Team v North - Extended bench

SainterK · Post: # 1097247Post **SainterK** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:09pm

North v St K

McQualter, Polo, Lynch, Ledger for Koschitzke.

Pratt, McKinley, McMahon, Hansen for Delaney

goddardisgod · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:12pm

No Johnson or Walsh......

Hmmmm....

Armoooo · Post: # 1097251Post **Armoooo** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:12pm

Some handy ins for them...
McMahon is a pretty underrated small defender IMO, McKinley is average but has played well against us in the past, Hansen has tore us apart from memory, Pratt is meh.

I'm pretty disappointed that Walsh still hasn't managed to get a game. I hope that it's Lynch or Ledger to come in... or better yet Lynch AND Ledger for Kosi and Raph.

Hallalj#3 · Post: # 1097253Post **Hallalj#3** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:12pm

That's embarassing.. Let it only be lynch and ledger please..

thequarry · Post: # 1097254Post **thequarry** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:13pm

I was under the impression Raph couldn't play if he'd been "dropped" to the VFL last week? He's been named on the extended bench.

Does anyone know the official ruling for sure on that one?

fingers · Post: # 1097255Post **fingers** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:15pm

I'd like to claim my correct guess in "Guess this weeks ins and outs" on McQualter and Ledger.

Con Gorozidis · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:15pm

Hallalj#3 wrote:That's embarassing.. Let it only be lynch and ledger please..

+1 has to be lynch and ledger. what do we gain from polo and mcqualter ?

if lyon picks polo and/or mcqualter he has mental issues.

i believe raph is eligible to play because we got permission from the afl.

sainterinsydney · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:17pm

B: James Gwilt, Zac Dawson, Farren Ray

HB: Brendon Goddard, Sam Fisher, Sean Dempster

C: Nick Dal Santo, Jack Steven, Jason Gram

HF: Brett Peake, Nick Riewoldt, Sam Gilbert

F: Stephen Milne, Ryan Gamble, Adam Schneider

Foll: Ben McEvoy, Clinton Jones, Leigh Montagna

I/C: Steven Baker, Raphael Clarke, David Armitage, Andrew McQualter, Tom Lynch, Tom Ledger, Dean Polo

In: Andrew McQualter, Tom Lynch, Tom Ledger, Dean Polo

Out: Justin Koschitzke (Suspension)
North Melbourne

B: Scott Thompson, Cameron Pedersen, Michael Firrito

HB: Brady Rawlings, Nathan Grima, Levi Greenwood

C: Daniel Wells, Brent Harvey, Andrew Swallow

HF: Jack Ziebell, Aaron Edwards, Ben Cunnington

F: Lindsay Thomas, Drew Petrie, Ryan Bastinac

Foll: Todd Goldstein, Leigh Adams, Liam Anthony

I/C: Scott McMahon, Daniel Pratt, Lachlan Hansen, Ben McKinley, Cameron Richardson, Shaun Atley, Kieran Harper

In: Scott McMahon, Daniel Pratt, Lachlan Hansen, Ben McKinley

Out: Luke Delaney (Shoulder)

sainterinsydney · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:18pm

That forward line is preety scary--and not the good kind of scary!

Con Gorozidis · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:20pm

we could lose this.

gram was woeful last week. mcqualter, polo, raph and gamble are all pretty rubbish lets be honest.

sainterinsydney · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:21pm

How many goals does Will Johnson have to kick to get a game? This is ridiculous!

saintjake · Post: # 1097263Post **saintjake** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:22pm

naming Gamble at Full Forward really wouldnt worry any other team.
Id Rather see Milney play one out then Gamble.

SainterK · Post: # 1097265Post **SainterK** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:23pm

sainterinsydney wrote:How many goals does Will Johnson have to kick to get a game? This is ridiculous!

He didn't train, don't think I saw him at all...he could be injured.

Junction Oval · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:26pm

Like other Posters, it's disappointing that we couldn't find room for Johnson in particular and to a lesser degree, Walsh.

If Ledger and Lynch do not get a game, I will be very disappointed.

Junction Oval · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:28pm

I forgot SainterK, that you mentioned in your Training Report, that Johnson didn't train yesterday - must be injured.

joffaboy · Post: # 1097268Post **joffaboy** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:29pm

goddardisgod wrote:No Johnson or Walsh......

Hmmmm....

You blokes should really get down to Sandy and see how they are going before you comment.

ALL of those selected were better than both Walsh and Johnson last week, or should they selected out of form players for the hell of it?

joffaboy · Post: # 1097269Post **joffaboy** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:31pm

Junction Oval wrote:Like other Posters, it's disappointing that we couldn't find room for Johnson in particular and to a lesser degree, Walsh.

If Ledger and Lynch do not get a game, I will be very disappointed.

ledger went OK for Sandy. Lynch was getting an absolute bath against Brett Eddy before he injured a knee.

Hope Lynch is played up forward if he gets a game because we will get killed with him down back.

borderbarry · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:33pm

Disappointing. Particularly if they go with the first four named on the bench, which they normally do.

saintjake · Post: # 1097271Post **saintjake** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:33pm

joffaboy wrote:
Junction Oval wrote:Like other Posters, it's disappointing that we couldn't find room for Johnson in particular and to a lesser degree, Walsh.

If Ledger and Lynch do not get a game, I will be very disappointed.
ledger went OK for Sandy. Lynch was getting an absolute bath against Brett Eddy before he injured a knee.

Hope Lynch is played up forward if he gets a game because we will get killed with him down back.

No but they could select to fix the gaping hole we have at Full Forward.

Dr Spaceman · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:36pm

Junction Oval wrote:I forgot SainterK, that you mentioned in your Training Report, that Johnson didn't train yesterday - must be injured.

Will's current tweets suggest he is "unwell" rather than injured.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1097275Post **Mr Magic** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:37pm

Junction Oval wrote:Like other Posters, it's disappointing that we couldn't find room for Johnson in particular and to a lesser degree, Walsh.

If Ledger and Lynch do not get a game, I will be very disappointed.

Just curious, why will you be 'very disappointed'? (not actually directiung this to you persoanally but to all the posters making remarks about the team selection)

Do you know why certain selections were made?

Do you know what match-ups we've got planned?

Do you know which players are 100% ready to go?

Do you know which players did the jobs they were required by the coaches to do last game and at traning?

I find it amazing that posters are making negative comments about selections without knowing anything as to the reasoning behind those selections.

And if I was Mini I would just retire.
It seems pointless to continue playing because immaterial if he plays well in the reserves or not, he shouldn't be 'picked' because 'keyboard warriors' state that he shouldn't be.
Others should just be selected in front of him even though he's performing much better than them over an extended period of time.

Sometimes I just shake my head at the 'barracking' that passes for informed opinion on here.

Solar · Post: # 1097277Post **Solar** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:40pm

The forward line is a bit of a joke

saintbob · Post: # 1097278Post **saintbob** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:42pm

Hallalj#3 wrote:That's embarassing.. Let it only be lynch and ledger please..

Agree 100%

Why no Johnson or Walsh surely they would be a better option than McQualter.

InkerSaint · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:44pm

Armoooo wrote:I'm pretty disappointed that Walsh still hasn't managed to get a game. I hope that it's Lynch or Ledger to come in... or better yet Lynch AND Ledger for Kosi and Raph.

+1.

Jacks Back · Thu 30 Jun 2011 6:46pm

Tommy Walsh is a rookie? Has he been elevated?

From memory he may of for either Gardiner or Hayes.