Milne must NOT play against the Pies

[saintspremiers]

The MRP should've graded his stupid dog act as intentional and he would've got 2 weeks he deserved.

Milney has been a champion for us up until this season, but is clearly way below his best now.

That aside, pulling someone's face is something you'd expect from Judd not a Saints player.

It's a terrible look for our club and Milne needs to play a VFL game this week as proper punishment.

Fortunately Milera played well today so it makes the decision a bit easier.

Please Scotty stick to your word - and put the jumper above the player just like was done (albeit different circumstances) with Gram.

Suck it up Milney, play a blinder in the VFL and give us FOOTY to remember when you're back in R,W & B for one last season.

rant over....

[R. Harvey 3 votes!]

A week in the two's wouldn't hurt...

[mr six o'clock]

Agree

and it will be good for there supporters .
They are much more comfortable screaming out " petrol sniffing black c@#t " .
Shouting " Rapist !" tends to have too many replying " yeah !"

So it will be good for all involved .

[plugger66]

Hope he plays. Stupid act but still deserves to play. Much better than any other option. If Kosi can play then Milne must play.

[8856brother]

Pick the best side. Pick the tip rat.

[BigMart]

Sandringham to earn his spot back.

His efforts this year have been below par, needs to demonstrate his effort at Sandy.

[stinger]

Sandringham to earn his spot back.

His efforts this year have been below par, needs to demonstrate his effort at Sandy.

i agree with you.......milera to come in....milney to sandy...much as it pains me to post that....

[plugger66]

Has to play. All smalls below par this year but he is still the best.

[bobmurray]

Sandringham to earn his spot back.

His efforts this year have been below par, needs to demonstrate his effort at Sandy.

hasn't looked to be at AFL level..

We shouldn't be a benevolent team, we should be a team that plays in form players only, if we were, the tip rat would be at Sandy

[BigMart]

If he's good enough, he'll win his spot back, if not it means another is performing better

It's all about the effort... Not the name

[Sainternist]

Has to play. All smalls below par this year but he is still the best.

I'm with you, Plugger.

Can offer some much needed fire power up forward.

Plus, I would dearly love to see him kick a match winning goal against the Filth. It would be so satisfying to see their fans cry their eyes out on behalf of Milne.

[Spud02]

Disgraceful description of a legend of the club saintspremiers. By the way, if you want him left out, name the other small forwards who deserve his spot on form...

[skeptic]

Milne's talent is undisputed... However ur only as good as ur last game and milne's last few have been aversge... Milne VS Saad VS Milera VS TDL... All are not playing particularly well but Milne is the oldest by a way and is only slowing down. He wants his spot back, Milne needs to take it back

[St Chris]

I think Ahmed needs a week in the VFL before Milney does. Conditions were perfect for him in NZ and he couldn't get near it.

[dragit]

I think Milera has probably shown the most of 'the smalls' so far…

Saad & Milne about on par, but after Watters went public with his displeasure of Milne's suspension, he really needs to follow through, Milne to kick 7 at Sandy.

[plugger66]

Milne's talent is undisputed... However ur only as good as ur last game and milne's last few have been aversge... Milne VS Saad VS Milera VS TDL... All are not playing particularly well but Milne is the oldest by a way and is only slowing down. He wants his spot back, Milne needs to take it back

He takes it back because the others failed without him. He should and hopefully will play.

[BringBackMadDog]

The OP is a disgrace. Please leave the bagging of players to opposition scum bags only. Milney deserves so much more from us than this. As for leaving him out, I think I read this same game after round 4 last year. Plus the other small forwards hav don stuff all anyway. At least Minle attracts quality opposition week in weak out which makes if easier on our other forwards.

[bobmurray]

I think posters get so hung up on what a player has done in his career that they can't hack it when said player turns to shite..
It is a fact of life in the AFL...

Get rid of the chaff I say,,,,

[8856brother]

I think posters get so hung up on what a player has done in his career that they can't hack it when said player turns to shite..
It is a fact of life in the AFL...

Get rid of the chaff I say,,,,

All Australian only last year after a very slow start. Are you saying he's cooked?

[Sainternist]

Jeez, some of the comments in this thread... You'd think some of you guys were opposition fans.

[matrix]

Tez in
tip in the magoos

[Scollop]

He's the Etihad specialist and there's some retribution from last year. If that doesn't motivate him or fire him up, then yes he is cooked. I reckon he'll play and hopefully he kicks a few. Hope the Kos plays too

Maybe Channel 7 will run promos for Friday night football with a flashback to Harry O's dropped mark where they paid a free against Milne. How would 7 look if Milne isn't named? Surely that's reason enough to bring him back in

[SaintPav]

I think posters get so hung up on what a player has done in his career that they can't hack it when said player turns to shite..
It is a fact of life in the AFL...

Get rid of the chaff I say,,,,

yeah, whatever you say.

[WellardSaint]

This is starting to sound like the Essendon board at Bigfooty.

[Teflon]

Milera has gone back, played well kicked 6 and got plenty of it as he can also run further up midfield....he deserves to come in.

Milne to Sandy.