Eddy ... support for another whipping boy

[terry smith rules]

I thought he was great for the game time he got (about 65%)

He was one of the few that hit a target all night, 2 or 3 bullet passes.

He tackled and at one point sold some candy.

He definitely holds his spot.

I can't believe people here keep gunning for the same guys, whatever they do or however we play.

[thejiggingsaint]

Everyone who wears the jumper is open to praise and (when needed) constructive criticism. Whipping boys are the domain of idiots and bullies!
Our club just doesn't need 'em!

[barks4eva]

I thought Eddy was good, looks much improved, more solid, will get better!

[undecided]

He was involved in atleast 3 of our goals.

[Saint Bev]

Don't call the poor boy a whipping boy, hasn't played many games and did a pretty good job last night. Really nice guy as well.

[terry smith rules]

Don't call the poor boy a whipping boy, hasn't played many games and did a pretty good job last night. Really nice guy as well.

did you read the post?

[BigMart]

I don't rate him....heplayed pretty well in this game.

[derby Street]

I thought he was great for the game time he got (about 65%)

He was one of the few that hit a target all night, 2 or 3 bullet passes.

He tackled and at one point sold some candy.

He definitely holds his spot.

I can't believe people here keep gunning for the same guys, whatever they do or however we play.

A reasonable effort in this game - eventually won't hold his place when we get a couple back. Strength - has a big motor - weakness - burns the ball

[meher baba]

He seems better each time we see him: his foot passing is definitely improving, although it still has too much loop in it for my liking.

I doubt he will ever become more than a backup, but he's an ok one.

[Beekay]

I doubt he will ever become more than a backup, but he's an ok one.

lol bit harsh. how many games has he played and how old is he?

[Saint Bev]

Don't call the poor boy a whipping boy, hasn't played many games and did a pretty good job last night. Really nice guy as well.

did you read the post?

Yes I did, and pretty sure the subject says "Support, for Eddy, another whipping boy" hence why I said people should say that.

[borderbarry]

We had two emergencies in S.A., Eddy and Steven. Steven has only played one game, and he impressed me more than Eddy has in any of his. Steven appears to be much quicker, and is a goal kicker. What will it take for him to get another game? Our selectors to get a bit of courage and faith, or what?

[plugger66]

We had two emergencies in S.A., Eddy and Steven. Steven has only played one game, and he impressed me more than Eddy has in any of his. Steven appears to be much quicker, and is a goal kicker. What will it take for him to get another game? Our selectors to get a bit of courage and faith, or what?

Well only one could play and Eddy was there first choice. Steven will get his chance.

[terry smith rules]

Don't call the poor boy a whipping boy, hasn't played many games and did a pretty good job last night. Really nice guy as well.

did you read the post?

Yes I did, and pretty sure the subject says "Support, for Eddy, another whipping boy" hence why I said people should say that.

sorry Bev

you need to reread the post, I give him a big wrap and there are no commas in my topic line

and amongst some here he is a whipping boy, hence the topic line

[Spinner]

Eddy did well!

Clean possession, cant say the same for others ie Geary.

[MCG-Unit]

15 poss, 8 contested, 80% Eff, and 5 tackles in 62% game time

Not sure how much more Eddy could have done