Windhager, Owens and NWM. All will be good or even very good players. Absolutely. In a rotten fkd up year, we can take away the 3 1st year players who have batted beyond their league. Windy's en route to being a real good player - how many best Lachie Neal in a game? The kid did. Ah, Michie. The ki...

I was thinking to myself tonight. What is Clark’s role in this team going to be going forward? We already have two half back loose playing flankers who I think most (including the st Kilda coaching team) clearly view as better options. Clark is not a good a shut down defensive player and is better ...

The kid just needs some f****** luck Just needs some luck….. Like Billings, Webster, Jones, etc, etc. See where I’m heading here. He’ll be 27-28 and people will still be getting defensive about it. There’s no luck involved when it’s repetitive over and over and over again. Having your head caved in...

The kid just needs some f****** luck Just needs some luck….. Like Billings, Webster, Jones, etc, etc. See where I’m heading here. He’ll be 27-28 and people will still be getting defensive about it. There’s no luck involved when it’s repetitive over and over and over again. Having your head caved in...

He’s a spud. Another first round draft pick down the toilet. 23 year old midfielder getting 12 touches a game. No speed, no urgency, no will or want to win. No physical pressure. Wtf has he been doing?? Does he actually train or get in the gym at all?? As much as I hate the prick Selwood, where the...

He’s a spud. Another first round draft pick down the toilet. 23 year old midfielder getting 12 touches a game. No speed, no urgency, no will or want to win. No physical pressure. Wtf has he been doing?? Does he actually train or get in the gym at all?? As much as I hate the prick Selwood, where the...

Out of everything you saw tonight this is what you bring up ? The kid should be f**king commended after having his head caved in after spending 6 months out to sack up and just walk out onto the field this year. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt but this is just about as uninformed as it gets....

Royston wrote: ↑Fri 12 Aug 2022 11:39pm Fat and not AFL fit....disgrace he is in that condition and still being picked. Cant imagine the Swans accepting that

A 'disgrace', eh champ? You fancy the Swans m.o.? Then f.o. to fkn Sydney, and get your fkn jollies.

Unless the first reply is that he’s carrying an injury… kid is clearly not match fit Spent the entire second half off to the side waiting for short passes to get easy uncontested ball. Brushed off tackles easily on numerous occasions and on two occasions in the third, he was briefly on Rayner (or t...

Yeah, I was surprised at Hodge's comments. He's seen lots of footy over the years, so I have to respect his opinion on Steele. I personally look at players like Lachie Neale and Scott Pendlebury as being super elite. I have Steele close to them, but to hear Hodge say Steele is the best and hardest ...

Or he needs to be read the riot act HTFU Ah, the wisdom and wit of the local suburban footballing hack. The same hack that spends endless time potting Hunter Clark for being 'insufficiently muscle defined', thereby claiming superior competitive performance traits for himself, vs a young fella who h...

I love GT he had more balls and straight up not like some on here who probably never got a spank off daddy he was a bloody great coach got the best out of players and they stood tall if this bloke was our pres our 2nd premiership would have been lifted Utter nonsense. Thomas was a half baked hack w...

Hello Teffers...are you there? Tis a fair question. In my experience Teffers is a good - and not stupid - man. But, gee, why is it so few get the fundamental problems, and resort to simplifying those problems as if there's an easy fix? That was a damn good win, well thought out, and executed a trea...

I think players should give up in protest if the free kick count is heavily weighted against us They should concede the 4 premiership points and just walk off at half time Actually...Why bother trying at all after quarter time ....really? Seriously...It's not fair...I want my mummy Nah - what every...

Ya wanna know what the 'voting order' should be? Ya note what Luke Hodge said about Jack Steele after the game. Watching the game, I thought Steeley had set himself the task of besting Cripps where it counted. Golly gee, it worked. But, I didn't expect to hear one of the greatest of all time, in Hod...

Mr Magic wrote: ↑Sun 15 May 2022 5:41pm

bigcarl wrote: ↑Sun 15 May 2022 5:33pm Not Geary I wouldn’t think. You need to be able to command a spot in the side.

Maybe Ross or whoever is in the leadership group.

Membrey?

V-Cs Membrey and Howard, Wilkie and Geary the other 2 in the Leadership Group

The only thing he said which was worth consideration is the damning stat of being 16th in centre clearance differential last year- it was/ is a real issue if we want to get up the ladder. Given the well documented stuff up with the preseason preparation, the late start of Ryder, and Marshall's foot...

Definitely a valuable member and a one year contract is well deserved. Why? Has been stuffed by injury. Young fellas coming through. Should retire. Impact injuries. If young players are better let them win their spot. If he's not handed a captaincy role and, let's face it, he shouldn't be - Steele'...

And there are tools on this forum who think we were better off sacking him We probably did Grant a huge personal favour. He's nurtured and developed several business ventures and made a windfall for himself and his family He keeps displaying real life tangible evidence of creativity, innovation, bu...

If we want him we would offer him a contract attractive enough to stay. We don’t want to as we don’t need him. It’s a meh from me I would much rather we developed Bytel. Seems the Saints think along the same lines. I would hope so. Dunstan's limitations are glaring. A combo of being unable to hurt ...

I've been away for a while, but feel compelled to return. Lonie's a spud, at best a 'quality' VFL player. If we think retaining him on the list will make us better, we're imbeciles. How many games? 70 odd? And, how many 'rippers'? One?! He is so one sided it would be embarrassing if I didn't 'unders...

These guys are the scapegoats whenever we lose. The forum goes bananas with people telling us what they 'çan't do' and not what the can do !! Everyone has faults, but you can't question the endeavour, the aggression and the competitiveness of all 3 ...not to mention an element of mongrel which you ...

desertsaint wrote: ↑Fri 25 Jun 2021 11:30pm ......Marshall so important to us, structurally and mentally......

Absolutely spot on, both attributions.

I didn’t think Marshall did much Ryder was pretty good He gave Ryder relief and was competitive. We must be happy about this. Please he's 1000 times better than Hunter. He plays like a midfielder. You seem to understand just how important Marshall is to us, Mag. When a bloke like Luke Hodge says wh...

Connolly got a few cheap kicks at the end but he has a beautiful peg and he didnt look out of place His first run past handball receive was sensational .... unfortunately he just missed hitting the target with his handball Be good if we could identify our Daniel Rich equivalent. By fork, he can kic...