ralph or maxxy?

gosainters66 · Wed 02 Sep 2009 10:41am

whitch 1 ralph or maxxy

markinUSA · Post: # 809154Post **markinUSA** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 10:43am

Hi and welcome to the board.

I just wanted to say, his name is RAPH, or Raphael, but not Ralph.

Just thought I'd share. It's a common mistake, but one that shouldn't go uncorrected on this board.

Cheers
Mark

BringBackMadDog · Wed 02 Sep 2009 10:45am

Who's Ralph?????? If you meant Raph, then I dont understand the question as they play two different roles in the side, Raph is a running, creative half back and Max is a dour stick to it defender who generally plays on the last line of defence. If Max comes in it has to be at the expense of Zac or Blakey

matrix · Post: # 809156Post **matrix** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 10:45am

different players playing in different positions.

both get a gig

SainterK · Post: # 809165Post **SainterK** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:04am

I'll assume you may not entirely understand the positions they play, this was from the Herald Sun today...here is a grab.

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/ ... 42,00.html

Zac Dawson's redemption story has became inextricably linked with Hudghton's heartbreak.

Dawson got his chance this year only when elevated off the rookie list to play in the absence of Hudghton, sidelined with a pre-season calf injury.

Although many ex-St Kilda players and officials can't see a Saints finals side without Hudghton, the evidence points to him being sidelined yet again.

Lyon yesterday conceded Dawson was taking Hudghton's spot, but said no one should criticise him for seizing his chance.

"What is it specifically (that has him in front of Max)? If you really drill down, Zac has probably taken his opportunity," Lyon said.

"Is he the one keeping Max out? Probably more than likely. Zac has played 20 games and Maxy has played seven.

"Max has played seven games injury-interrupted. League footy is about grabbing your chances, whether you are a rookie or a draftee.

"To Zac's credit, who could have pictured this?"

jonesy · Post: # 809176Post **jonesy** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:32am

Ralph-Smith definitely won't come up.....he needs a run,been a very long injury,but could be worth a punt? Maybe for Gilbert...50/50 I guess

gosainters66 · Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:34am

sorry about the speeling of raph but dont take that much notice of his name as i dont rate him at all he is not creative he is destructive , poor use of the football lets him down all the time , they need shuffel the side around to get maxxy back in there cause he is still our best back man

SainterK · Post: # 809188Post **SainterK** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:47am

gosainters66 wrote:sorry about the speeling of raph but dont take that much notice of his name as i dont rate him at all he is not creative he is destructive , poor use of the football lets him down all the time , they need shuffel the side around to get maxxy back in there cause he is still our best back man

Did you read the above, Zac is in for Max? Perhaps you should change the thread title, because it is misleading if you are just wanting to highlight why you don't like a particular player.

redwhite&blackblood · Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:52am

Are you kidding me. Raph easy. Even if Max is ready to play the question isn't if Raph should stay in but of the Cougar stays in which is a tough call anyway even then i side with the Cougar. Max is just unlucky again.

nobhead · Post: # 809195Post **nobhead** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 11:56am

raph will definetly play and his disposal is quite good.better than max's .anyway as previously stated two different type players .its unfair too compare them both .

matrix · Post: # 809204Post **matrix** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:13pm

after the 2nd post by the OP'er im not even gonna bother

markp · Post: # 809205Post **markp** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:13pm

Ralph for milne.

shmic_s · Post: # 809222Post **shmic_s** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:33pm

my cats breath smells like cat food

Milan Faletic · Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:36pm

That depends if Mick Riewoldt or Steven Koschitzke play.

Maybe Nick Hudghton or Max Ball. Not sure

doppler effect · Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:37pm

shmic_s wrote:my cats breath smells like cat food

My cats name is Mittens

Joffa 5 · Post: # 809225Post **Joffa 5** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 12:40pm

gosainters66 wrote:sorry about the speeling of raph but dont take that much notice of his name as i dont rate him at all he is not creative he is destructive , poor use of the football lets him down all the time , they need shuffel the side around to get maxxy back in there cause he is still our best back man

Do you ever call into SEN after games?

Milan Faletic · Wed 02 Sep 2009 1:06pm

Joffa 5 wrote:
gosainters66 wrote:sorry about the speeling of raph but dont take that much notice of his name as i dont rate him at all he is not creative he is destructive , poor use of the football lets him down all the time , they need shuffel the side around to get maxxy back in there cause he is still our best back man
Do you ever call into SEN after games?

Thanks for the laugh during the work day, Joffa 5 or is that Joffer Fie!

I'm busy trying to shovel my speel

redwhite&blackblood · Wed 02 Sep 2009 1:16pm

Joffa 5 wrote:
gosainters66 wrote:sorry about the speeling of raph but dont take that much notice of his name as i dont rate him at all he is not creative he is destructive , poor use of the football lets him down all the time , they need shuffel the side around to get maxxy back in there cause he is still our best back man
Do you ever call into SEN after games?

I am pretty sure he rang and spoke to KB on Raph being the worst St. Kilda player he has ever seen.

eppo67 · Post: # 809278Post **eppo67** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 2:46pm

No match up for Max against filth.

But will play in GF on either Mooney or Hawkins.

IluvHarvey · Post: # 809279Post **IluvHarvey** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 2:47pm

When did Sean RALPH-Smith come back and why is he taking Max's spot?

spert · Post: # 809376Post **spert** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 5:02pm

I would drop Ralph if he hassled me at the pub. Now what was the question?

Thinline · Post: # 809381Post **Thinline** » Wed 02 Sep 2009 5:10pm

The westion quas would Sally Schmilgert or Gabriel Spark play goose man on the fence up against the Blackbirds at the ABC on Sunterday?

ralph or maxxy?

ralph or maxxy?

raph clarke