Ahmed Saad??

[ShanghaiSaint]

where is he when will we see him play????

[stkildathunda]

Been playing VFL and not really setting world on fire. Also been suspended for last few weeks and makes his return today.

[ShanghaiSaint]

Been playing VFL and not really setting world on fire. Also been suspended for last few weeks and makes his return today.

thanks for the info mate.

[8856brother]

Still has a fair way to go from what I have seen in 3 qtrs today.

[ShanghaiSaint]

Still has a fair way to go from what I have seen in 3 qtrs today.

also watching sandy and the pies atm, I hear what you guys are saying from watching him in todays game. Siposs looking good though.

[savatage]

Stood up when it counted. 2 goals in the last quarter when the heat was on & set up another.

[bigred]

Small forward remember.

He wasn't terrible today.

[Foz]

Just looked to lack a little 'touch' today after a week off suspended.

Would be good to throw him up the ground occassionally with his pace.

[8856brother]

Small forward remember.

He wasn't terrible today.

His touch was. Last qtr saved his day. Up till then he was pretty ordinary. Still needs more time IMO.

[Stillwaiting]

Small forward remember.

He wasn't terrible today.

His touch was. Last qtr saved his day. Up till then he was pretty ordinary. Still needs more time IMO.

So from what you have seen of him, do you think he will eventually make it at AFL level?

[8856brother]

Small forward remember.

He wasn't terrible today.

His touch was. Last qtr saved his day. Up till then he was pretty ordinary. Still needs more time IMO.

So from what you have seen of him, do you think he will eventually make it at AFL level?

Hopefully. Not a cert. Definately not in the next few weeks.

[stkildathunda]

He needs to add something else to his game. You cant make it as just a goal sneak in AFL these days. Needs to be able to run in midfield or something like that, which i dont think Saad is able to do. Last year his highest possession count for a game was 15 from memory. Think he averaged about 10 for year. So doesnt get great deal of the ball.

[on the outer]

At the moment I think Saad will only get a game if Milne is injured or suspended during the year, he has a good goal sense and the knack for being in the right place at the right time but as mentioned above while he is fast he needs to add some petrol to the tank in order to take a turn in the midfield if required.

[bobmurray]

Small forward remember.

He wasn't terrible today.

His touch was. Last qtr saved his day. Up till then he was pretty ordinary. Still needs more time IMO.

So from what you have seen of him, do you think he will eventually make it at AFL level?

I reckon Dunell might have a better chance of making it....

[8856brother]

In his defence. In the first half, he was in front, and on the lead today when the delivery went over his head at least twice in the forward 50. His actual vertical leap to try to get at both kicks was quite impressive. That didn't help his cause. If the kicks were as they should have been, he may well have had 2 or 3 at half time.