Should St kilda make a play for Jonathon Brown?

Ros Lyon · Post: # 612132Post **Ros Lyon** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:28pm

Imagine him at full forward, Kosi at CHF and Rooey roaming around. Would our first and second round pick satisfy Brisbane?

Discuss.

Saints in 20?? · Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:33pm

why bother discussing something so stupid?

Ros Lyon · Post: # 612137Post **Ros Lyon** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:34pm

It's not stupid, there is a chance he wants toi come home.

St DAC · Post: # 612138Post **St DAC** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:34pm

Don't feed the troll.

Ros Lyon · Post: # 612139Post **Ros Lyon** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:36pm

St DAC wrote:Don't feed the troll.

For crying out loud, stop calling me a troll. The moderator has unlocked my profile because I am not a troll.

JeffDunne · Post: # 612140Post **JeffDunne** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:40pm

If Brisbane would take our 1st & 2nd pick and we can fit him in the cap without too much damage, why wouldn't you?

Ros Lyon · Post: # 612141Post **Ros Lyon** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:42pm

JeffDunne wrote:If Brisbane would take our 1st & 2nd pick and we can fit him in the cap without too much damage, why wouldn't you?

That would be picks 10 and 25 approximately. How old is he?

ausfatcat · Post: # 612142Post **ausfatcat** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 12:47pm

and don't forget injury prone

BAM! (shhhh) · Wed 30 Jul 2008 1:21pm

The team that gets the best palyer wins the trade. If picks 10 & 25 amount to Jonathan Brown's bootlaces at any age, you've done well.

Of course you do it. If Brown decides to move, Brisbane will get a lot more in return than that. They'll push for a top 5 pick for starters, if you don't have one go out and trade for it - someone will. Then add either another first + player/another pick or 2nd and upcoming player.

Brown's 26 (27 in oct) and has plenty of good footy ahead. The model for any Brown trade would be the Judd trade.

Besides which, I can't really see Brown moving.

Ralphy · Post: # 612161Post **Ralphy** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 1:31pm

he wont leave brisbane so NO
we should be going for fevola.

The Saintsational Man · Wed 30 Jul 2008 1:42pm

JB is as pure a match winner as they get.

Could win a game of his own boot with ease.

We'll never see him in saints colours though.

He'd go to a powerhouse club;

Collingwood, Essendon, Carlton ect.

WayneJudson42 · Wed 30 Jul 2008 1:50pm

I'd chase Fev instead.

St DAC · Post: # 612179Post **St DAC** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 2:48pm

Ros Lyon wrote:For crying out loud, stop calling me a troll. The moderator has unlocked my profile because I am not a troll.

If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...

skeptic · Post: # 612182Post **skeptic** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 2:55pm

St DAC wrote:
If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...

what does it taste like?

The Saintsational Man · Wed 30 Jul 2008 2:56pm

skeptic wrote:
St DAC wrote:
If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...
what does it taste like?

Are you asian?

St DAC · Post: # 612195Post **St DAC** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 3:45pm

skeptic wrote:what does it taste like?

Why do you think I left that part out?

st.byron · Post: # 612196Post **st.byron** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 3:48pm

Ros Lyon wrote:Imagine him at full forward, Kosi at CHF and Rooey roaming around. Would our first and second round pick satisfy Brisbane?

Discuss.

If it were possible and it's a big if, still no.
We need to be investing in kids for the future, not short term fixes on risky players. We've had enough of that.

plugger66 · Post: # 612198Post **plugger66** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 3:53pm

Im more interested in Franklin. Apparently unhappy at the hawks.

WayneJudson42 · Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:04pm

Great! Another power forward who can't kick straight

4ever_saint · Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:05pm

Im more interested in Franklin. Apparently unhappy at the hawks.

source?

if he really was unhappy at the hawks, would there be any chance of him coming to st kilda? would we be willing to make a play for him?

stinger · Post: # 612212Post **stinger** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:17pm

Ros Lyon wrote:Imagine him at full forward, Kosi at CHF and Rooey roaming around. Would our first and second round pick satisfy Brisbane?

Discuss.

f*** off troll......

stinger · Post: # 612213Post **stinger** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:19pm

St DAC wrote:
Ros Lyon wrote:For crying out loud, stop calling me a troll. The moderator has unlocked my profile because I am not a troll.
If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...

and this troll is a real turd.....

St DAC · Post: # 612214Post **St DAC** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:19pm

4ever_saint wrote:
Im more interested in Franklin. Apparently unhappy at the hawks.
source?

if he really was unhappy at the hawks, would there be any chance of him coming to st kilda? would we be willing to make a play for him?

I think Plugger's tongue was firmly planted in his cheek ...

stinger · Post: # 612215Post **stinger** » Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:23pm

plugger66 wrote:Im more interested in Franklin. Apparently unhappy at the hawks.

no sh!t sherlock....

The Saintsational Man · Wed 30 Jul 2008 4:38pm

stinger wrote:
St DAC wrote:
Ros Lyon wrote:For crying out loud, stop calling me a troll. The moderator has unlocked my profile because I am not a troll.
If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...

and this troll is a real turd.....

Maybe we need a new system for new members on this forum.

Say 100 posts before they can start a post.

Would leave those who are not true saints fans with an uphill climb to start "trolling" threads and those who do make 100 posts and then start trolling, well that just in itself would be so sad, it's almost funny.

Should St kilda make a play for Jonathon Brown?

Should St kilda make a play for Jonathon Brown?

Re: Should St kilda make a play for Jonathon Brown?

Re: Should St kilda make a play for Jonathon Brown?