Any problems for Goddard?

saintrod · Post: # 812425Post **saintrod** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:40pm

I didn't see it but some pies supporters said
Goddard would be cited for a head high hit on Thomas. Did anyone see it and has he got anything to worry about?

saintDal · Post: # 812430Post **saintDal** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:41pm

I don't think he got him in the head. It was just a good solid bump.

Enrico_Misso · Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:41pm

Right in front of me in the members.

A beautiful beautiful beautiful bump.

mick13 · Post: # 812433Post **mick13** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:42pm

It looked fair from where we were...

But jesus, he's important to us. Hope he's cleared.

SainterK · Post: # 812434Post **SainterK** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:42pm

Perfect bump, he melted like a snow flake

Moccha · Post: # 812436Post **Moccha** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:42pm

Clutching at straws

st.byron · Post: # 812439Post **st.byron** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:43pm

Nothing in it.
Fair solid bump.
If that gets the attention of the MRP then we might as well play basketball

rexy · Post: # 812440Post **rexy** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:44pm

No where near the head, all good.

Gabba · Post: # 812446Post **Gabba** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:45pm

Fantastic bump! Nothing in it.

Mr Magic · Post: # 812459Post **Mr Magic** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:49pm

And what about the disgusting deliberate taking out of players standing the mark by Collingwood?

Just watched it on a replay and Goddard delivered a perfect bump to the side of the piece of shyte show pony.

Stillwaiting · Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:51pm

Mr Magic wrote:And what about the disgusting deliberate taking out of players standing the mark by Collingwood?

Just watched it on a replay and Goddard delivered a perfect bump to the side of the piece of shyte show pony.

It was a fair bump, but you must remember it was a filth player, so we wait and see

saintrod · Post: # 812482Post **saintrod** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:56pm

Thanks for the re-assurance these pies supporters kept on mouthing off that he wouldn't play for the rest of the year.

saintspremiers · Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:57pm

saintrod wrote:Thanks for the re-assurance these pies supporters kept on mouthing off that he wouldn't play for the rest of the year.

It's good that you are re-assured from a bunch of one-eyed Saints fans!

claystreet · Post: # 812491Post **claystreet** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 7:59pm

Couple of head highs need to be looked at that we deliberate by the filth tossers

BJ good to go son nothing in it

joffaboy · Post: # 812493Post **joffaboy** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:00pm

saintrod wrote:Thanks for the re-assurance these pies supporters kept on mouthing off that he wouldn't play for the rest of the year.

They were talking about Pendelbury and Rocca.

Beautiful - got him right down the middle and the little outside show pony went down like a bag of feral s.hite.

Sainterman · Post: # 812495Post **Sainterman** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:01pm

Great bump and will not be a problem. Did some nice things today BJ, liked that mark he took over Shaw (think it was Shaw). Anyway, nice sure (shaw( hands from BJ!

Sainterman · Post: # 812500Post **Sainterman** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:02pm

joffaboy wrote:
saintrod wrote:Thanks for the re-assurance these pies supporters kept on mouthing off that he wouldn't play for the rest of the year.
They were talking about Pendelbury and Rocca.

Beautiful - got him right down the middle and the little outside show pony went down like a bag of feral s.hite.

Was getting into Daisy as he squibbed about 4 contests in a row...the filth supporter behind me was getting very upset trying to tell me how hard at it he was...lol.

ausfatcat · Post: # 812523Post **ausfatcat** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:06pm

Yep noticed Daisy pull out of a contests a few times today on tele. The worst being with hayes come through could've grabbed the ball but let hayes take it run away (around the 10 min mark of the last quater).

He has no problem running backwards with flight when it's in their forwardline thou.

SuperSaint · Post: # 812529Post **SuperSaint** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:07pm

Just got home and we saw it clearly. He has absolutely no case to answer. It was a fair front on hip and shoulder.

What I did notice is Goddard clutching his thigh in a contest with abou 3 minutes left. He seemed to limp off afterwards and hope it wasn't a hammy.

kp83 · Post: # 812569Post **kp83** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:19pm

Mr Magic wrote:And what about the disgusting deliberate taking out of players standing the mark by Collingwood?

Yes, happened 3 times that I can recall and it was a disgrace that they were allowed to keep doing it.

vacuous space · Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:26pm

No case to answer. I don't think I saw anything reportable from either side3 today. There wasn't any head high contact in Goddard's bump. Any damage to Thomas came because he wasn't paying attention.

Maxwell's hit on Mini was interesting. He won't be in any trouble, but what was he doing there in the first place? After all the talk last week about snipers, he seemed to be hanging around just for the chance to blindside a guy.

Ghost Like · Post: # 812599Post **Ghost Like** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:26pm

That bump by BJ was the best bit of a final I've seen since Burke and Cook gang tackled McKeranan in the '97 Prelim.

If BJ had got him in the head Thomas would not have woken until mid way through pre-season training they hit that hard.

Great play and the perfect example of the Saints back to their best and closing space on the opposition.

goodie · Post: # 812600Post **goodie** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:26pm

Only problem I saw was that he didn't hit him hard enough

perfectionist · Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:26pm

Nothing in the incidents, but he seemed to have hammy problems near the end. That's more of a concern. Hopefully, it was cramp induced hammy problems which tend to be more of a strain than a tear.

felixleo · Post: # 812604Post **felixleo** » Sun 06 Sep 2009 8:27pm

Good solid hard hit to the body which finally woke us up and got us going.