So what do we think of Adam Schnieder's game?

[skeptic]

Only caught the last half on radio...

what did people think?

[plugger66]

He was apple crumble today. But normally pretty good.

[battye]

He was okay. Which made him one of our better players today.

[BigMart]

5/10

[saintsRrising]

Only caught the last half on radio...

what did people think?

0.4 = villain

2.2 = pass with his general play

4.0 = hero

Unfortunately he kicked 0.4


Roo also missed two very gettable goals in his 0.3

[slider]

Fair

[WinnersOnly]

I haven't been impressed by any of his footy since his return - time to reward Tom Ledger and give Schneider a reminder.

Maybe its time to play a few other kids also eg Markworth, Newnes and Webster also.

[plugger66]

I haven't been impressed by any of his footy since his return - time to reward Tom Ledger and give Schneider a reminder.

Maybe its time to play a few other kids also eg Markworth, Newnes and Webster also.

Would anyone be in our side now if you had your way?

[desertsaint]

Not a fan. Seems to choose when to put in an effort.

[paddy]

think he played quite well, was well placed, he just missed a few set shots... the construction really messes with the wind at SCG at the moment...

Milney had the idea.... kick it high and hard...

schnides was probably a little to soft a touch and the ball carried

[skeptic]

SEN described his game as "dangerous but ineffective".

Seems to me that they may have accurately summed him as a player with that one sentence

Is frequently talked about as one of our best top 10 players... I think he's been average since 2010 with a few good cameos and a lot of games where he does a few good things.

I would think that most people would agree that he is a more talented player than Milne... I know who I'd pick first though.

WHen you compare all of our small forwards in Milne, Schneider, Milera and Saad... 3 of them have had at least one match winning performance this season

[saintbob]

Snides was good again IMO, missed a a couple of easy shots at goal but you can forgive him for that as he is usually a very good finisher

[gringo]

as said 4 behinds dud 4 goals hero missed some sitters.

[SainterK]

He still cramps an awful lot late in games.

I'd swap him and Dunell this week

[chook23]

much better than kosi

[plugger66]

He still cramps an awful lot late in games.

I'd swap him and Dunell this week

To good to sit on the bench for 3 quarters. If cramp is a concern them sub him off. At least that way we get about 3 quarters from a player much better than Dunnell at this stage.

[saintbob]

much better than kosi

Who in turn was much better than Roo

[SainterK]

He still cramps an awful lot late in games.

I'd swap him and Dunell this week

To good to sit on the bench for 3 quarters. If cramp is a concern them sub him off. At least that way we get about 3 quarters from a player much better than Dunnell at this stage.

Yeah, but they seem to want to sub off a tall for a small with the sub, otherwise I'd agree....3 quarters would be good from Schneids.

[chook23]

much better than kosi

Who in turn was much better than Roo

part of the reason roo struggled was that HE WAS again knocked stupid by the overrated Kosi

[SainterK]

much better than kosi

Who in turn was much better than Roo

part of the reason roo struggled was that HE WAS again knocked stupid by the overrated Kosi

Maybe Roo shouldn't try to mark everything, did it last week as well, calling guys out of everything.

Doesn't need to be the dude all the time, just to play his role.

They haven't been impeding each others space for ages now, still think we looked our best this year when he was playing traditional CHF, Kosi roaming in the 50...in fact I'd rather Kosi attempt the pack marks as he is better at cannoning them all over.

[chook23]

Kosi overall .........career very disappointing

Roo overall............a champion over his career

both have bad days though...............kosi many more though

[SainterK]

Just saying that Roo should never contest a mark when Kosi is attempting to take a pack mark, and should wait for the inevitable spillage, think that is just common sense....let him bowl everyone in the opposition over.

[1965 Saint]

Never kicks eawhen it matters (09 GF!!!) We really needed him today and he didnt deliver

[skeptic]

Snides was good again IMO, missed a a couple of easy shots at goal but you can forgive him for that as he is usually a very good finisher

when was the last time that happened?

[ralphsmith]

Deliberately missed easy goals against his former adoring fans.