The rumours are still rife, that we are trying to manufacture a trade with North for pick 2 which would give us access to Finn, Jagga or Sid.

Make it happen SOS!!!

Hayes very stiff because of his ruined knee and his age Paton wouldn't have got another game. Effective stopper, but no game sense and a rabbit in the headlights with ball in hand. I can only see North Melbourne showing any interest in hum Hotton has talent, but seems to lack attack on the contest....

Billings???

I’ve got no doubt we’ll sit back and let one of the powerhouse teams waltz in and snatch pick 3 and then complain about the strong teams getting stronger!!

North Melbourne will look to slide down the draft order because they’re real keen on Armstrong who is said to be around picks 8-10.
So hopefully we can offer up one of our picks 7 or 8 and possibly a future pick and get our hands on their pick 2.

bobmurray wrote: ↑Wed 16 Oct 2024 4:54pm Carlton reportedly wants a pick in the mid-20s from St Kilda for Brodie Kemp, according to the Herald Sun's Jon Ralph.

The Saints hold Picks 32, 45 and 47, along with selections 7 and 8 that could be used.

Tell ‘em they’re dreaming!

Why can't we try and get pick 3 from WC, give them picks 8 and 47 plus next year's 1st round If that means we miss out on Macrae who cares, get kids like O'Sullivan or Reid in for the next 10 years Just have a f****** crack Saints!! Now that’s something I could get around. Or try and swap our futur...

No thanks, we may as well keep Hayes as they get on the park as much as one another

Why can't we try and get pick 3 from WC, give them picks 8 and 47 plus next year's 1st round

If that means we miss out on Macrae who cares, get kids like O'Sullivan or Reid in for the next 10 years

Just have a f****** crack Saints!!

5 games in 3yrs, the club tried now it’s time to move on.

Pick 47 and they pay 150k of his current contract per year, would seem about right to me.
They don’t want him and he doesn’t want to be there, so they either cough up or they can keep him as far as I’m concerned.

Or maybe we pick up Finn instead

What I don’t get is why GC would even contemplate giving pick 13 to someone above them on the ladder, which just makes that team stronger and the promised return pick would be worse.
Why not deal with someone around or below you on the ladder and then it’s a win/win for everyone?

SDK

Embarrassing, I wonder what he’ll say if Roo’s 3 boys turn out to be stars and we get first crack at them under the FS rule.

CURLY wrote: ↑Tue 01 Oct 2024 2:58pm Apparently Battle was asked not to attend the Best and Fairest.

What are peoples thoughts on this.

It’s an absolute s*** go, if it’s true.

Clubs need to be better than that, I’m sure the players wouldn’t have given two f**** and would’ve preferred to see him there.

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Thu 19 Sep 2024 11:20am Can't see him leaving GWS. He is Josh Kelly's replacement.

1.2m a year for 7yrs would test his loyalty, write the cheque out and go knock on his door!

Move him on

Lions by 21pts

Pie in the sky!!!

But if we can pull it off it, it would be a massive coup.

I’d rather get Hugo’s cousin from the Dogs.

Cerra, is apparently on the outer at Carlton.

Was he at Freo with RTB and would we be interested?

No thanks, he can go to North Melbourne with Seb

VOSS, but he's got one of the better lists which wallpapers over the cracks!!

DRAFT!!!

Mids with elite skills and outside speed x 2

The Dees will probably delist him anyway as they clearly don't rate him, and if that's the case he can come as a Campbell type insurance policy.

We wouldn't be that stupid otherwise, would we?????