We have the worst midfield in the league and haven’t improved it.
Simple as that

He has been hugely accurate
That’s what has me worried too

Cal twomey has us taking travaglia and tauru
Disaster if that happens

Must get a mid
Any of the highly rated but not Reid

Bite the bullet and trade out 8 and next year F1 for 2
Go hard now

Get a future 2nd back if need be

Don’t get bit players

Injuries
Shallow list

Hotton is the disappointing one
Must have been way short of standard

I have to respond here In Ratts last year We were terribly unfit We had no idea one week to the next how we were going to play We got run over so many times after half time it was embarrassing Players went backwards In lyons first year We won first 5 games without a forward line There was consistent...

Get them both done
Pickett deserves a chance

I agree 100%
Offer next years first round - definitely better value than blues are offering
Get it done

Surely we are not comparing Dow to Callaghan?
He is exactly what we need
Get it done

The thing that has annoyed me most about this… so often, you hear players say when they move clubs that they want the incumbent to be taken care of during the trade. I know it’s FA but Battle could at least insist that Hawthorn structure the deal so that we get a pick 6 or whatever. Then everyone w...

I can 100% assure you we will not pay overs. Josh will do what’s best for his family-as he should ; yet the St Kilda footy club decade after decade cut loose great players often for little return Like who? only ones I can think of the last 30 years is Hall and maybe acres. and Considering Hall want...

Clark can’t kick
Too many turnovers…..

Clark can’t kick
Too many turnovers…..

He hurt it when the ball was kicked to him by nwm, when it hit his toes and he tried to mark
Came up very gingerly and was propounded from then on
He never went into the ruck that I saw

Hammer was good today
Took at least two contested marks and his opponent barely got it
Good game

Too late now
Season is done
That’s the whole point

Wow Sydney Melbourne Melbourne Brisbane Adelaide
So tough

Then they had a bye and 5 Melbourne games in a row
If we had 2 in a row we would be happy

We travel 1 more time than Collingwood this season, and that's to play Hawthorn in Tassie. We don't always have to play the victim you know? It’s not the total season, it’s the concentration of when. Our intestate travel is bunched and early in the season Theirs is spread Simple as that It is defin...

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2024 2:07pm Every man and his dog who don’t support stk and Saints supporters with 2 eyes know it wasn’t a free kick

And the same for the swallow goal - what’s your point

Keep Battle, pick 19 is not enough
Force FA to be pick 7-8 or keep and pay him big money scaling down over 6 years

We will get pick 7 - Ashcroft will be pick 2~3 and there will be another academy pick no doubt.

Clark was ok/average for 2.5 quarters and stepped it up, particularly when it counted in the last with clean accurate possessions. Was great to see.

spert wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2024 9:44am I'm kind of sick of people making excuses for King- he got flogged last night and only looked slightly better when he went up the field.

And the Coleman medalist leader at the other end dominated the game, after his opponent went off in the first 20 minutes

People on here are hilarious

Not one commentator/expert I saw on Fox or channel 7 after the game tonight thought the free to King was there. Jack Riewoldt even saying “absolutely not”. But I guess those 7-8 ex players are all clueless, biased flogs with agendas against St Kilda! Swings and roundabouts 👍 Did they think the horr...

I can’t believe no crouch. You need an older fella in the 2s to teach the way and I thought it would have been Ross getting dropped, Crouch in. Bonner out for Arie. Arie has been tearing it up and smashing the door to be selected. Needs a game. 💯💯 Bonner got the DCM from Port because although he ca...

Smith was 1 x acl and a medial or pcl at the same time
Penny was bone on bone knee, was set to be that AA defender
Kosi was a real shame
Jarrod Allen too, I liked him
Ball was costly, so costly

Smith was 1 x acl and a medial or pcl at the same time
Penny was bone on bone knee, was set to be that AA defender
Kosi was a real shame
Jarrod Allen too, I liked him
Ball was costly, so costly