Rumour - Luke Miles delisted?

[The Saintsational Man]

I've heard this from a friend who claims to know Luke and that's the story I was told.....

Please someone tell me it isn't so?

[ace]

I've heard this from a friend who claims to know Luke and that's the story I was told.....

Please someone tell me it isn't so?

IT ISN'T SO.

[Saintersss]

Wouldn't be that surprised. I mean he looked okay in his 2 games this season, but to be honest he hasn't showed that much in his 3 years. Hasn't played that well in the VFL. Although I'd probably prefer if we keep him.

If the rumours are true that we are taking Bruce, maybe the saints wanted to keep 4 picks in the draft for kids, so they delisted him...

[Con Gorozidis]

Wouldn't be that surprised. I mean he looked okay in his 2 games this season, but to be honest he hasn't showed that much in his 3 years. Hasn't played that well in the VFL. Although I'd probably prefer if we keep him.

If the rumours are true that we are taking Bruce, maybe the saints wanted to keep 4 picks in the draft for kids, so they delisted him...

what rumours say we are getting bruce? and if we want to keep our 4 picks for kids i can think of a few who id de-list before luke. id be SHOCKED.

[ace]

We can't delist him.
If Stanley plays in next year's grand final we will need Miles to win the half time sprint.

[Moccha]

According to the Aged apparently hasn't signed a contract yet along with Gardie, Demspter and Eddy

[Teflon]

Id be keeping him ahead of Eddy/Mcqualter IMO Miles hasnt even had the chance to show what he can do and from the little I saw he played ok - surely worth a shot?

[SainterK]

According to the Aged apparently hasn't signed a contract yet along with Gardie, Dempster and Eddy

Surely I won't already have to change my sig

[Dr Spaceman]

According to the Aged apparently hasn't signed a contract yet along with Gardie, Dempster and Eddy

Surely I won't already have to change my sig

No doubt this will all become a lot clearer at List Lodgement 2 at 2pm today.

[Bardon Saint]

According to the Aged apparently hasn't signed a contract yet along with Gardie, Dempster and Eddy

Surely I won't already have to change my sig

No doubt this will all become a lot clearer at List Lodgement 2 at 2pm today.

Yeah and then until it is made public possibly weeks later

[Bardon Saint]

Wouldn't be that surprised. I mean he looked okay in his 2 games this season, but to be honest he hasn't showed that much in his 3 years. Hasn't played that well in the VFL. Although I'd probably prefer if we keep him.

If the rumours are true that we are taking Bruce, maybe the saints wanted to keep 4 picks in the draft for kids, so they delisted him...

I really liked the way he played. Very composed in the game against Adelaide?

[borderbarry]

Accoding to todays paper it is Eddy who looks gone, which I find odd given the amount of finals Ross has had him in.

[saintlee]

Could easily be both Eddy and Miles delisted. Neither are that important. But personally I think Miles is worth keep for another year, seemed composed in the 2 games he played this year.

[saintspremiers]

Could easily be both Eddy and Miles delisted. Neither are that important. But personally I think Miles is worth keep for another year, seemed composed in the 2 games he played this year.

scrap both of them.

They'll never been anything more than GOP's.

I did like Eddy's work ethic, and perhaps he can do a Gwilt or Sam Fisher and go from a GOP to a top player, but that rarely happens.

[Dr Spaceman]

Could easily be both Eddy and Miles delisted. Neither are that important. But personally I think Miles is worth keep for another year, seemed composed in the 2 games he played this year.

scrap both of them.

They'll never been anything more than GOP's.

I did like Eddy's work ethic, and perhaps he can do a Gwilt or Sam Fisher and go from a GOP to a top player, but that rarely happens.

Eddy & McQualter are probably both great guys, and there's no doubt they have a crack, but if one or both of them are no longer at our club @ 2pm I won't lose any sleep.

[jays]

keep miles he has pace

[Con Gorozidis]

Id be keeping him ahead of Eddy/Mcqualter IMO Miles hasnt even had the chance to show what he can do and from the little I saw he played ok - surely worth a shot?

+ 1

would seem odd that some get countless opportunities (32 and 40) and luke gets 2 games. he played ok and at least hes quick which lord knows is an area we are weak.

[Con Gorozidis]

Could easily be both Eddy and Miles delisted. Neither are that important. But personally I think Miles is worth keep for another year, seemed composed in the 2 games he played this year.

scrap both of them.

They'll never been anything more than GOP's.

I did like Eddy's work ethic, and perhaps he can do a Gwilt or Sam Fisher and go from a GOP to a top player, but that rarely happens.

gwilt was always good when he got the ball. he just didnt get it a lot when he was first on the scene. eddy doesnt get it and when he does tends to handball at his mates feet and/or cough it up.

and those saying miles is no good. hes had a lot of excellent games at sandy in the last 3 years. gets a stack of ball at vfl level. id play him armo and al smith regularly to let them get into a rhythm at afl level and then we can decide

[Saintersss]

Could easily be both Eddy and Miles delisted. Neither are that important. But personally I think Miles is worth keep for another year, seemed composed in the 2 games he played this year.

scrap both of them.

They'll never been anything more than GOP's.

I did like Eddy's work ethic, and perhaps he can do a Gwilt or Sam Fisher and go from a GOP to a top player, but that rarely happens.

gwilt was always good when he got the ball. he just didnt get it a lot when he was first on the scene. eddy doesnt get it and when he does tends to handball at his mates feet and/or cough it up.

and those saying miles is no good. hes had a lot of excellent games at sandy in the last 3 years. gets a stack of ball at vfl level. id play him armo and al smith regularly to let them get into a rhythm at afl level and then we can decide

You haven't watched him in the VFL have you?

[borderbarry]

The five unsigned players, Gardi, who there is still some doubt as to whether he is to continue, no contract will be signed until that decision is made but there is not a lot of time left.
Dempster, Mcqualter, Eddy, all in our bottom six. Then Miles who is not quite in our best 22 yet, but I would keep him out of those four.
With List Lodgement 2 this afternoon it will be interesting to see if any are let go.

[Moccha]

got to get rid of McQualter

[st_Trav_ofWA]

i heard a rumour back in july Luke was heading back to perth ....

[shmic_s]

i heard a rumour back in july Luke was heading back to perth ....

That's no good. Was hoping there is still a chance of being re-drafted/rookied.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

i heard a rumour back in july Luke was heading back to perth ....

That's no good. Was hoping there is still a chance of being re-drafted/rookied.

might still happen but i hear his old WAFL club Swan Districts are keen to get him back ... provided he doesnt get drafted to another AFL club

[mad saint guy]

Extreme pace, good defensive skills, composed under pressure and neat disposal. Unless there was a serious injury problem I'm seeing no good reason for his delisting. I'd definitely have him on the list before Cahill, Johnson, Dempster, Peake, Baker, Heyne and even Raph with his injury record.