Worst 25 possession game ever played.

[BigMart]

Has lost all confidence, and Richmond players were bagging the f*** out of him..... And he looked like he was going to cry.

HTFU ..... Mentally!

He's pretty tough physically, mentally shallow.

If he ain't rested, we are not fair dinkum

[saintspremiers]

Hate to agree. Like a rabbit in the spotlight.

Luckily we play GC next week. Good chance to make a few changes.

[james rose]

Sadly I agree- its a shame because he can be a gun.

[BigMart]

Well he directly cost us 4 goals.... Incredible really

[seano1]

who ?

[CURLY]

Had to ruck and hit some really good leads yeah he got caught but why give it to him on his right? Milne was worse.

[jays]

Gilbert needs to go

[cross2012]

No right side and needs to take first option. Did a few nice things though

[elvis lives]

Was almost like he was playing for the wrong team. If he stays in the side there is something seriously wrong at the selection table. Although I did say that about Blake five weeks ago and he has well and truely proven me wrong so hopefully gilbo can do the same

[seano1]

ahh quite correct hes gone gone gone needs to see a shrink , ever since the photos thing last year hes gone off the boil

[8856brother]

Terry Smith

[mr six o'clock]

who ?

[rexy]

Saw some good signs personally, will be a tough decision when Fisher is ready, Simpkin Gwilt Gilbert Gram could all make way for him IMO

[Hurricane]

I think he has been beyond poor all season. Why is he still getting a game?

Send him back to Sandy for some confidence and a bit of a freshen up or send him on holidays or whatever it takes to get his head right, his form back and his s*** togther.

At his best he is a great weapon for us and I really hope he gets back to that asap

BANG BANG

[Bad Co.]

Thought he tried really hard, but confidence absolutely shot to pieces ATM. Can't believe how clean his touch and marking were in '09, how bad now.

You're right, maybe a run for Sandy will do him the world of good.

[Austinnn]

I think he could get dropped for a game or two, not as punishment, but to work his way back into confidence. That's all that's really missing. Needs to be assured that there will be a place for him when he finds his mojo again, but at the moment he's like a runaway train.

He's not going to work his way back in the seniors I'm sorry to say, he needs a game or two against much easier opposition to make him feel like a star again.

Ever since the scandal, he's been a problem, not completely terrible; he does some good things and some bad things. In the old days, it was just good things and he was one of our stars.

Biggest problem was bad choice of girlfriend. Bet he wishes he could turn back that clock...

[Teflon]

Gram before Gilbert - at least he put his body in.

Sure, hes a dumb player lets be honest....but every side has one and hes ours....Gram punces around.....

[felix]

Get a life

[Hughjarce]

Gwilt was worse. A shadow of the player from the past few years. Yes, I know he is short of match practice but he would surely make way for Fisher.

[BigMart]

But Gram (who was shocking early) probably got us back in the game with a blitz in the last qtr

Gilbert was costly.

[skeptic]

it really is a wonder isn't it... has been badly out of touch for nearly a season and a half... why won't they drop him?

it can't be good for his confidence getting his butt handed on a platter to him week after week

[Austinnn]

Gwilt was worse. A shadow of the player from the past few years. Yes, I know he is short of match practice but he would surely make way for Fisher.

No.

He's just come back, and will be given more than 2 games to prove himself. The end.

[Teflon]

But Gram (who was shocking early) probably got us back in the game with a blitz in the last qtr

Gilbert was costly.

I'll take effort as our previous coach preached so much...over 2 minutes of flashy goals anyday...

Gilberts not a smart player, has Clark-itis on occasion but he at least attacks the ball and aint averse to putting the body in.

Gram picks and chooses for mine - cameo's dont cut it.

[St Ick]

I say bypass Sandy, send him to the year 12 formal! Played his best footy when he was mucking around with.... well... you know the story....

[Teflon]

Gwilt was worse. A shadow of the player from the past few years. Yes, I know he is short of match practice but he would surely make way for Fisher.

er...no.

When Gwilt goes near the footy or has it in his hands.....I get a "warm, fuzzy" feeling inside.
When Gilbert has it my whole body goes numb....waiting for the eff up (same from Milne who was also ordinary tonight)