Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Imagine the likes of Caro if we recruited him and he mucked up again, he'd be a victim of our "culture" blah, blah, blah.
Weller, Weller, Weller we can't draft em all, we've got to give the other clubs a chance to load up their lists, tell em to give Eddie a call, Nathan's on a GOP fest, Tuck would fit right in there.
Six debutants for the Saints so far in Season 2024.
Dont some people here have the courage to want new players who have never played AFLto be at our club. Some always seem to want ex AFL or unproven AFL but listed listed AFL players at our club. In our current situation a punt on new players should be the way to go considering we already have many from other clubs this year.
plugger66 wrote:Dont some people here have the courage to want new players who have never played AFLto be at our club. Some always seem to want ex AFL or unproven AFL but listed listed AFL players at our club. In our current situation a punt on new players should be the way to go considering we already have many from other clubs this year.
Don't panic plugger. We only have 3 picks #3,#19 & #20. We aint gunna use any of them on re-cycled players !!
NEW scarf signature (hopefully with correct spelling) will be here as soon as it arrives !!
CURLY wrote:No drams Rookie listing a bloke like this. 25 years old 190cm 90kg ball winnning mid. Could easily play 100 senior games as he can clearly play.
No dramas trying to get the next Milne or geary surely. Forget this guy even as a rookie.
CURLY wrote:No drams Rookie listing a bloke like this. 25 years old 190cm 90kg ball winnning mid. Could easily play 100 senior games as he can clearly play.
No dramas trying to get the next Milne or geary surely. Forget this guy even as a rookie.
Cant see the issue really there are 4 spots if he is best available take him. 25 is hardly throw out material.
CURLY wrote:No drams Rookie listing a bloke like this. 25 years old 190cm 90kg ball winnning mid. Could easily play 100 senior games as he can clearly play.
No dramas trying to get the next Milne or geary surely. Forget this guy even as a rookie.
Cant see the issue really there are 4 spots if he is best available take him. 25 is hardly throw out material.
But we know what we are getting. we are in a position to take the punt on young kids. We will finish bottom 3 anyway so why go the safe option.
CURLY wrote:No drams Rookie listing a bloke like this. 25 years old 190cm 90kg ball winnning mid. Could easily play 100 senior games as he can clearly play.
I agree - we still can get as many kids as we can fit on the list - I'd swap this guy for Shenton - who came in mature age and still isn't doing anything
BigMart wrote:We wouldn't draft a bonfide champion who did drugs.... When we were contending
Why a GOP who's done drugs?.... When were crap
Because Cousins was still doing gear thats why we pulled out. From what everyone is saying Travis is over his depression and is back on track. Everyone deserves a 2nd chance.
A long time ago, but Travis was at Berwick SC when I worked there... In Y8...
He was a terrible student, and had an aweful attitude towards school and teachers, many wanted him booted. He was only a young boy then, but It didn't surprise me when he got in strife... Hopefully he has matured. But I wouldn't be risking drafting him.... Not worth it as he ain't much chop anyway.