Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

out
Cripps

In
Schneider

[Beno88]

In : Geary, Schneider

Out : Cripps, Newnes

Emergencies : Newnes, Clarke, Wilkes

[Wrote for Luck]

In: Clarke
Out: Cripps

[Ralphy]

out cripps newnes
Ins
Clarke Schneider

[stkildathunda]

Probably no change tonight as club tries to hide things as per usual... But think final changes will be:

IN: Wilkes, Schneider, Raph
OUT: Kosi, Cripps, Newnes

[WinnersOnly]

In: Geary & Schnieder
Out: Gwilt & Cripps

[SainterK]

Into the extended squad

Geary, Schneider, Clarke

Final changes
Out Cripps Siposs
In Geary Schneider

[Old Mate]

Out
Newnes & Cripps

In
Geary & Schneider

[trojansaint]

Out: Cripps

In: Schneider (Sub)

Siposs to get a full game.

Emergencies:
Clarke, Ledger, Geary

[borderbarry]

Out.. Cripps

In... Clarke

[Quixote]

Probably no change tonight as club tries to hide things as per usual... But think final changes will be:

IN: Wilkes, Schneider, Raph
OUT: Kosi, Cripps, Newnes

Kosi out?

[SainterK]

Someone on true sainters (who they appear to think would know) said Kosi has a quad strain Quixote

...and that Gilbert also carrying back injury.

Not sure about this info being in the public doman though, not good I would of thought.

[stkildathunda]

Someone on true sainters (who they appear to think would know) said Kosi has a quad strain Quixote

...and that Gilbert also carrying back injury.

Not sure about this info being in the public doman though, not good I would of thought.

Well theres that but also

haha nah also think he could do with rest as hasnt look right the last couple weeks and has looked like he is carrying something.

[Quixote]

Someone on true sainters (who they appear to think would know) said Kosi has a quad strain Quixote

...and that Gilbert also carrying back injury.

Not sure about this info being in the public doman though, not good I would of thought.

Thanks K.

Bugger! We're getting injuries to all the wrong players.

[The Redeemer]

Out Cripps
In Schneider

No real reason to change anything else although I think that Jack Newnes does not really deserve a spot based on his performance Friday. That in mind I do not see the point in bringing a youngen in one week and then dropping the next week. He didn't do anything but he didn't have a stinker by any stretch.

[bergsone]

Out Gram

In Schneider

[Eastern]

We need to look at it on two fronts;

1. Who has earnt a spot, and

2. Who deserves to be dropped

On the 1st point Geary & Raph would have to the 1st couple in line, followed by Schneids who may need one more week

On the 2nd point form would suggest that Gilbo might be skating on thin ice & Cripps didn't show much last week. Newnes was servicable without setting the world on fire

So, my prediction is;

In: Geary

Out: Cripps

Sub: Newnes

Unlucky: Raph

Emergencies: Raph, Wilkes, Schneider

Disclaimer: There might be injuries/soreness that we don't know about

[saintspremiers]

Out Gram

In Schneider

Gram out why?

Because he kicked 2 goals in the last?

Or do you have NFI???

[Dave McNamara]

In: Clarke
Out: Cripps

My pick too - which means it's unlikely.

Must say that I'd be worried about Gears coming in. He may be right, but if he had a fracture, why risk another knock to the head so soon, when we are only playing the Sons of Beaches??? Rest him longer and make sure I reckon. We need Mrs G's boy fit and healthy!

Also, as much as I want the Schneiderman and little Lenny in, I reckon Raph would be the go as he would provide another defender, and also allow Grammy to move to his happier hunting ground on the wing. Sooooo...,

Out: Cripps (inj), the Gran who started against the Tuggers.
In: Clarke, the Grrrrrrr-am who finished against the Tuggers.
Sub: Don't know???? Want Sippa for a full game. Raph is not suited to subbing. Maybe that only leaves Newnes, but I want him to have a full game...(?) Arrrgh, it's all too difficult...!!!
Emerg: Ledge', Schnieds', Wilkesy.



Go Raph! Go the Grrrrrrrrr-aminator!

[bergsone]

Out Gram

In Schneider

Gram out why?

Because he kicked 2 goals in the last?

Or do you have NFI???

Because imo form doesnt warrant it.NFI HEY i dont play favourites like some on here.I waant to see more than just acouple of good efforts ,if he plays this week and does well,good for him/us

NFI ,well maybe we can discuss this as well,but I dont feel as I need to put down on a forum my career in this game

[bakes]

In : Geary, Schneider

Out : Cripps (injured), Gram (omitted)

Sub: Schneider
Unlucky: Raph Clarke
Newnes will be a gun and will play out the rest of the year in the 1's so that they can pump as much experience into him as possible.

Re: Gram: we need to start looking to the future.

[bakes]

Also, I'd like to see Seb Ross make his debut. Watters gave him big wraps pre-season with likening him to Pendlebury, so I'd like to blood as many of these kids with potential as we can, and be prepared for some short term pain whilst looking towards the future.

[Eastern]

Also, I'd like to see Seb Ross make his debut. Watters gave him big wraps pre-season with likening him to Pendlebury, so I'd like to blood as many of these kids with potential as we can, and be prepared for some short term pain whilst looking towards the future.

We are still in finals contention so bring him in IF it is considered that he is in our BEST 22. If he is anything short of this he needs to be developed at Sandy. Lets not forget that we now have a very good development structure in place !!

[saintspremiers]

Out Gram

In Schneider

Gram out why?

Because he kicked 2 goals in the last?

Or do you have NFI???

Because imo form doesnt warrant it.NFI HEY i dont play favourites like some on here.I waant to see more than just acouple of good efforts ,if he plays this week and does well,good for him/us

NFI ,well maybe we can discuss this as well,but I dont feel as I need to put down on a forum my career in this game

FYI he had 22 possies, laid 6 tackles as well as his pathetic 2 goals.

Who now has NFI??

[bakes]

saintspremiers, statistics can be misleading as we know with the Ablett V Dale Thomas scenario last week.
A player can have only 10 possessions yet have a huge impact on the game, whilst a players can have 50 possessions and not have a meaningful influence.
Healthy debate is good btw, no need for anyone to attack other posters based on their opinion.
Gram seems to be one player who definitely divides opinions! Match committee has tough calls to make each week.