Dont understand why they thought throwing Sharman into the ruck was a good idea. He got rag dolled.
He is a dab kick for goal ( usually ) and yes we should cetainly keep playing him...

[quote=cps post_id=1958026 time=1654145932 user_id=1693] Hi All, I listened to this interview with David Parkin recently: [url]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPBDnHZMrR0&t=30s[/url] At 17.12 he mentions our current coach and how highly he rates him. I thought people here might be interested. Ch...

And all these years I thought his name is Davenport not Devonport.
.

Roma and Hayes were two huge outs night....

I used to bang on about poor umpiring years ago, but have finally realised that great teams usually manage to win despite poor umpiring decisions...not always, but usually. The worst features about our great game are the rules and interpretations .

I wouldnt be an umpire for quids

[quote=realdeal post_id=1922179 time=1629629265 user_id=313]
That 25m punch forward in the last qtr that lead to a goal was as good as a possession..
[/quote]

Yep that was a beauty

well if the guide is right...

they say time heals all wounds...hmm havent seen the replay ever since I was at that game. Its only highlights...maybe I can handle it 18 yrs on.

Was the day I began to resent Geelong...

I was at that game and Milan is right on the money. David Grant was absolutely killing Geelong in defence until he was taken out. I still harbour resentment for Geelong over that day. lol In my opinion, the loss of Grant cost us the game. With a small bench, it was a huge blow... there ere other fac...

Correct Sam23, we kicked ourselves out of the game, pure and simple. On a day when weather conditions might have favoured our crumbing forwards, they didn't deliver. They know it and are hurting badly.I really feel for them. It just wasn't their day.. In any other game on any other day at least one ...

Raph did Ok...in fact rather well in all the finals. He had a fantastic last quarter against Footscray, and played very well against Collingwood. (just a shame he missed that kick for goal...would have boosted his confidence further I reckon). Raph has improved game by game, and I think he is probab...

She fessed up to being a Western Bulldogs supporter a few months back at Etihaad. Not that it really matters...

Easy explanation. This site was full of so called 'supporters" bagging the hell out of RL , our 'dreadful' draft pick record, and at least half of our team players, all of whom are proving very valuable at the moment.,

Legendary wrote "Definitely was about Jeld-Wen. Lose their sponsorship and you lose St Kilda. Massive, massive consideration." I hope you are wrong on that one. I really do. I guess that's the beauty of having DIck Smith as a Richmond sponsor. David Hicks, Ben Cousins....not afraid to stan...

[i]""All the above are either very, very poor to date - or ordinary. Except for King. He was a good one. The rest have been woeful in terms of output and value add on-field.[/i] "" I disagree. I think Joffaboy summed it up pretty well. I think we recruited very last year , when w...

"""Isn't this a "Summer Series" slot......read: repeat interview from earlier this year??!!""" Yes correct. Good listening though., esp if one listens to the Watson story and then wonders about Voss and his chances of success ... Hopefully Voss has already mad...

""regarding milney: i just had a quick look our forwards stats. over a long period he averages twice as many goals as koszi and schenider. its hard not to conclude that milney is a highly under-rated player - even by saints fans. and that kosi is over-rated. "" Agree Con. Good to...

"at amin, he won't play until june or july. by then he will have to go into the reserves for 4 weeks. band by then it will be august before he can make it into the afl side." Even so, that still could put him (Dempster) playing next year, as opposed to the year after. I wish him all the be...

[b]Another reason for getting Begley, if we do get any of the young Irishmen he will no doubt assist them to acclimatise to Australia[quote][/b] Yes, another plus for choosing Begley over the aging, badly behaved, melb player (who, by the way, was absolutely caned here on this forum by most forumite...

[u]goddard in the guts spotting up Roo time after time after time[/u]


I like the sound of that!

Disappointed ? Absolutely. I would have been far more upset about the desision if Cousins hadnt shaved every hair from his body...Why the hell did he do that? stupid stupid man. makes a man look guilty, even if he isnt... I am pleased that at least St Kilda gave it a red hot go...unlike some of the ...

Exactly! Scuba Sam44

I just love it when the media gets it so wrong, and they often do.

As they say in the classics.."football is a funny game" ..Anything could happen. I moved back to Melb this year to help see St Kilda into the finals. After picking up KING, Schneider and Dempster so cheaply, and Harves pledging to do one more year, and announcing his faith in Ross Lyon, I ...

Went to watch Casey today, hopimng to see Ferguson star up fwd...but he spent most time in defence. Wasnt a great day for him, or any of the team for that matter...Birss did Ok i thought, but the player who really stood out for me , never gave up, and ran all day was Number 1...Kyle Mathews...Gutsy ...

Look guys and girls, this was the game to lose against Geelong...not the next one. No point in playing your best hand this week to maybe win the game and then having nothing up your sleeve for next time,...Geelong would then have us all worked out, and us going into GF full of false confidence. Yes,...

I hope everyone spares a thought for Milney. It wont be a fun ride home for him. Expect to lose him for more than a week, possibly 4-6 depending on damage and repairs. The bloke deserves a lot more respect than he often is afforded on this forum. Not sure who we have to step into the side who can cr...