Corrected goal decision WCE v Ess

Bono · Post: # 881342Post **Bono** » Sat 13 Feb 2010 7:39pm

Isnt is amazing that they can look at the scoreboard to see a goal decision error in a NAB Cup match but dont refer to anything in an AFL Grand Final when a Premiership is on the line!!!!!

Sainterman · Post: # 881348Post **Sainterman** » Sat 13 Feb 2010 7:59pm

Made me think about that too.

Shame, but I guess that was the catalyst for change...

hAyES · Post: # 881351Post **hAyES** » Sat 13 Feb 2010 8:13pm

That was the first thing I thought of. Frustrating to say the least!

#1GILL · Post: # 881352Post **#1GILL** » Sat 13 Feb 2010 8:14pm

What's done is done.

The more important thing is that it won't(shouldn't) happen again.

Milan Faletic · Sat 13 Feb 2010 8:29pm

I agree. We always have to suffer first and then there is a rule change.

matrix · Post: # 881439Post **matrix** » Sun 14 Feb 2010 10:22am

tissue???

stinger · Post: # 881552Post **stinger** » Sun 14 Feb 2010 8:59pm

matrix wrote:tissue???

why?...it was a valid comment.......hd's got your number....afaic......

Cro · Post: # 881661Post **Cro** » Mon 15 Feb 2010 2:45pm

My understanding was that the umpires coach contacted the umpire with the ear piece in and told him to go and reverse the mistake.

Would have been two AFL games in a row with horrible mistakes made.

saint66au · Post: # 881854Post **saint66au** » Tue 16 Feb 2010 7:57am

Its not that hard..you can refer decisions to video in NAB Cup..you cant in Home and Away games

Sheesh..did I hear anyone calling for 4 goal umpires or video review in 2004 when Aussie Jones' shot went wide but was called a point??. No..people were too busy complaining that they showed it too many times...oh and we benefited from it and won the game so its "just one of those things"

Anyone who thinks its always St Kilda that suffers from these things should go take a look at Saturday nights NAB game. Every single time a new rule or re-interpretation of an old rule was applied, Hawthorn benefited from it. They even mentioned it in the commentary. If we'd copped all the bad breaks Richmond got in that game there'd be people here thinking it was all a plan to undermine St Kilda this year cos we were too successful in 2009

Ya win some and you lose some..its not all a grand plan to see St Kilda shafted **evil laugh**

kosifantutti23 · Tue 16 Feb 2010 8:46am

saint66au wrote:Its not that hard..you can refer decisions to video in NAB Cup..you cant in Home and Away games

I think they trialled this once with a video umpire but it's not part of the rules now. And it certainly needs to be a more rigorous process than the field umpire glancing up at the scoreboard to confirm something.

And Aussie's kick was a point!

matrix · Post: # 881899Post **matrix** » Tue 16 Feb 2010 12:03pm

stinger wrote:
matrix wrote:tissue???
why?...it was a valid comment.......hd's got your number....afaic......

excuse you???
HD has my number??
well im still waiting for a call
and errrr, you need to comment about another thread in a totally dif section of the forum in here?
post it in the general forum in the relevant topic if you have something to say
otherwise thats hijacking and ill run to the mods and cry that im being picked on
then i can use the tissues i was offering later.

stinger · Post: # 882623Post **stinger** » Wed 17 Feb 2010 5:49pm

matrix wrote:
stinger wrote:
matrix wrote:tissue???
why?...it was a valid comment.......hd's got your number....afaic......
excuse you???
HD has my number??
well im still waiting for a call
and errrr, you need to comment about another thread in a totally dif section of the forum in here?
post it in the general forum in the relevant topic if you have something to say
otherwise thats hijacking and ill run to the mods and cry that im being picked on
then i can use the tissues i was offering later.

who's sooking now...ffs

...i can post a link if you like...

..it was a valid comment.,,,,mine above that is......to one of your typical smartarse comments...as i said hd's right.....don't like it..?.tough....