3-way trade- would we be happy with...

StNoodles · Post: # 659780Post **StNoodles** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:54pm

x. clarke to port

a. thomson to tigers

j. shulz to st kilda

Ralphy · Post: # 659781Post **Ralphy** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:56pm

no.
shulz is crap

degruch · Post: # 659782Post **degruch** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:57pm

Yes, I think J Shulz would be very happy with that trade!

SaintWodonga · Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:57pm

Too many rumours... Not enough facts!

goodie · Post: # 659785Post **goodie** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:58pm

Hell no. Injury prone X outranks squib Schulz

StNoodles · Post: # 659786Post **StNoodles** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 1:59pm

not a rumour, just after opinions

fingers · Post: # 659788Post **fingers** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:01pm

How about

x. clarke to port ---> NO

a. thomson to tigers ---> NO

j. shulz to st kilda ---> NO

Eastern · Post: # 659803Post **Eastern** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:20pm

degruch wrote:Yes, I think J Shulz would be very happy with that trade!

I thought it was H. Schultz, and that his manager, Klink wanted to trade him to the Russian Front !!

yipper · Post: # 659805Post **yipper** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:21pm

Eastern wrote:
degruch wrote:Yes, I think J Shulz would be very happy with that trade!
I thought it was H. Schultz, and that his manager, Klink wanted to trade him to the Russian Front !!

I know nuthink...nuthink.

st.byron · Post: # 659808Post **st.byron** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:24pm

StNoodles wrote:x. clarke to port

a. thomson to tigers

j. shulz to st kilda

nyet.

degruch · Post: # 659811Post **degruch** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:25pm

Eastern wrote:
degruch wrote:Yes, I think J Shulz would be very happy with that trade!
I thought it was H. Schultz, and that his manager, Klink wanted to trade him to the Russian Front !!

*monacle drops out of eye socket* Easteeerrrrrrnnnnnnnn!

saint66au · Post: # 659812Post **saint66au** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:26pm

Just an aside..

When Schultz arrived at Punt Rd he immediately got the nickname "Sarge"...but had to go ask one of the older people at the Club why LOL

GrumpyOne · Post: # 659813Post **GrumpyOne** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:26pm

FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.

saintsrus · Post: # 659814Post **saintsrus** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:28pm

GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.

Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing

Animal Enclosure · Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:32pm

saintsrus wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing

Spot on. X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

Let Misson & co work their wonders & everyone will remember why X was taken at no 5 in the super draft.

BTW Schultz is a spud of the highest order. Struggles to get a game at the Tigers when they are desperate for tall forwards!

mightysainters · Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:34pm

I'm not a big fan of X... but Shulz? Tell him he's dreaming...

mightysainters · Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:35pm

Animal Enclosure wrote:
saintsrus wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing
Spot on. X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

Let Misson & co work their wonders & everyone will remember why X was taken at no 5 in the super draft.

BTW Schultz is a spud of the highest order. Struggles to get a game at the Tigers when they are desperate for tall forwards!

And the word was that Raph was always the most talented out of the brothers Raph would have gone top 5 if he had a good Under 18's championships but struggled with injury...

Eastern · Post: # 659821Post **Eastern** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:38pm

mightysainters wrote:
Animal Enclosure wrote:
saintsrus wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing
Spot on. X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

Let Misson & co work their wonders & everyone will remember why X was taken at no 5 in the super draft.

BTW Schultz is a spud of the highest order. Struggles to get a game at the Tigers when they are desperate for tall forwards!
And the word was that Raph was always the most talented out of the brothers Raph would have gone top 5 if he had a good Under 18's championships but struggled with injury...

I think it was Michael Maclean who said that Raph would end up being the most talented footballer EVER to come out of NT. The list includes McLoed, Rioli x 3, Motlop x 3 or 4, Brennan.

Lets hope that Raph proves this prediction to be 100% CORRECT !!

Sobraz · Post: # 659830Post **Sobraz** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 2:56pm

GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.

This is a massive call....

IMO if a favourable trade comes up, X is out most expendable player of (semi) quality.... Unlike our other forum whipping boys Dal and Kosi, X has never, ever dominated in a game, or had a great year...

He has shown abit in small doses... I dont think he'd be worth much on the open market...

As for Schultz, not sure whats worse... A player that never plays (X), or an AFL player with a reserves attitude (schultz)...

St Chris · Post: # 659832Post **St Chris** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 3:02pm

mightysainters wrote:
Animal Enclosure wrote:
saintsrus wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing
Spot on. X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

Let Misson & co work their wonders & everyone will remember why X was taken at no 5 in the super draft.

BTW Schultz is a spud of the highest order. Struggles to get a game at the Tigers when they are desperate for tall forwards!
And the word was that Raph was always the most talented out of the brothers Raph would have gone top 5 if he had a good Under 18's championships but struggled with injury...

Raph got himself reported and suspended in the Under 18 comp to fly under the radar and last until St Kilda's first pick (Pick 8), because the experts had him rated higher than that. Always wanted to come to the Saints to play with X

GrumpyOne · Post: # 659834Post **GrumpyOne** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 3:08pm

Sobraz wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
This is a massive call....

IMO if a favourable trade comes up, X is out most expendable player of (semi) quality.... Unlike our other forum whipping boys Dal and Kosi, X has never, ever dominated in a game, or had a great year...

A massive call perhaps, but one I am prepared to back all the way.

X has all the skills, the pace we need in midfield, never shirks a contest, and brings the unpredictability that aboriginal players have that can punch a hole through most defences.

Don't judge him over the last two years where he was hampered by niggling injuries. Now that a professional approach has been taken in our injury management area, and a program put in place to manage his body, I am completely confident that we will see the skills and attributes that earnt him Burkie's old jumper.

mightysainters · Tue 07 Oct 2008 3:22pm

St Chris wrote:
mightysainters wrote:
Animal Enclosure wrote:
saintsrus wrote:
GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.
Agree there, let the medical staff do their thing
Spot on. X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

Let Misson & co work their wonders & everyone will remember why X was taken at no 5 in the super draft.

BTW Schultz is a spud of the highest order. Struggles to get a game at the Tigers when they are desperate for tall forwards!
And the word was that Raph was always the most talented out of the brothers Raph would have gone top 5 if he had a good Under 18's championships but struggled with injury...
Raph got himself reported and suspended in the Under 18 comp to fly under the radar and last until St Kilda's first pick (Pick 8), because the experts had him rated higher than that. Always wanted to come to the Saints to play with X

Played and got injured i think.... That was the conspiracy theory think he was a bit overrated and was shown up in quality standard of football in the championships....

saintjake · Post: # 659872Post **saintjake** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 4:17pm

GrumpyOne wrote:FFS guys, trading X would be the silliest thing we have done in the last ten years.

Will be a superstar in 09.

we have been saying that for ages,
and body still breaks down..

Saints94 · Post: # 659874Post **Saints94** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 4:25pm

I'd think i would prefer Thompson

bigcarl · Post: # 659875Post **bigcarl** » Tue 07 Oct 2008 4:26pm

Animal Enclosure wrote:X was always the more talented of the Clarke boys & we've seen indications of what Raph is capable of.

wasn't raph regarded as the more talented junior?

in any case, they are both potentially very good players. x just needs some luck with injury.

too many on here are judging him on one game when he was bought back for a final without a real solid match fitness base.

3-way trade- would we be happy with...

3-way trade- would we be happy with...

Re: 3-way trade- would we be happy with...