going to take a fair bit to pry him away from Essendon.

Don't understand why Blake is playing ahead of Simpkin, unless they want him to second ruck to keep Stanley down back. In fact Blake should purely be in the team for depth purposes only and only play games like last week, because we had three important defenders out. Also, we are really struggling f...

Would love a PM as well, thank you.

Would love one as well please.

People love to say that using a number 1 pick on a half-flanker is a complete waste, therefore Watts shouldn't play off the HB line, but if you look back on the past decade, we've seen the following picks; Hodge, Goddard, Deledio and Gibbs; all play predominately off the HB flank. I do think Watts c...

I really hope Rhys doesn't play down back. This is the first year Rhys has actually shown something and he actually looked very good when he wasn't injured. Yes, he wasn't a major goal kicker (probably only averaged 1.5 goals/game), however he played the lead half forward role to perfection. If he c...

I rate Ben highly, however I question how many talls we can fit into our side. I just don't think you can play two genuine ruckman in a side with the new interchange rules (especially if they further reduce it to 2 and 2 as they alluding to). And the fact is, neither Hickey or McEvoy can play any ot...

you pretty much made up half of those claims on asumptioins people on this forum are saying that a good defender is coming next year thats about it i think you have just taken it to the negitive extreme...... good luck with that way of life.. Yes, I was just pointing out how ridiculous all the clai...

All this talk and a lot of whinging about StKilda not having or recruiting a big bodied fullback yet how many are there in the AFL? Yes I ackowledge alot of teams have talls that play down back but lets be honets other than a select few none are fantastic footballers. Most clubs in fact basically a...

Can I ask why you and others seem to always mention Frawley? Can I ask why it bothers you so? We need a FB. Frawley's a good one. His team is terrible. They've just lost senior players. They may lose draft picks. Frawley may want out. He'd probably want to go to a club that needs a FB. We need a FB...