Agree with most bar Kosi. Wouldn't rate him in the top 10. Closer to 15. Most overrated and incosistent player on our list. read this after i did my post, agree completely. talent wise he is in the same league as dal santo and goddard etc. but performance wise he is nowhere near it. blake is just o...

broken into ability groups 1. Hayes 2. Riewoldt 3. Goddard 4. Montagna 5. Dal Santo 6. Fisher 7. Gilbert 8. Lovett 9. Gram 10. Jones 11. Blake 12. Ray 13. Schneider 14. Milne 15. Koschitzke 16. Gardiner 17. Baker 18. McQualter 19. Dawson 20. Armitage 21. Smith 22. King 23. McEvoy 24. Dempster 25. Cl...

hate to say it, but you'd have to say our list is weaker on paper this year than last.

anyone have the stats on how many times he was in the bests this year for sandy? or better yet seen him play much?

Surely you jest..... :roll: Young kids please!!!!! are you joking? we picked up what 7? kids last year plus rookies. smith is still young and if he stays injury free may actually play in a flag in the next couple of years unlike a kid we'd pick in the 60's. was widely regarded as the best player in...

wait wtf, he never worked on his core strength at st kilda? surely that can't be right, the guys always been too light for the way he plays surely core strength is one of the first things he'd work on? still can't believe he wanted to leave btw... doesn't make any sense, saints supporter growing up,...

Couldn't get a game for Melb, how can he get a game with anyone else. what gave you that impression? missed the pre-season and start of the season after he did his achilles against us last year, got dropped once for disciplinary reasons e.g dal and milne last year and still managed to play 13 games...

wtf? our training singlets last year were awesome! green and gold?

Couldn't get a game for Melb, how can he get a game with anyone else. what gave you that impression? missed the pre-season and start of the season after he did his achilles against us last year, got dropped once for disciplinary reasons e.g dal and milne last year and still managed to play 13 games...

Couldn't get a game for Melb, how can he get a game with anyone else. what gave you that impression? missed the pre-season and start of the season after he did his achilles against us last year, got dropped once for disciplinary reasons e.g dal and milne last year and still managed to play 13 games...

He'll be head coach soon enough, Ratten is an absolute dud coach. Am looking forward to see what his game plan is now that 'kick it to Fev' is invalid. Expect Carlton to go down this year.

We have delisted the likes of McQualter and Ferguson over the Lyon period. And then re-drafted them. Then there is Miles - now up-graded again. It would be up to Maguire to show he has the appetite and to then show he has the skill set. As with Ball, remuneration comes last in paving the way for a ...

you've left out one Major player- a current landowner and Born tasmanian would fit Half forward and be captain of an all australian team very easily :wink: He never played in Tassie. bulls***, my mates brother played juniors against him. Used to play for Sandy Bay (not to a very high level obviousl...

Barring injury he will blitz it Carey style. Without motivation (apart from the usual stuff) he's already the most dominant and hard to stop forward in the league, imagine what he'll be like now out for revenge. I dunno if they take bets on AA CHF, Captain or MVP but I'd get on him for all 3 (not br...

you've left out one Major player- a current landowner and Born tasmanian would fit Half forward and be captain of an all australian team very easily :wink: He never played in Tassie. bulls***, my mates brother played juniors against him. Used to play for Sandy Bay (not to a very high level obviousl...

Buddy, now you are really cracking me up! "biting us on the bum" eh? hmm....somehow I doubt it. BUT.... Best of luck Goose, and I hope TassieJones is right and you star for the Hawks or another club. There you go. I'm not a sad sack like yourself and want for the best for a player who has...

wtf??? what the f***!!! this has got to be one of the worst decisions ever made about our list. how leigh fisher or many other blokes on the list are better value i have nfi! what the hell? such a legend, such a great player and we can't even trade him for a scrap draft pick??? what the hell! why?!...

wtf??? what the f***!!! this has got to be one of the worst decisions ever made about our list. how leigh fisher or many other blokes on the list are better value i have nfi! what the hell? such a legend, such a great player and we can't even trade him for a scrap draft pick??? what the hell! why?! ...

nothing against raph, but macdonald every day of the week

out of the team, in terms of contribution to the club not just who was the best player, (not including ditteritch since he started out here) you'd have to say Gehrig would be the best by a fair bit, followed by Hammill and Gram . I'm not familiar with some of those names, but it certainly looks like...

Joel MacDonald was in AA form in 2008 before injury. Not as good this year but still a good year. I'm absolutely shocked he was delisted. No doubt in my mind he'll get picked up by someone, would like a player of his quality late in the draft (essentially free) but we do have a surplus of half back ...

Considering what X went for we probably would have got s*** all for him, so I'm definitely glad we held on.

I could see him working his way into the 22 over the course of the year definitely

Didn't we delist Shanahan? I think Nick Stevens is probably a better example.

Anyway I reckon he'll do an O'Keefe, apart from the B+F

I'm stoked to be honest, never wanted him to go. If we ended up with Lovett for Ball, that would only be a small net gain. Imagine if we got both, much more significant improvement to our best 22. There's still the whole PSD thing, but surely if he's too proud to play in the VFL, Luke wouldn't be wi...

we wouldn't use pick 62 because we got pick 60 for X.

That said we still got ripped off though.