Schneider...
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
- Milton66
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3521
- Joined: Tue 19 May 2009 9:53pm
- Location: None of your goddam business
Schneider...
Of all our trades, I reckon he is the best.
I rate him highly. Has has very good skills, can thread a goal, and has a great footy brain.
He also has finals experience, and has played in a premiership team @ 21.
Is one of the top 10 most important players at our club.
Onve he develops his aerobic capacity, he has the potential to become an elite mid.
Love the Schneids.
I rate him highly. Has has very good skills, can thread a goal, and has a great footy brain.
He also has finals experience, and has played in a premiership team @ 21.
Is one of the top 10 most important players at our club.
Onve he develops his aerobic capacity, he has the potential to become an elite mid.
Love the Schneids.
Hotel De Los Muertos: Your room is ready... Care to step inside?
- SaintWodonga
- Club Player
- Posts: 1868
- Joined: Wed 04 Jul 2007 12:01am
- Location: Wodonga
- Contact:
Re: Schneider...
+1 .. He is a star.Milton66 wrote:Of all our trades, I reckon he is the best.
I rate him highly. Has has very good skills, can thread a goal, and has a great footy brain.
He also has finals experience, and has played in a premiership team @ 21.
Is one of the top 10 most important players at our club.
Onve he develops his aerobic capacity, he has the potential to become an elite mid.
Love the Schneids.
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1357
- Joined: Wed 07 Apr 2004 8:42pm
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30089
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1233 times
Swans had salary cap issues IIRC.
Plus he was getting lazy...and Dempster was to Schneider as C. Gardiner was to King. Thrown in because he would have been delisted otherwise.
I actually believe Dempster is a very good and versatile player. And if it wasn't for him doing his knee last year he would have played every game and be having a crack at his 2nd premiership this year. He'll be back in the side next year.
But yes, Schneids is amazing at times. He really can turn games on their heads...as we all witnessed in 2005.
Here's hoping for a similar performance in 2009...
Plus he was getting lazy...and Dempster was to Schneider as C. Gardiner was to King. Thrown in because he would have been delisted otherwise.
I actually believe Dempster is a very good and versatile player. And if it wasn't for him doing his knee last year he would have played every game and be having a crack at his 2nd premiership this year. He'll be back in the side next year.
But yes, Schneids is amazing at times. He really can turn games on their heads...as we all witnessed in 2005.
Here's hoping for a similar performance in 2009...
- Ghost Like
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 6562
- Joined: Wed 19 Sep 2007 10:04pm
- Has thanked: 5788 times
- Been thanked: 1909 times
A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
- Milton66
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3521
- Joined: Tue 19 May 2009 9:53pm
- Location: None of your goddam business
Agree.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
Hotel De Los Muertos: Your room is ready... Care to step inside?
Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
- Milton66
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3521
- Joined: Tue 19 May 2009 9:53pm
- Location: None of your goddam business
Putting words into people mouths are you?plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
Regardless of Milne's career, I'd still take Schneids. He can play midfield, small fwd and brings more physical pressure than Milney IMO only.
Milne is yet to prove himself in finals... Scheider has.
Hotel De Los Muertos: Your room is ready... Care to step inside?
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 684
- Joined: Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:44pm
Also much younger, at least 4 years or so isn't it?Milton66 wrote:Putting words into people mouths are you?plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
Regardless of Milne's career, I'd still take Schneids. He can play midfield, small fwd and brings more physical pressure than Milney IMO only.
Milne is yet to prove himself in finals... Scheider has.
- sax
- Club Player
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Tue 29 Nov 2005 10:19pm
- Location: Barossa Valley
- Been thanked: 1 time
I'd still take BOTH!!!!Milton66 wrote:Putting words into people mouths are you?plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
Regardless of Milne's career, I'd still take Schneids. He can play midfield, small fwd and brings more physical pressure than Milney IMO only.
Milne is yet to prove himself in finals... Scheider has.
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
milney is a star... best small forward in the comp.
Watch the first quarter against the Hawks. Schneider is as much a star as Milney is. I'd rate Schneids a better kick, tackler and marker of the ball. But Milney wins on epicness.plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
But theres really no reason to get into a debate about this though. Both can break games apart and they're clearly the best small forward duo in the league.
Trio, don't forget Minimick13 wrote:Watch the first quarter against the Hawks. Schneider is as much a star as Milney is. I'd rate Schneids a better kick, tackler and marker of the ball. But Milney wins on epicness.plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
But theres really no reason to get into a debate about this though. Both can break games apart and they're clearly the best small forward duo in the league.
![Wink :wink:](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
True, I reckon Mini's a better kick and tackler than those two...ohwhenthesaints! wrote:Trio, don't forget Minimick13 wrote:Watch the first quarter against the Hawks. Schneider is as much a star as Milney is. I'd rate Schneids a better kick, tackler and marker of the ball. But Milney wins on epicness.plugger66 wrote:Schneider a good player, Milney a star. We easily forget how good Milney is.mick13 wrote:A lot of people thought that Schneider coming to St Kilda would be the end of Milney...Milton66 wrote:If I was left with one pick and had to decide between Schneids and Milne... I'd go Adam, hands down.
As much as I like Milne.
But he works better with another small forward in the side (ala Brent Guerra)
But yeah, I'd choose Schneids over Milney as well. Just a good thing we'll never have to think about doing that!
But theres really no reason to get into a debate about this though. Both can break games apart and they're clearly the best small forward duo in the league.
Imagine if he could get 25 touches a game instead of 15!
- Moccha
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4528
- Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 3:33pm
- Location: Two Pronged Attack
- Contact: