Minchington v Ledger !!

[Eastern]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

[ShanghaiSaint]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

Waters saw it as well . I liked him a lot. That spear pass to roo was great

[Con Gorozidis]

Can see why the coach likes him.
Nuggety and goes hard but nice kicking skills and clean hands.

[SainterK]

Could go through the midfield as well?

[Dr Spaceman]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

Seeing as most people think Ledger has no future then the winner must be Minchington, even if by default.

[saint6709]

I thought he looked good -only 19 - looked to me like he could go through the midfield

[SainterK]

Might well be Michington v Milne from a list perspective

[noob]

More like Minchington vs Saad.

[SuperDuper]

Being December born, from an age perspective, Minchington can be compared with 1st year recruits.
So he is going nicely... Needs to string more games together, he seems to have had several injuries...

[BigMart]

Minchingtin ..... Small fwd and occasional mid .... 12-15 ppg in the VFL

Ledger ..... Inside mid ..... 25-30 ppg in the VFL

[savatage]

If we're comparing the two, I'd take 15 from Minchington over 30 from Ledger.

I don't dislike Ledger - but Minchington is easily the more damaging footballer.

[BigMart]

I'd say Ledger is the far more damaging player in the VFL on weight of numbers alone... Clearances alone would make him better... He is a prime mover

But at AFL level Minchington fits in better as a flanker, secondary role player as his effect per possession is probably better

Darren is talanted imo

[defacto]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

minchington by a mile

ledger has many issues that are stopping him from getting a call up

[BigMart]

What are those issues?

Confirmed or a belief??

Quite frankly, I'd like to know the truth! On evidence, it's head scratcher..

[magnifisaint]

What are those issues?

Confirmed or a belief??

Quite frankly, I'd like to know the truth! On evidence, it's head scratcher..

You can't handle the truth!

[Middo]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

minchington by a mile

ledger has many issues that are stopping him from getting a call up

What are these so called issues everybody seems to talk about but not say what they are and who said it ..?
I'm thinking bulls#it !!

[Con Gorozidis]

The Minch reminds me a bit of Stokesy

[Con Gorozidis]

The Minch reminds me a bit of Stokesy the way he plays.

[Kickit]

I just wish we could take the "ball magnetism" from Ledger and put it in Minchy and Sippo.

[Life Long Saint]

[Dr Spaceman]

I just wish we could take the "ball magnetism" from Ledger and put it in Minchy and Sippo.

Ever since our "new recruit" MarkMcGough was sold as a "ball magnet", the term has lost a bit of lustre for me

[spert]

It's a bit hard to make a judgement on Ledger unless Watters gives him a game in the seniors, and I see no real reason not give him a game as he seems to be putting good efforts in at Sandy. Maybe the incredible match-winning midfield we have is just too hard to break into?

[Old Mate]

The likely retirement of Milne, injury prone Schnieder and delisting or at least longterm suspension of Saad should see Minchington upgraded to the senior list.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Ledger is on the primary list. Minchington leap frogs over him from the rookie list and into the seniors. I liked a bit of what I saw from Minchington tonight. Which one has the brighter future? !!

minchington by a mile

ledger has many issues that are stopping him from getting a call up

What are these so called issues everybody seems to talk about but not say what they are and who said it ..?
I'm thinking bulls#it !!

simply put he doesnt have the tank to be in the seniors he has gone backwards in his fitness and that is what is holding him thats what i have been told ... really as a third year player he shouldnt be having fitness issues so thats why i think he might be back at claremont next year

[BigMart]

His tank seems to get him to a lot more contests in the VFL than his contemporaries??

But not a game in front of them

Standing next to him, he looks lean, trim and fit?
Can assure you that he has,Siposs, Murdoch, Webster, Minchington covered for endurance

I reckon attitude must be his issue..... Cayden Bethany style

Can also assure you that he can definitely play... Absolutely